Open 723: Purgatory! (Hell Phase 3)

[RC most awesomest]

Okay Oxy is scum

[Oxy]

Yeah, you're clearly great at this game ;P

lolol

RC in this thread:

[RC most awesomest]

Also I know what I'm doing

please stop gross appeal to authority.

This approach to my slot doesn't make much sense at all, simply saying that I know what I'm doing when I immediately deduced what Oxy needed 5 posts to get to is pretty reasonable.
It also doesn't respond particularly well to anything that I've done this game, at no point have I appeal to authoritied on any sort of reasoning besides something Oxy didn't even contest besides to say that I didn't know that 'for sure', which I even conceded. Accusing me of appeal to authoritying doesn't come from someone who doesn't generally know who I am.

Oxy shouldn't have me on their radar: I've been gone for 3 months then was only back for like a few months before then. Someone told them about me in scum PT.

Also in general I don't think it's ever the town approach to react to my townread on him (which I immediately 180ed ftr) by calling it bad and arguing that I couldn't have known it was a town thought process. Calling it scummy and being suspicious of it maybe, but what town calls townreads on them bad?

Yeah, you're clearly great at this game ;P

lolol

RC in this thread:

Again: how does this make sense as a town response to anything that I've done this game?

[RC most awesomest]

I established and confirmed that this was a newbie slot ftr, this isn't an alt. That level of familiarity didn't come from nowhere.

[Oxy]

What are you even talking about?

You've made numerous comments that amount to "I'm a good player so if you think I'm making a bad play, you're wrong." which is an appeal to authority to defend your read.

Which isn't scummy (because wtf would it matter), but it is gross to keep crowing about yourself.

As to knowing you/not knowing you - I've come across you while reading different parts of this site. From that reading, I know that you like to post a lot, and that a number of people really dislike you. That's about it.

[Oxy]

I established and confirmed that this was a newbie slot ftr

Does this imply that you have read my iso from any game of mine, completed or otherwise?

[RC most awesomest]

Who are these 'a number of people'

And yes if you disagree with that read you're wrong because it's a pretty strong read: contingent on the premise being true which we've now established it wasn't, it was just general scum tendency to think they need to overreact to and overly question townreads on them to seem towny: which isn't true at all by the way, as scum you shouldn't react to townreads unless you do as town as well.

Does this imply that you have read my iso from any game of mine, completed or otherwise?

I had already read PYP and 1859 because NSG was in them so yes.

[Oxy]

Who are these 'a number of people'

I don't know. I read the threads surrounding the geriatric rule set a while back. You weren't exactly loved.

And yes if you disagree with that read you're wrong because it's a pretty strong read: contingent on the premise being true which we've now established it wasn't, it was just general scum tendency to think they need to overreact to and overly question townreads on them to seem towny: which isn't true at all by the way, as scum you shouldn't react to townreads unless you do as town as well.

Does this imply that you have read my iso from any game of mine, completed or otherwise?

I had already read PYP and 1859 because NSG was in them so yes.

Then why do you think that I don't call town reads on me bad when town?

[RC most awesomest]

I don't know. I read the threads surrounding the geriatric rule set a while back. You weren't exactly loved.

I mean, me coming in and telling them you can't force every game ever to play under that ruleset wasn't loved by like Shea.
You realize that I was the first person to mod a serious post restricted game and that I invented the ruleset that geriatric games are played under, correct?

[Oxy]

You realize that I was the first person to mod a serious post restricted game and that I invented the ruleset that geriatric games are played under, correct?

I don't realize that. Others opinions of you aren't really relevant to this game, anyway. I just wanted to give you a proper context for my understanding of you.

[Oxy]

if you disagree with that read you're wrong because it's a pretty strong read: contingent on the premise being true which we've now established it wasn't

If you are reading my posts, you'll know that my entire disagreement was based on you not knowing whether that premise was sound or not.

[RC most awesomest]

I mean tif hat's true I immediately, before you even responded to it, moved on to saying that it was a hasty townread so what point were you trying to make?

[Oxy]

Ehh i think I read too much into oxy

At that point, this was all you had said about the town read.

I was looking to flesh out your thought process, and it worked.

