Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[armlx]

Too lazy to find games now, but have you heard of the stereotype of the poisoned punch bowl?

[Battle Mage]

Too lazy to find games now, but have you heard of the stereotype of the poisoned punch bowl?

No. I'd still like you to find me games. Hell, even 1 game would do for now.

BM

[armlx]

Quite frankly, I'm going back and having trouble finding a single game with a cult, let alone one with a cult kill. I know it has been discussed before several times.

[Battle Mage]

Quite frankly, I'm going back and having trouble finding a single game with a cult, let alone one with a cult kill. I know it has been discussed before several times.

You tried Cultafia?

The only completed game i can think of is my own Doctor Who Mafia. The cult victims were 'deleted' according to the flavour.

Keep searching please.

BM

[Matt_S]

This game has random mafia kill methods, including poison. So poison killing isn't necessarily a cult thing. However, given that we still have three kills after lynching the serial killer, something's definitely up. The cult recruit having a kill would explain pretty much everything.

On another note, I was debating with myself whether to go back to Peers, or follow through with my suspicions on killa seven or TheSweatpantsNinja. Given that killa seven does seem to be naturally scummy, I'll leave him alone for now. And since I fear a chain of OMGUS if I vote TheSweatpantsNinja now, I'll

Vote Peers

. He slipped away when Rosso's lynching came up. For your convenience, my initial points against him:

I'm looking at Peers for tomorrow. His last two posts are perfect to explain my suspicions.

Vote: killa

Yeah, I'll join the wagon. Let's see if we can get a worth-while claim out of this.

He was questioned a lot on what would be a worthwhile claim, yet he never answered. And it sounds like he's only wagoning in order to get a claim.

We still have a week to talk people, no need to lynch right now.

Translation: "Hey, maybe if you guys ignore my scumbuddy you'll convince people to lynch a hapless town role instead", right?

Translation: "I can't let this guy hunt more scum or I'll be dead tomorrow!"

Yeah, I've convinced myself.

Vote Peers

[Battle Mage]

This game has random mafia kill methods, including poison. So poison killing isn't necessarily a cult thing. However, given that we still have three kills after lynching the serial killer, something's definitely up. The cult recruit having a kill would explain pretty much everything.

On another note, I was debating with myself whether to go back to Peers, or follow through with my suspicions on killa seven or TheSweatpantsNinja. Given that killa seven does seem to be naturally scummy, I'll leave him alone for now. And since I fear a chain of OMGUS if I vote TheSweatpantsNinja now, I'll

Vote Peers

. He slipped away when Rosso's lynching came up. For your convenience, my initial points against him:

I'm looking at Peers for tomorrow. His last two posts are perfect to explain my suspicions.

Vote: killa

Yeah, I'll join the wagon. Let's see if we can get a worth-while claim out of this.

He was questioned a lot on what would be a worthwhile claim, yet he never answered. And it sounds like he's only wagoning in order to get a claim.

We still have a week to talk people, no need to lynch right now.

Translation: "Hey, maybe if you guys ignore my scumbuddy you'll convince people to lynch a hapless town role instead", right?

Translation: "I can't let this guy hunt more scum or I'll be dead tomorrow!"

Yeah, I've convinced myself.

Vote Peers

Chain of OMGUS? I dont understand.

BM

[Matt_S]

Chain of OMGUS? I dont understand.

I vote TheSweatpantsNinja, he votes me. Killa seven also votes me to be consistent with his stance yesterday. Then I vote killa seven. People start getting mad at me, I vote them, etc.

[killa seven]

Chain of OMGUS? I dont understand.

I vote TheSweatpantsNinja, he votes me. Killa seven also votes me to be consistent with his stance yesterday. Then I vote killa seven. People start getting mad at me, I vote them, etc.

you sound guilty, i never voted you or fo'd you, i only called you out on one thing. you look very scummy at the moment. i dont remember you voting for me yesterday, dont confuse killa sven 1 with killa seven 2 thank you.

[Battle Mage]

Chain of OMGUS? I dont understand.

I vote TheSweatpantsNinja, he votes me. Killa seven also votes me to be consistent with his stance yesterday. Then I vote killa seven. People start getting mad at me, I vote them, etc.

you sound guilty, i never voted you or fo'd you, i only called you out on one thing. you look very scummy at the moment. i dont remember you voting for me yesterday, dont confuse killa sven 1 with killa seven 2 thank you.

Actually i dont see why he cant compare K7 1's suspicions with K7 2's...
I mean, if you are the same person, theres no reason why you wouldnt hold similar views if you were the same affiliation.

Mind you, fear of confrontation is kinda scummy Matt...

BM

[Matt_S]

Chain of OMGUS? I dont understand.

I vote TheSweatpantsNinja, he votes me. Killa seven also votes me to be consistent with his stance yesterday. Then I vote killa seven. People start getting mad at me, I vote them, etc.

you sound guilty, i never voted you or fo'd you, i only called you out on one thing. you look very scummy at the moment. i dont remember you voting for me yesterday, dont confuse killa sven 1 with killa seven 2 thank you.

