Open 720: NOIR (GAME OVER)

[jjh927]

Hider should 100% reveal. I'm on the hider reveal train. 2 innos and a conftown vs nothing at all from not revealing

[Oxy]

That's pretty much where I'm at.

Unless someone has a good reason for the hider not to out, I think they should.

[Alonzo]

Wait so no kill says that scum either no-killed or they targeted the hider with their kill. The only reason to no-kill is to setup the hider to out themselves by thinking that scum now know who they are.

So either scum know who the hider is and we may as well get the info now. Or scum just submitted no-kill to make us think that and get the hider out in the open.

How does the Hider Survive the nightkill?

[jjh927]

By hiding behind town

[jjh927]

Abilities:

Hide: Every night, you may target a player to hide behind them. If your target is a member of the mafia or the Vigilante, you will die. If your target dies that night, you will die.

On nights that you hide, you will be immune to mafia and Vigilante kills.

[Sando]

Unless someone has a good reason for the hider not to out, I think they should.

The only advantage that is popping up in my mind is that leaving the hider alive without directing their hide leaves the scum forced to "waste" their jail on them, plus if they fail to jail them then we know scum was lying. I'm not seeing any reason not to have the hider out in that, but then I've only thought about this for 5 mins, and I don't need hider info absolutely now, so I think we wait a little bit before doing it, doesn't cost us anything.

[Oxy]

Yeah, I see no reason not to give people 24 hours to think about it

[pinturicchio]

Mr. blue sky, please tell us why, you had to

hide

away for so long (so long!)

[jjh927]

Oh neat Pintu hider then?

[Oxy]

Mr. blue sky, please tell us why, you had to

hide

away for so long (so long!)

It was a great crumb.

I lowkey wanted to grumble about your song choice for me, but i didn't want to bring attention to the post.

who are our confirmed towns? alonso and?

[jjh927]

It's a worthless crumb if he didn't state any targets

[pinturicchio]

Want to here something funny? Scum thought I was the vig because they jailkept me on N1 and only the worst died. Wanna know why I know I was jailkept? I hid behind the worst scum saved my life on N1 and tried to kill me on N2! But I'm a smarty pants and knew they were trying to do that; that's why I scumread everyone who was trying to push me on D2 'cause they were looking for my claim... aka mutant.

Btw, I hid behind Oxy, so start following him and me on this game, please?

VOTE: mutantdevle

[pinturicchio]

It's a worthless crumb if he didn't state any targets

See above

[Oxy]

oh shit.
i read your post, "yes, yes, yes, alonzo is town" as you softing your hide result

[jjh927]

Yeah sure mutant can replace you in the 3 people I think are scum. I'd still rather do Not_Mafia today but aside from maybe the Havingfitz slot I'm confident everyone who isn't in my scumreads is town

VOTE: mutant

[jjh927]

You're supposed to crumb hider targets, not results

[Oxy]

well, it was also pin's first vote of the game, so I kind of added the two, i dunno

[pinturicchio]

You're supposed to crumb hider targets, not results

Didn't want to do that since I knew scum thought I was the vig so I wanted to play as "frustrated vig who couldn't get his kill done and probably dead on N2".

Oh and by the way, scum probably knows who the real vig is now since no one died today, so they must've jailkept him/her

[jjh927]

Btw that CJ lynch was bad play and you should be ashamed

[Alonzo]

Good times.

I'm gonna retire to bed, and think about who to dynamite, and who to laser beam.

@JJ the Cj Lynch was a fine town lynch.

[Sando]

Oh and by the way, scum probably knows who the real vig is now since no one died today, so they must've jailkept him/her

Or they chose tracker.

[Oxy]

Ugh, Pin, now I feel an additional responsibility to play this game well, and I'm not too confident in my reads these days.

I'll go back and read mutant's iso tomorrow with a fresh eye, and see where that takes me.

p.edit last pr is tracker, almost certainly, no?

[pinturicchio]

Agreed. CJ was playing shit, but mutant and probably Not_Mafia are scum on that wagon

[jjh927]

Shouldn't rule out tracker but I can't imagine not taking vig with fuckin NM in the game

[pinturicchio]

Oh and by the way, scum probably knows who the real vig is now since no one died today, so they must've jailkept him/her

Or they chose tracker.

Oooooh I forgot that decision could be made! Yeah that's much more likely, duh.