[Oxy]

Then why do you think that I don't call town reads on me bad when town?

Let's go back to this, though. It's more important.

[RC most awesomest]

I have 0 recollection of you doing this in your past games but I wasn't necessarily close reading your posts in them. I'm not really in the mood to meta dive you right now.

VOTE: Uglyduck

super gut scumread 64

[teacher]

Confirmed (and not reading) v/la through tomorrow. Happy Mother’s Day for those to whom it applies.

[Invisibility]

Lastly - with only VT and Goons, is there any claim options people are aware of? I am excited to play the game but I am at a loss regarding like.... how to approach it.

I had a nice plan to claim vanilla villager on day 1 if I rolled scum

Now I'm not quite sure what to do

I don't like this post

also Oxy vs RC is not SvS

[Invisibility]

Also in general I don't think it's ever the town approach to react to my townread on him (which I immediately 180ed ftr) by calling it bad and arguing that I couldn't have known it was a town thought process. Calling it scummy and being suspicious of it maybe, but what town calls townreads on them bad?

This post is bad. It isn't scummy to call townreads on yourself bad because a bad read is a bad read. (i'm not saying Oxy is town. i'll have to reread thread to get a better grasp of stuff. Oxy and RC were very wordy)

[UglyDuck]

Lastly - with only VT and Goons, is there any claim options people are aware of? I am excited to play the game but I am at a loss regarding like.... how to approach it.

I had a nice plan to claim vanilla villager on day 1 if I rolled scum

Now I'm not quite sure what to do

I don't like this post

also Oxy vs RC is not SvS

I mean... it could be SvS - seems like literally the exact set up of a game in which SvS interactions like this would happen.

[ruru]

Town Mason: N_M, NSG
Town: Oxy
Not a mason: RC
Not town: UD

[RC most awesomest]

Well that vote wasn't from NSG ;P

oxy, what would make you say that i wouldn't be voting you at that point?

also, what's your read on ruru right now?

Also in general I don't think it's ever the town approach to react to my townread on him (which I immediately 180ed ftr) by calling it bad and arguing that I couldn't have known it was a town thought process. Calling it scummy and being suspicious of it maybe, but what town calls townreads on them bad?

This post is bad. It isn't scummy to call townreads on yourself bad because a bad read is a bad read. (i'm not saying Oxy is town. i'll have to reread thread to get a better grasp of stuff. Oxy and RC were very wordy)

not speaking about oxy specifically here, but just in general i find scum question townreads on them to look towny more often than town actually do.


-nsg

[Maruchan]

Role PMs are out. Game starts when 8/9 have confirmed. You have 48 hours. (expired on 2018-05-14 19:30:00)

8/9 Confirmed. Hell Phase 1 begins. You may begin voting for your candidate for HELL. Deadline for a lynch is (expired on 2018-05-20 16:00:00). If a lynch isn't reached, compulsive plurality lynch takes place. Have fun everybody!

Hell Phase 1 Vote Count:
Invisibility - 0 -
teacher - 0 -
Oxy - 0 -
RC most awesomest - 0 -
Alchemist21 - 0 -
UglyDuck - 0 -
Not_Mafia - 0 -
AP - 0 -
ruru - 0 -

Not Voting: Invisibility, teacher, Oxy, RC most awesomes, Alchemist21, UglyDuck, Not_Mafia, AP, ruru

[RC most awesomest]

Also in general I don't think it's ever the town approach to react to my townread on him (which I immediately 180ed ftr) by calling it bad and arguing that I couldn't have known it was a town thought process. Calling it scummy and being suspicious of it maybe, but what town calls townreads on them bad?

This post is bad. It isn't scummy to call townreads on yourself bad because a bad read is a bad read. (i'm not saying Oxy is town. i'll have to reread thread to get a better grasp of stuff. Oxy and RC were very wordy)

if you disagree with me then the chances are pretty damn good that I know something that you don't know as opposed to vice versa.
scum spend a lot more time sorting out townreads on themselves than town do generally

[ruru]

I don't like this post

also Oxy vs RC is not SvS

What's your role?

[ruru]

VOTE: UglyDuck