Responding to the rest of Stanley's points:
1. Regarding your read on UnaBombah, I didn't like you asking him whether he gets lynched a lot because if he said that he didn't, you would have used that as a reason to suspect him. But just because his normal playstyle doen't lead to him being lynched doesn't mean he's scum here. Perhaps other people don't find his playstyle or the type of phrases he uses to be particularly scummy. He wasn't wagoned here because he was cocky or patronising or told us we'd be able to make an educated decision. He got wagoned because Lefty and Ircher made a hard push on him and people agreed with them. If Lefty/Ircher weren't in the game, odds are UnaBomBaH may not have been wagoned. So, it feels like you are making a few logical leaps here.
2. You acknowledge that you townreading Draynth was flawed. You said Draynth was town because he argued that he wasn't going to keep his vote on someone at all times instead of just doing what UnaBombah told him to and voting someone. I have trouble believing that you genuinely believed this argument when you were so easily persuaded otherwise. In fact, in your previous scumgame, your partner MathDino pointed out to you multiple times in the scum PT that a lot of what he said in thread were his real thoughts. You know that scum don't normally lie about theory points because it's something that can easily be checked from game to game. That's also a pretty weak reason to townread Draynth that you continued using all the way until
286 when there was much more content to go on.
3. As to the other reasons you now gave for townreading Draynth: I don't think his readslist in
206 was good at all. I don't see why you are townreading him for his read on Una which is basically "Una is scummy but I don't know why" and sheeping Ircher. I don't see
88 as something scum would be unlikely to make. In fact, if scum see that someone is reading up on their games, they would be curious to know which games are being read so they know what town is looking for when reading them. I can see town also asking that question of course but I consider it null and not a towntell. Also, I don't think Draynth put you at risk of being lynched by saying that he was paranoid of you truthfully claiming mafia goon in your first post. That's moonlogic and isn't actually going to get anyone to agree with him.
4. You wanted comments on your reads on OIAM and Ircher. I'm very confident Ircher is town. The way he deconstructed people's posts, the amount of effort he went through and the fact that all of his conclusions are reasonable and things I can easily follow and understand and mostly agree with points to him being town. It's one of those reads I'm happy to put the game on the line for. OIAM is bit more hazy. Sometimes I don't understand or agree with his thought process and reading him has been much more of a struggle. I do understand his vote on you because he's been scumreading you since your little one on one argument so I expect he'd jump on a wagon of you if one got started. I think the LAL argument is kind of a stretch but that seems typical for him so I'm giving him a bit of latitude. It's possible I'm wrong on this read though and if you or anyone sees his posts differently, I'm happy to discuss more.
