Labyrinth Mafia (Endgame)

[Wisdom]

Because he wasnt
It was csheep and the mod derped

[Wisdom]

Speaking of which

random did you use a communicative on nico n2 or not

not intentionally but i'll double check

[Shoshin]

I'm not relieved about Shep's death. I just had no intention of dying in his place

[Wisdom]

besides why the hell would random send a message to nico
And why would he lie about doing it
Doesnt make any sense

[the worst]

how do people feel about the fact Shoshin claimed bg in her pt with CShep tho

[the worst]

I want to lynch Shoshin more than I want to breathe but this doesn't feel right

[Shoshin]

One thing that I don’t get is why she voted for Angel and is so angry at both CS and me for Angel lynch. If she really felt it was a bad lynch, then why did she go along with it?

She says if she was a doc, she would have saved him but for someone who claims to be this upset about a mislynch, she seems quite relieved about his death.

Also, why didn’t she use her NA on Sajj? He was adamantly opposed to Angel lynch. or Wheme? I initially thought her reaction was villagery but for her to be this upset about a lynching that she participated in makes no sense.

She is also aware of how anti-town Angel was, it’s not like we lynched Nico or even GIF. I could understand her being upset if either one of them had been mislynched because Nico - self-evident - GIF - sketchy but 0 threat to town but she’s not mad at Sajj for shooting GIF but CS and me are somehow evil people for wanting to eliminate a highly toxic player from the game. Why?

I voted for Angel at the end because the lynch was inevitable and I wanted to move on. I'm not even that upset about Angel's lynching, what actually upset me is the fact that you keep saying it was a good lynch when it obviously wasn't. Mislynching should be a cue to reevaluate, not a cue to keep doing what you're doing. That's what bothers me about how you've responded to the lynch.

I'm not relieved about Shep's death. I didn't want to die in his place. There's a big difference between the two.

Yes, I'm aware that Angel wasn't playing pro-town. I also strongly opposte policy lynching of any kind. You said you did too, except that's not what your actions or reasoning shows.

I never said you or Shep are "evil people." Again, you keep taking this personally even though I keep telling you it's not. I want you rethinking the game, specifically Random. That's all.

[Shoshin]

the worst, why are you voting me?

[the worst]

UNVOTE:
this solve is wrong

gnite

[Wisdom]

how do people feel about the fact Shoshin claimed bg in her pt with CShep tho

bg is a better fakeclaim because it makes the others want to leave you alive in case you autoresolve
Or maybe it fit her flavor claim better than doc
Or maybe rc literally gave her a bg fakeclaim

[Wisdom]

oh come on tw
Its chick and her, it cant be anyone else

[Shoshin]

because shes scum maybe?

All of the contradictions are pinging me. She trashes CS for being bad at finding scum OOH then keeps referencing his reads on Random as a basis for her to tunnel him.

I would think if she really wanted random lynched, she would have absolutely saved the one player who was not only scumreading him but had the best chance of persuading others to lynch him, since she has pretty much positioned herself as a broken record about him.

*tin foil* theory: Shoshin is w/w with random?

Shep isn't a good townie. I know who Shep's main is, I've played with him before, and we've talked in PM about how we play the game and our strengths and weaknesses. He's bad as town, good as scum. And he admits this openly.

I reference him re: Random to point out that I'm not alone in suspectnig Random - two other townies also did, Nico and Shep - but I'm the one who caught Random and explained why he's scum to Shep - Shep just agreed, in part because he trusts my scumhunting skills.

Yeah, I get that you keep saying I would have saved Shep. I didn't. I chose not to. Get over it.

Would you have died in place of Angel if Angel was confirmed town? I'm guessing not, since you keep saying her play was anti-town. Just because someone is confirmed town doesn't mean it's worth dying in their place.

[Shoshin]

Wisdom, why can't it be Random?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Because he wasnt
It was csheep and the mod derped

You seem awfully sure of this. Why is that?

[Wisdom]

nancy dont make me repeat the same things one million times

[Shoshin]

Wisdom, why can't it be Random?

[Shoshin]

oh come on tw
Its chick and her, it cant be anyone else

My question is in reference to this. Why can't it be Random?

[Nancy Drew 39]

besides why the hell would random send a message to nico
And why would he lie about doing it
Doesnt make any sense

If random is scum here, why wouldn’t he lie?

He hasn’t confirmed it yet and I don’t like how you’re giving him an out based on you assuming the mod derped. We don’t know that and either do you.

Your defense of random is kind of pinging me because it’s too over the top.

He may still be town but I don’t like how you’re automatically assuming a mod derp. Until RC tells me otherwise, I believing there wasn’t one.

[Shoshin]

besides why the hell would random send a message to nico
And why would he lie about doing it
Doesnt make any sense

If random is scum here, why wouldn’t he lie?

He hasn’t confirmed it yet and I don’t like how you’re giving him an out based on you assuming the mod derped. We don’t know that and either do you.

Your defense of random is kind of pinging me because it’s too over the top.

He may still be town but I don’t like how you’re automatically assuming a mod derp. Until RC tells me otherwise, I believing there wasn’t one.

Good analysis. Well done, Nancy!

[Wisdom]

why would he lie about sending a message
would you suspect him if he had said he sent a message
Its a fucking message

[Nancy Drew 39]

nancy dont make me repeat the same things one million times

You’re pushing this too hard based on unproven assumptions. RC would have messaged me back if my NA didn’t go through. I’m calling bullshit on this.

[Scioness Sajj]

Sho, why did you claim your protective to CShep?

[Wisdom]

Like, imagine you are scum, and for some reason, you sent a message to someone
Come massclaim, will you say you did nothing (and risk getting caught) or just out you sent a message (which is harmless and nobody will suspect you for it)?
Use your brain ffs

[Wisdom]

nancy dont make me repeat the same things one million times

You’re pushing this too hard based on unproven assumptions. RC would have messaged me back if my NA didn’t go through. I’m calling bullshit on this.

This is wrong on many levels.
First of all, the mod derp is not YOUR action, is his listing CShep's action in Reality's result.
Second, the mods do NOT tell people if their actions succeeded, so no, he would tell you nothing.
Concentrate, nancy. Im using common sense.

[Nancy Drew 39]

why would he lie about sending a message
would you suspect him if he had said he sent a message
Its a fucking message

The difference between Reality and you, is that Reality isn’t ignoring this as a possibllity. Random didn’t outright deny this. He basically said he would check and we still haven’t heard back from him yet.

But you insisting the mod derped BEFORRE random can even attempt an answer is scummy af.

VOTE: Wisdom