Open 724 - Pick Your Power X/Y [Endgame]

[Iconeum]

And just how likely do you think it is that janitor flips RB? All the way on 7th or something in draft position?

Agreed on janitor in any case

[Iconeum]

VOTE: janitor

[Ircher]

So, scum is janitor, davesav, SIMYK. I can understand if you guys think I fit in that list (at least in davesav spot). If you think i fit into that list in another spot we need to talk.

If you think I'm scum but still agree with janitor and SIMYIK, consider me a vote on either on those 2 you can use.

This is what we need to be discussing, however. The bad/not bad discussion is much less important.

Janitor, Davesaz, and me would all have been good N1 cop targets.

Pedit: I’m not lynching SIMYK today; that’s not even question. That said, maybe 40%? 55% if you are town.

[Iconeum]

Spoiler: Iconeum's earlier scumread on janitor (please read if you need more convincing)

VOTE: janitor

So now ur fencing on both Math and Saske

Hey how lovely you posted the first 5 pages overnight

Hmm I'm unsure of SIMYK being town this early? Wouldn't reasoning around the draft be WIFOM territory?

Shading SIMYK here, based on using WIFOM. Almost everyone who posted at this time is 'guilty' of this. So why SIMYK?

Definitely agree that SIMYK has been contributing a lot and none of it seems like bad or too fluffy soooo she would be far from a scumread

But still the draft seems like wifom territory.

'I don't townread SIMYK because WIMOM, but it's for from scummy!' hedging

how is anything that you've posted useful to the gamestate then

I asked you a question about something that bothers me. Seems like part of a game to me honestly.

@SIMYK
The game is barely underway so I'm not really having a read on anyone. Sure scum could interact a lot but I'd imagine they're more comfortable in the shadows than here. But that again is also wifom-y which is why I'm slow in forming reads.

Not having a read? You made it clear you don't townread SIMYK, which is a read per definition.

okay SO

if BEEFSTER’S flight or fight reactions were TRIGGERED because of Mathdino’s post, wouldn’t he ALSO instinctually HIDE his claim instead of BROADCAST to everyone that he is the scum jailkeeper?

Sure I am not INTIMATELY FAMILIAR with Beefster’s QUIRKS but I assume a BASELINE where people are not SO bad at scum they risk their tean’s chances their FIRST POST just because they though town WANTED them to claim ( ⚆ _ ⚆ )

Is my baseline INACCURATE for Beefster?

also that dosent answer my question -____- - not knowing Beefster does NOT make the reasoning itself invalid （￣へ￣）

It's certainly possible he'd be more inclined to hide his role but it's not exclusive. But I don't see why town would blurt out their role, either.

@simyk I didn't want to question a NAI thing, I wanted to question something I found weird.

I don't necessarily find Mathdino's actions scummy per second... It just bothered me as a weird way to get a TR. Which isn't all too scummy in itself

Would Beefsters JK claim get him free tho? Could still be a scum Jailkeeper. Or am I too tired to process all that correctly now?

Same as with SIMYK, hedging Math's actions as 'not necesarilly scummy'.

In all a pretty scummy feeling to his ISO so far

@janitor, all your effort went into reacting to NAI-posts (according to yourself). Why did you feel the need to interact with them?

It really makes me feel like you wanna appear active while not having to take a stance, and I scumread you for it.
My vote isn't RVS.

What do you expect us to do with 'weird'? If you say something is not scummy, but not towny, you might as well not say it at all. And spend your time replying to stuff that you CAN form an opinion about.

Only scum would have the motivation to play like that

I just let my thoughts flow on matters that stand out to me. How does that make me scum immediately? What you could do is weigh in on the matter itself. And I'm pretty busy replying to stuff I can form opinions about right now

That's just it though. You didn't say your thoughts on matters that stood out. Exactly the opposite. You were commenting on things that were NAI (thus don't stand out) for you.

I'm not sure u are scum for it. It's a very good place to start though.

[Eddie Cane]

So, scum is janitor, davesav, SIMYK. I can understand if you guys think I fit in that list (at least in davesav spot). If you think i fit into that list in another spot we need to talk.

If you think I'm scum but still agree with janitor and SIMYIK, consider me a vote on either on those 2 you can use.

This is what we need to be discussing, however. The bad/not bad discussion is much less important.

Janitor, Davesaz, and me would all have been good N1 cop targets.

Pedit: I’m not lynching SIMYK today; that’s not even question. That said, maybe 40%? 55% if you are town.

If he was going to fake a roleblock anyways why not claim a "less scummy" target?

[Iconeum]

Town reads on Ircher and Taly.
Weak town lean on Beefster.
Wanna look closely at people on Ircher wagon.
The Janitor possible scum.

If you're paying attention then it's clear from context.
Further details are better left for much later.

It's much later... now.
Explain plz.

[davesaz]

Good, it wasn't a gambit.

What wasn't?

If you're paying attention then it's clear from context.
Further details are better left for much later.

A50 claiming neighbor wasn’t a gambit. I paused briefly before replacing in because A50 is known for fake claims and it was a minor gamble to take the slot because I hate being in the position of explaining that.

[Eddie Cane]

oohhhhhh ya

[yessiree]

SaskeIsMyYaoiKismesis has been prodded.

[Ircher]

I guess we're kinda done for the day?

[Eddie Cane]

VOTE: Janitor

[Ircher]

Intent to hammer by 5:00 PM tomorrow unless people want more time.

[Ircher]

(Well, that's if me voting would be a hammer)

[Iconeum]

Ircher, if janitor flips scum, do you think i'm bussing him?

[Ircher]

Yes.

[Eddie Cane]

yawn

[mutantdevle]

Umm, please don't hammer. I have stuff to do.

Doing what I'm doing takes time; we have 9 days so please give it to me. I'm not going to rush my approach to this game because people want to end the day so soon. I'm prioritising real life because I have some deadlines coming up.

Please take any hammer as extremely sus - especially if I'm the night kill. As that will prove mafia want to silence mechanical solving.

[Ircher]

Okay, fine with me; I was only going to hammer if everyone felt they said what they wanted to say today.

[Ausuka]

This is the first of many prod dodges I will do today and my apathy towards this game will increase as time goes by.

Also I'm totally going to ignore the mechanical solving thing unless it comes to actual solid conclusions which it probably won't.

[yessiree]

VC 3.3

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

The Janitor (4) [L-1]

- Ausuka, Taly, Iconeum, Eddie Cane

Iconeum (1)

- Ircher

Not voting

- mutantdevle, SaskeIsMyYaoiKismesis, davesaz, The Janitor

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2018-06-03 13:00:00)

[yessiree]

The Janitor has been prodded.

[Eddie Cane]

rain drop drop top apathy coming plop plop

[mutantdevle]

This is the first of many prod dodges I will do today and my apathy towards this game will increase as time goes by.

Also I'm totally going to ignore the mechanical solving thing unless it comes to actual solid conclusions which it probably won't.

I plan to come to a solid conclusion, that's why I want the time.

The posts I'm making up until then are just to document my thoughts - both for your benefit but mainly for mine so I can keep track of what I've looked at.

[yessiree]

SaskeIsMyYaoiKismesis is being replaced for failing to pick up his prod.

[Ausuka]

lol