I'm telling a story of what will happen, not of what already did happen. I'm free to add any creativity I want to prophecies.

Mind you, fear of confrontation is kinda scummy Matt...

Then vote for me. Just because I don't think voting for TheSweatpantsNinja now will lead to anything constructive doesn't mean I'm afraid of confrontation. OMGUS voting is hardly real confrontation anyways. It's just a distraction.

[dahill1]

upon rereading khelvaster (animorph), he was always wishy washy about BM. one post he would be defending BM, the next attacking him.

[Toaster Strudel]

upon rereading khelvaster (animorph), he was always wishy washy about BM. one post he would be defending BM, the next attacking him.

Indeed, and I am EXTREMELY leery of the Miller/Hider claim, that's the kind of claim that's just tooooo scummalicious.

The Miller/Hider claim explains two of the problems that scum might encounter in a game. The first problem is that they may be investigated and found guilty. Conveniently, BM declared himself a miller. The second problem is that the scum must explain his continued survival night after night. This is especially important if we have living vig, and the miller doesn't get nigthkilled and continues to live. So "hider" and "miller" makes a perfect combo for a scum claim.

Also, I see BM is very active and scheming. That's his scum persona, not his town persona.

The Miller/Hider claim is the real clincher. I don't believe it. I believe that BM is just plain scum.

vote: Battle Mage

[Toaster Strudel]

Oh, ans something else I'm just thinking of, a Hider claim is also useful for a scum because it might keep the vig at bay.

[Matt_S]

upon rereading khelvaster (animorph), he was always wishy washy about BM. one post he would be defending BM, the next attacking him.

Indeed, and I am EXTREMELY leery of the Miller/Hider claim, that's the kind of claim that's just tooooo scummalicious.

The Miller/Hider claim explains two of the problems that scum might encounter in a game. The first problem is that they may be investigated and found guilty. Conveniently, BM declared himself a miller. The second problem is that the scum must explain his continued survival night after night. This is especially important if we have living vig, and the miller doesn't get nigthkilled and continues to live. So "hider" and "miller" makes a perfect combo for a scum claim.

Also, I see BM is very active and scheming. That's his scum persona, not his town persona.

The Miller/Hider claim is the real clincher. I don't believe it. I believe that BM is just plain scum.

vote: Battle Mage

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

[dahill1]

upon rereading khelvaster (animorph), he was always wishy washy about BM. one post he would be defending BM, the next attacking him.

Indeed, and I am EXTREMELY leery of the Miller/Hider claim, that's the kind of claim that's just tooooo scummalicious.

The Miller/Hider claim explains two of the problems that scum might encounter in a game. The first problem is that they may be investigated and found guilty. Conveniently, BM declared himself a miller. The second problem is that the scum must explain his continued survival night after night. This is especially important if we have living vig, and the miller doesn't get nigthkilled and continues to live. So "hider" and "miller" makes a perfect combo for a scum claim.

Also, I see BM is very active and scheming. That's his scum persona, not his town persona.

The Miller/Hider claim is the real clincher. I don't believe it. I believe that BM is just plain scum.

vote: Battle Mage

QFT i was going to write something like this in my next post but you pretty much summed it up

Vote BM

[Matt_S]

Dear dahill1,

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

[dahill1]

Dear dahill1,

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

oops

unvote

that does make a huge hole in my argument

[skitzer]

On the poisoning: I was in a game where the Mafia had a poisoner, but it was delayed. So, saying that the cult recruit was a poisoner, they may have been recruited night 0, notified of recruitment and poisoned someone night 1, and their first victim died and they poisoned another last night.

Also, BM is looking very scummy today.

FoS: BM

tonight's the night the vig should get 'em, if we don't lynch him first.

[dahill1]

Dear dahill1,

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

oops

unvote

that does make a huge hole in my argument

EBWOP: the part about the khelvaster/BM connection
he still could be cult

[DrippingGoofball]

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

Duh, BM is scum?

[VanDamien]

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

Cult also = scum.

Vote: Battle Mage

[dahill1]

Cult also = scum

revote BM

sorry meant to do this last post

[Toaster Strudel]

Please 'splain Rosso's guilty on him first.

Duh, BM is scum?

Like Goofball says.

[Toaster Strudel]

For clarity's sake.

Normally, one would expect a cult cop to get a "guilty" on cults, and "not guilty" on non-cults.

However, Rosso seems to have gotten a "guilty" on a miller - but I too would expect that a miller would be innocent to a cult cop. However, BM was guilty to Rosso. This must mean that BM was culted. A culted miller/hider? That cannot be suffered to live.

[curiouskarmadog]

need to reread the end of the day yesterday..I thought Ani's contentless post/vote on RC looked suspicious...

BM, did you ever indicate that you felt Ani was scummy yesterday?....anyway, going to read...more later.