Lynch the Wolves (Game Over)

[RadiantCowbells]

I am going to lynch NSG because she's scum this game and everything who thinks that she isn't is bad and should get better at reading her. Meta is for losers, her ISO is objectively scummy as fuck based off of x criteria because I am godking Wisdom.

VOTE: NSG

[northsidegal]

i would be laughing but i'm still bitter

[RadiantCowbells]

How strongly were you townreading me in our last game?

[TheGoldenParadox]

Amazing idea: policy lynch the 3 headed hydra so we don't have to worry about who the heads are anymore

I've recieved notification that the 3 headed hydra is in fact one player messing with us as part of my Role PM. Has anyone else recieved this indication?

[MathBlade]

Amazing idea: policy lynch the 3 headed hydra so we don't have to worry about who the heads are anymore

I've recieved notification that the 3 headed hydra is in fact one player messing with us as part of my Role PM. Has anyone else recieved this indication?

No.
That would also mean that mastina made a moderator lie in the first few posts making the game bastard.
Mastina would not call a bastard game not bastard.

VOTE: Golden Paradox

This can die.

[MathBlade]

Players

Players

:

1. Luna Nova (
   Anonymous 3-headed hydra
   )
   
2. HeWhoSwims
   
3. Almost50
   
4. Theta Alpine
   
5. Definition
   
6. TheGoldenParadox
   
7. Archwing
   
8. ArcAngel9
   
9. Creature
   
10. CheekyTeeky
    
11. RadiantCowbells
    
12. Vecna
    
13. Mathblade
    
14. Aronis
    
15. hebichan
    
16. Keychain
    
17. northsidegal
    
18. Yuurei

Spoiler: On Reserve (as replacements)

1. Ankamius
   
2. mhsmith0
   
3. Nosferatu

Spoiler: Alive (18)

1. Luna Nova
2. HeWhoSwims
3. Almost50
4. Theta Alpine
5. Definition
6. TheGoldenParadox
7. Archwing
8. ArcAngel9
9. Creature
10. CheekyTeeky
11. RadiantCowbells
12. Vecna
13. Mathblade
14. Aronis
15. hebichan
16. Keychain
17. northsidegal
18. Yuurei

Spoiler: Dead (none)

BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD MOD.

---

Current Gamestate

Status

:

Confirmation Stage

[Yuurei]

i imagine TGP was joking?

VOTE: mathblade

[MathBlade]

i imagine TGP was joking?

VOTE: mathblade

Let’s assume for a moment TGP was joking.

What benefit is there to joking the moderator lied to us outright when people are actively alt hunting? (a practice I despise and will not join) the hydra.

It is a way to comment without commenting and at the same time potential get people to slip if they have a way to get moderator notifications or not.

TGP from prior experience with them is not a joke or a troll user.

So I don’t think that was intended to be a joke.

[MathBlade]

Furthermore when someone is “joking” and could have disastrous consequences on how players hunt and play that “joke” can have rather large consequences if people are lead down the wrong path. A lot of people here on MS use meta and/or emotion tells and if they look for one set instead of three because they believe there is only one head not three that can be disastrous, especially when a majority of the content so far is around the hydra head.

So this “joke” even if it is one probably came from scum.

[Yuurei]

i guess you maybe has a point then?

VOTE: thegoldenparadox

it's not a bad reason for a vote in the begin i suppose...

[Aronis]

I declare that I will declare in the future my intention to declare and declaration of intent to intend to vote on declaring placing my vote on the person I am going to declare later on in this thread.

This post makes no sense. If you could just vote like a sane person, that'd be great

[MathBlade]

I declare that I will declare in the future my intention to declare and declaration of intent to intend to vote on declaring placing my vote on the person I am going to declare later on in this thread.

This post makes no sense. If you could just vote like a sane person, that'd be great

I just kinda ignored it when it still didn’t make sense when I woke up. :/

Aronis what’s your favorite food? (Pulling a page out of the Aronis playbook)

[Vecna]

Good day people. Interesting development, even before the game has officially started already.

Just as a general question; isnt a moderator lie only bastard if they cannot be reasonably anticipated? If they include a role that tells us specifically that another role doesnt work as previously prescribed, would that still make the game bastard, and the moderator lie not anticipable? (is that even a word?)

I have some feeling about the way Mathblade is handling this. I like the criticism, but the way in which it is being done feels like it is taking a few steps too quickly. Agenda driven maybe over "inquiring minds want to know"-driven if that makes sense.

Mathblade, do you really feel there could only be one type of motivation here? Because im getting some tingles that make me feel like youre trying to adhere to your previously built up reputation, and I dont really know if I believe you really feel that - even if this really was a joke - it would have as big consequences for the game as your trying to push here.

[Vecna]

Anyways im reasonably excited about this playerlist, and ill try to be playing this game in a positive and constructive way for once, without digging in too deep into anything and leaving my claws wherever they land.

[Vecna]

Mathblade, im actually hoping im wrong here and youre town. I feel like we owe it to eachother to solve a game together and make it look appealing and clean.

[RadiantCowbells]

@NSG do towny things please

[Vecna]

Hey RC, im happy to note I am already townreading you. Hurray

[RadiantCowbells]

very spicy because I was just making a mental note of the fact that I was pretty sure you and creature were town and I wanted NSG to do things so I could put her there too

[MathBlade]

According to the definition of bastard on MS, things like Miller for a town player or Godfather for scum are reasonably anticipatable.

Having something from signups be announced as 3 players then turning out to be one IMHO wouldn’t.

Varsoon when I was scum in FFT and never could actually post in thread was still advertised as bastard and that another player existed. So this would fall under needing the same declaration. So that hydra certainly has three heads. Which heads I will leave to the alt hunters.

In regards to one type of motivation, that’s why I tried to assume it was a joke. I could not think of a reason why anyone would joke like that have it be good therefore TGP needs to die.

Right now Gork Titus and Katsuki (if memory serves) are suggested as being in the hydra. For this example I am assuming that the slots are those three people but in no way encourage alt hunting/outing. If someone has a meta read of “Titus does X only as scum” and then X happens but it’s actually Gork doing X so the slot is town it could lead to a lot of bad assumptions. Hence why I don’t see town making that “joke”. Do you see another motivation that I am missing?

Pedit I hope we’re both town too and can overcome the past as well.

[TheGoldenParadox]

...
ofc that was a joke lmao
and in the one game I've played wiith you i was hella lurky
please don't claim to know my meta thx

[TheGoldenParadox]

also I'm in a game with creature cheeky rc mathblade and nsg
i feel happy
also mathblade is town that was very obvtown unless i'm the most idiotic human on the planet

[Vecna]

Im just gonna operate under the assumption that TGP's role does in fact state something about the hydra, until he stops claiming as such. There very well might be some avenues that were overlooking where it could be part of the game design, without it being completely bastard.

Edit: ok there we go

[Yuurei]

thegoldenparadox, do you have experience playing with mathblade?

you are calling him "obvtown" very early

[Vecna]

Yeah he is indeed........

Maybe the classic scummove, where you perceive to have been pushed for valid reasons and your hand feels caught in the cooky jar? Hence assigning way too much instant-towncred because you fail to look at it from the other potential reasoning for doing what he did.

[MathBlade]

Furthermore no one should ever be calling me obvTown except for a few certain people who I trust implicitly to read me well and not doing so is a scum tell. Don’t get me wrong I am town, but I have a damn good win rate as scum because I am perceived as town.

Vecna did I do a thing? Are we gonna mind meld this game?