In post 27, Ranmaru wrote:I don't feel what you are feeling on Alisae at the moment. Can you quote which post feels off to you?
In post 88, Ranmaru wrote:Mastina
: Did you catch up before voting Alisae? How did you make that mistake? Go through your thought process as you made that post.
In post 108, Ranmaru wrote:If Alisae flips town, I'd consider two scum within [Mastina, MariaR, Lycanfire]. If Alisae flips scum, I'd consider one of [Mastina, MariaR].
In post 129, Ranmaru wrote:TOWN [ Ranmaru] NULL [Errant > Unah > Chamber > MariaR ] [Cheeky > Mastina] SCUM
Today, we will be lynching Mastina. She is scum, and has effectively traded a D1 mislynch to hurt the effectiveness of town, and she has. Now we have to find her buddy when there is little information to implicate a buddy to her strongly. I want townies to step up and town up as soon as possible so we can salvage the damage done by Mastina. In my mind right now, Cheeky is her most likely scum buddy.
Hmmm. A fair bit of evidence here points to Ranmaru scum. In general here are the reasons I scum read him.
1. He was awkward af on entering D1 and his lines of questionning continue to look forced.
2. The quicklynch going through as easy as it did says to me that scum are likely to have stayed off the wagon. Ranmaru felt disingenuous in pushing me for my alisae gut read saying "I don't see how she's scum" which is alarming given that most other players were pinged by her. The whole stance felt like white knighting.
3. Near EOD more forced questionning around whether mastina was genuine or not in her derphammer.
4. Trying to create associations that make no sense near day end based on close to zero information.
5. Ranmaru jumping to the conclusion that mastina is scum SOD2 prior to other people entering who could have potentially more information.
6. Ranmaru completely abandoning his reads from D1 in favour of a lynch on me with very poor reasoning.
I know that Ranmaru by nature is a tryhard but I don't feel a genuineness to his pushes or lines of questionning at all this game and his depth of thought is lacking in comparison to his town game. I have witnessed how bad his reads are in general and how he tends to tunnel people who are town so I am not 100% confident in this read, more like 70% which is enough for me to go off today.
I'm waiting to see others opinions on the mastina debacle.
