Reads I was going to post yesterday:
Cheeky is genuine with her scum hunting and is present.
#304 and
#307 are her best posts so far. Not that she's correct, but it helps me read her alignment. (Although I thought she was correct at the time, it makes sense with a town mindset)
#460 and
#506 are also good posts. I agree with her Una mindset, only because I don't think Una is scum anymore, his recent post seemed townie. Cheeky is my top town read.
Una's original posts seemed shaky. He came off as too scummy to be scum, in that he was drawing attention to himself when he need not say such things as mafia. His wall post on Maria seemed alright, and I feel his reaction to Maria's response was townie. I also do think him stating he was waiting to use a computer so that he would not phone post as much due to quality standards is fair because I've seen other less experienced players state the same.
Mastina I'm betting is town here. More so through Process of Elimination. I think it's likely that her hammer may have been a mistake, and I'm not liking how easy her lynch is right now.
Chamber I keep flip flopping on. I felt a lot of his actions were scum motivated, yet I do note that he has been present. His interaction between him and Maria also makes me reconsider my scum read on him. His pushes seem bad, yet he is still scumhunting in spite of my dislike of him.
Errant hasn't really been paying enough attention to actually determine alignment. I do believe he's been playing in a way to remain an enigma on purpose.
#386 feels like a poke at me for the purpose of undermining my slot's credibility, rather then determining my alignment, as seen here:
#437 and
#477 He seems to see me as a big presence, yet also seems to forget that I have re-evaluated on more than one person, and more than once. This goes back to his
#296 where he uses Chamber's argument that I was pushing him in bad faith, so that [Errant] can try to topple my credibility, instead of determine my alignment, which he doesn't really have a good hold of. Finally, his vote on Mastina seemed to be quick, lazy, and comes without any thought.
#504 He also uses the justification that 'he's exhausted with the game'. That is not a good reason to vote Mastina. There's currently wagons on Mastina and Maria, he town reads Mastina but doesn't feel good about myself or Maria, yet he joins Mastina over Maria. He said he had Mastina as town, but as the day progressed, his read has become vague, so he could inch his way onto her wagon.
Maria, Maria, my dear Maria. As I said earlier, Chamber's interaction with Maria, made me reconsider my read on her. Chamber's
#485 made me look at Maria again. I think Chamber's
#419 is a good point. I also looked to see if she mentioned anything about League besides when she was pushed, as I have argued, and I did not see it anywhere else, which made me doubt my read on her. Also, her league game didn't go for very long, which was also odd. (Unless she's playing a mode that is shorter then 30 minutes) Her
#316 is weird because I strongly town read Cheeky, but it feels like she's been trying to put Cheeky to null to try to influence my control of the game.
#424 I don't get Maria's insistence that Chamber is town here, it feels like she's sticking to Una/Mastina when I don't think that is the best play or the most accurate path. I may be wrong on Chamber but I'm trying to make sure we have the most accurate read on scum, Maria isn't. This happened ever since I claimed the neighborhood.
=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic. ... 162763]#72 Finally, her 72 came after Errant's vote on Ali, and not before. That was very odd, if she sees the wagon building on Ali, naturally she would join when she gets there. It seemed a bit un-organic.
#477 is the most suspicious to me because she's admitting that her play is different here, and townreads Chamber for it in hopes that he would think she's not scum for it. I think Maria scum read me for that in The Thing Mafia, where I townread her.