SUPP 2017 MAFIA: COMPLETE

[MariaR]

Stop dodging my questions Commander thank you I'll restate them
1) Do you get how fire is not mech conf scum to me
2) Do you get why you shouldn't be voting me today
3) Do you now get that I'm not just a cop so me and fire aren't a cc.

[Dunnstral]

But then Fire claims and he's scum because there can't be two cops? I thought claims weren't AI... I thought Maria was open to crazy setup stuff... but nah, guess not.

I said this before and I'll say it again. I didn't believe fire was a cop because of his invest result more so then him claiming cop itself.

You thought a guilty on Esp wasn't plausible?

I believed Espe was town over Fire so yes to that from me

[Dunnstral]

And yeah I believe there's no cop claims right now. Neither of them are acting like cops should act. I think they're using too much information and trying to ride the cred.

0% chance we lynch an investigative claim today

[Commander Shepard]

Actually, I've made multiple posts entertaining this idea and questioning Maria/Fire as a pair, and it's driving me a bit crazy. Nobody seems interested too interested in that though...

I don't believe that town has 0 investigative roles so if nobody else says anything I don't think they can be a pair

Not everyone has claimed. Why the fuck would an investigative if it exists out itself now? If anything it'd check between the two cop/invest/whatever claims.

Pedit:

1) No I don't. If you think Fire is scum then you should be voting him. You're a claimed cop/invest/whatever. It's a fucking counterclaim.
2) No I don't. I think you're scum. The only thing mentioned is your votes are linked. So I'm a okay to vote you.
3) No I don't. If you used a cop ability then you're still counter claiming Fire.

[DeasVail]

I see that things have gotten active again and unfortunately I’m V/LA for this weekend.

I’ve very sporadically skimmed the thread and am probably a little more in support of lynching PP than I was in my last post. I think the reasoning for scumreading me is disingenuous considering that there’s this preoccupation with my rankings and how sometimes my expressed reads are different from that, though I also would think that’s totallh expected from town, which leads me to the thought that PP hasn’t put much thought into his read of me and that it’s more likely a result of me being a convenient scumread to have considering my perceived lynchability at this stage and lower activity.

The people that are just PoEing me as scum are a lot less suspicious to me because that kind of makes sense.

[ManWithNoName]

You kn ow what?

VOTE: Shoshin

[Commander Shepard]

And yeah I believe there's no cop claims right now. Neither of them are acting like cops should act. I think they're using too much information and trying to ride the cred.

0% chance we lynch an investigative claim today

Then we have to pretty much lynch Shoshin or we're probably hitting town.

Because this cop shit is bullshit. Maria and Fire have both done sketchy shit around their claims and I believe none of it.

Pedit: Hey DV. Thoughts on the Maria/Fire situation.

[Commander Shepard]

VOTE: Shoshin

[MariaR]

3) No I don't. If you used a cop ability then you're still counter claiming Fire.

How long have you played mafia?

[MariaR]

1) No I don't. If you think Fire is scum then you should be voting him. You're a claimed cop/invest/whatever. It's a fucking counterclaim.

2 Of the same role in a game isn't a counter claim first of all. Second of all that isn't even happening here because I'm not just a cop. Third of all I scumread you much more I cased your slot.

[Commander Shepard]

3) No I don't. If you used a cop ability then you're still counter claiming Fire.

How long have you played mafia?

Long enough to know you're full of shit. This game is too small to support two cops and Fire's makes more sense than yours if I have to pick. I'd rather just use my machine gun to kill you but the moderator took all my bullets (sniff).

Pedit:
Yes it FUCKING IS WHEN IT'S A COP. Other roles fine. But a cop and a cop both the same night is crap.
yes you "cased" my slot. Waaaaaaaaaah you should be voting Fire. And until you do I want your fucking head.

[Shoshin]

Maria, why'd you read Esp as town?

[MariaR]

3) No I don't. If you used a cop ability then you're still counter claiming Fire.

How long have you played mafia?

Long enough to know you're full of shit. This game is too small to support two cops and Fire's makes more sense than yours if I have to pick. I'd rather just use my machine gun to kill you but the moderator took all my bullets (sniff).

Pedit:
Yes it FUCKING IS WHEN IT'S A COP. Other roles fine. But a cop and a cop both the same night is crap.
yes you "cased" my slot. Waaaaaaaaaah you should be voting Fire. And until you do I want your fucking head.

So not long at all to know stuff about set ups ok I'll take this as NAI from you thank you.

[MariaR]

Maria, why'd you read Esp as town?

Before the cop claim? Honestly I forget I'll have to go back and look at quotes but his reaction to the guilty made any doubts I had go away

[Shoshin]

Nahdia,

welcome!

I read through your ISO and nodded a lot; but why is

PP's

claim towny?[/size]

I think, as scum, the wouldn't have pussyfooted around claiming for so long. They woulda just done it or not. If they wanted to deliberate on whether they should or not, they'd ask their scumteam (just checked; scum are confirmed to have daytalk).

Just noticed something about this. Nahdia townreads PP before checking whether scum have daytalk, which makes me think she decided to townread PP first and then came up with reasoning afterwards.

[Shoshin]

I also don't believe Sheperd would vote me in this game for the reasons he's given.

[MariaR]

He's scum pretty simple

[MariaR]

It's possible he's also faking how dumb he's acting and considering he's an alt that's the line of logic I'm leaning on at the moment

[Commander Shepard]

Oh I disagree with the common thought of the thread. I must be dumb. That's it yeah. Apparently you can't actually counter the points I have so now I'm dumb.

I gotta go. I'll start giving a shit when people don't resort to attacking others instead they attack points. Which none of you have actually done. Shoshin has came close and said they don't believe my reasons, but they don't actually attack the points which means they have merit.

Let's lynch Shoshin people.

[MariaR]

You've made no point. You've said that 2 cops can't be in the same game where 1) there aren't even 2 cop claims I've said I'm dif then a cop boom your argument is wrong 2) there could be 2 cop claims.
Pretty simple

[Shoshin]

lol I'm not attacking your points because they don't rise to the level of merit required of them to be attacked.

[DeasVail]

And yeah I believe there's no cop claims right now. Neither of them are acting like cops should act. I think they're using too much information and trying to ride the cred.

0% chance we lynch an investigative claim today

Then we have to pretty much lynch Shoshin or we're probably hitting town.

Because this cop shit is bullshit. Maria and Fire have both done sketchy shit around their claims and I believe none of it.

Pedit: Hey DV. Thoughts on the Maria/Fire situation.

Hey Shepard, I haven’t read the recent stuff properly. My most recent thinking on the subject was that Fire is probably town and Maria not so town but I didn’t want to go there today.

[ManWithNoName]

Commander, you are also OntheMark, right?

Because I feel like you also got scumreads on there for the similar style of play in Fallout 4 mafia. Was that OTM?

[Shoshin]

DV, what're your thoughts on Sheperd?

[ManWithNoName]

Commander, you are also OntheMark, right?

Because I feel like you also got scumreads on there for the similar style of play in Fallout 4 mafia. Was that OTM?

Wait, Nevermind this, FO4 is not over. I have no clue what game I am thinking of, because it was definitely a completed game.