Fallout Mafia - Commonwealth Edition (Day 8)

[Kaede Akamatsu]

I struggle to see why scum jungle would take such a risk that would inevitably lead to his lynch the day after. This is the only thing stopping me wanting a speed lynch on jungle to be honest.

My cop attempt was on Maria, I think Maria is scum but was holding off for my results but since that never happened

VOTE: Maria

They have no reason to lie, even as scum. If they say they did visit and you're lynched as town, they are confirmed scum. Which isn't a good trade off.

eh fair it was matt

Matt can you confirm that you didn't visit anyone last night?

[davesaz]

This is everything I brought up against davesaz.

He has answered but a small fraction of them.

The things that you think are low probability are things that I think are high probability because they would be low probability

if there were no liars or curveballs

. Mafia is a game of liars and curveballs, in which ordinarily low probability things are the most likely.

I just got finished with a game in which 2 of the scum were the most universally townread people in the game.
Why did scum win that one?

Because we all thought they were low probability.

This is my full and complete answer on why we disagree. Kindly stop trying to make it seem like I'm dodging.

[Alchemist21]

I’d stills be scumreading OTM if everyone who knows them better weren’t saying this is just them being them. The straight up refusal to see clearly laid out logic just reeks of scum trying to force a specific narrative no matter what.

And full disclosure on the party starter, the wording says it

ignores

any roleblock or redirect attempt, so it sounds like even one that resolves first by NAR would be bypassed by the Party Starter.

Right now the only mechanical reason to think OTM is Town is that Wilky said they got blocked after OTM claimed to have blocked Dave, which implies the existence of a second, scum-sided roleblocker.

[Ankamius]

It's true though, this is honestly one of the less extreme games I've seen from him.

[projectmatt]

alright, my hand is forced, i guess.

my flavor is piper. i'm an odd night rolecop. my pm specifies that i can investigate on every other night, starting on n1.

nero cain did not submit an action on night one. (i've been trying to figure out why, tbh.)

i was unable to investigate tonight.

assuming i'm not lynched today, i am going to investigate tonight within impossibear's scumpool.

[Ankamius]

hm

I'm actually not sure how to take that claim

[Kokichi Oma]

What a twist!

[projectmatt]

can we lynch the mafia yet

[Ankamius]

don't look to me

I'm here to look pretty

[Ankamius]

Actually, the way this is going to work is that we will have another three day phases of me lurking around, then immediately solving the game after everyone competent dies

Then I can pretend I did something this game

Sounds like a good plan to me!

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Ramcius

[EspeciallyTheLies]

alright, my hand is forced, i guess.

my flavor is piper. i'm an odd night rolecop. my pm specifies that i can investigate on every other night, starting on n1.

nero cain did not submit an action on night one. (i've been trying to figure out why, tbh.)

i was unable to investigate tonight.

assuming i'm not lynched today, i am going to investigate tonight within impossibear's scumpool.

this sounds like lies. probably a scum role cop. definitely not piper

[Kaede Akamatsu]

Just a fyi, if we're not lynching matt because you believe that claim i wanna lynch dave.

[Ankamius]

I still think he's town, so I want to give him a chance to at least give us

something

, then judge based on that.

Davesaz is a good wagon.

[OnTheMark]

Prod dodge will read at some point

[Kokichi Oma]

VOTE: dave

A day late but sure

[Kaede Akamatsu]

Weeeeeell ETL says they are lying and that they are definitely not piper.
But im not sure how much I can trust that, considering the way GIF designs flavor and roles.

[Ankamius]

VOTE: davesaz

[Kaede Akamatsu]

VOTE: dave
Ok that's an answer i guess.

[Ankamius]

I still think he's town, so I want to give him a chance to at least give us

something

, then judge based on that.

Davesaz is a good wagon.

basically my entire thoughts on it right here

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Weeeeeell ETL says they are lying and that they are definitely not piper.
But im not sure how much I can trust that, considering the way GIF designs flavor and roles.

to be clear... i'm not CCing his flavor. I just don't believe him.

[davesaz]

Don't be stupid, if you mislynch me you lost the opportunity to mechanically determine Maria.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Don't be stupid, if you mislynch me you lost the opportunity to mechanically determine Maria.

I agree with this logic, but I disagree with the delivery.

That's not like you, Dave.

[davesaz]

You're on the wrong account, and I've been awake for maybe 10 minutes?
But I'm not sure why you think it isn't like me.

[Impossibear]

Spoiler: slips

alright, my hand is forced, i guess.

my flavor is piper. i'm an odd night rolecop. my pm specifies that i can investigate on every other night, starting on n1.

nero cain did not submit an action on night one. (i've been trying to figure out why, tbh.)

i was unable to investigate tonight.

assuming i'm not lynched today, i am going to investigate tonight within impossibear's scumpool.

this sounds like lies. probably a scum role cop. definitely not piper

Weeeeeell ETL says they are lying and that they are definitely not piper.
But im not sure how much I can trust that, considering the way GIF designs flavor and roles.

to be clear... i'm not CCing his flavor. I just don't believe him.

Don't be stupid, if you mislynch me you lost the opportunity to mechanically determine Maria.

I agree with this logic, but I disagree with the delivery.

That's not like you, Dave.

You're on the wrong account, and I've been awake for maybe 10 minutes?
But I'm not sure why you think it isn't like me.

You're not usually mean.

ETL