NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

[xyzzy]

Even if he doesn't post much at least I do feel his posts have content

Literally where because I have seen nothing but "Beep boop I agree with this post"

You all are straying from the true path, stop

repeatedly claiming to not see something does not disprove its existence

[Inferno390]

Ohmygosh

I almost gave up on lynching dram today because of that flashwagon. Thank Mith we kept traction.

I’m gonna say that the xyzzy wagon is incredibly scummy based on its timing. If I had to lynch within a few wagons because of deadline, I would never choose someone who has had little to no analysis. You’re basically stealing info from town by denying them flip associations and wagon analysis.

This whole wagon feels designed to put Town in the dark D2. Makes me highly sus of Elbirn.

Lynch needs to happen within Hit/Taly/Flubber/Dram today. Sorry to anyone who feels otherwise, those flips are going to be the best for D2 position, regardless of any specific reads on them.

[profii]

It’s fair to say your lynch pool is better but given that scum will be in the lurkers, xyzzy is arguably an ok lynch just not as optimal.

i Think you are calling it scummy to get people to come round to your way out of fear though. Interesting


I’ll sit for a bit and see if we are going for flubbber or dram today

[Inferno390]

Of course there’s an argument that there’s at least 1 scum in the lurkers.
But what makes xyzzy a better lurker to lynch than all the other ones?
Why’s it so important to lynch lurkers that it’s worth jeopardizing D2 information?
And what if xyzzy is Town and Elbirn is wrong? What happens then?

There are far too many ways for a flashwagon like this to go wrong and not nearly enough to go right. And the fact that Elbirn refuses to work with Town on the current lynchpool by go, “Oh, here’s a lurker I don’t like! Flashwagon him!” Is super scummy imo.

[dramonic]

Not waiting to get lolhammered while at work.
Im a prime-night Jailkeeper. So jk on 2-3-5-7

Way to derail a scumlynch to out your PRs people

[Ausuka]

Hmm!

@Mod: does this game follow the new Normal guidelines?

[Inferno390]

That is the most defensive PR claim I’ve ever read.
It’s also very convenient that it won’t help us at all N1...

[Elbirn]

@Inferno, I don't lynch for information. I lynch to kill scum like a normal person.

[Inferno390]

Hmm!

@Mod: does this game follow the new Normal guidelines?

Damn, good call Ausuka.

[dramonic]

Just because it's a normal doesnt mean Pine can't make up modifiers

[Elbirn]

Actually it does, and I originally read that post as even night for some reason.

10/10 will vote dram
Jk xyzzy we good today

[Elbirn]

Wait no I lied to you

(Acceptable Modifiers):
Ascetic, Backup (with or without primary role present), Bulletproof, Enabler (with or without primary role present), Macho, Neighbor, Non-Consecutive Night, Weak, X-Shot, Ninja, Loyal, Disloyal, Loud, Multitasking, Informed, Activated,

any modifier restricting to a specific set of nights (e.g. Even/Odd Night, Night Specific, Novice)

[Skygazer]

If I had to pick the scum on the xyzzy wagon it'd be hit and maybe chickadee, definitely not elbirn.

Wouldn't prime-number be covered under "any modifier restricting to a specific set of nights?"

pedit: ninja'd

[dramonic]

That is the most defensive PR claim I’ve ever read.
It’s also very convenient that it won’t help us at all N1...

Because my odds of obstructing a N1 kill as an outed JK would be massive indeed if I was regular

[Ausuka]

Ah ok that makes sense. I believe the claim now.

VOTE: xyzzy

[profii]

Of course there’s an argument that there’s at least 1 scum in the lurkers.
But what makes xyzzy a better lurker to lynch than all the other ones?
Why’s it so important to lynch lurkers that it’s worth jeopardizing D2 information?
And what if xyzzy is Town and Elbirn is wrong? What happens then?

There are far too many ways for a flashwagon like this to go wrong and not nearly enough to go right. And the fact that Elbirn refuses to work with Town on the current lynchpool by go, “Oh, here’s a lurker I don’t like! Flashwagon him!” Is super scummy imo.

That’s better

[Inferno390]

That is the most defensive PR claim I’ve ever read.
It’s also very convenient that it won’t help us at all N1...

Because my odds of obstructing a N1 kill as an outed JK would be massive indeed if I was regular

That’s not my point and you know it

[profii]

So we are agreed that prime number fits in the rules?

VOTE: flubber

[profii]

Oh and not cc’ing

[Inferno390]

Yeah it fits

[xyzzy]

prime number modifier is kind of weird but also plausible in 17p

[Elbirn]

Isn't 1 a prime number

I went to college

[Skygazer]

Wasn't this game advertised as mild role madness? I can see a prime number modifier being used for balance purposes or something.

According to wikipedia, 1 is not prime. I majored in music.

[Inferno390]

@Inferno, I don't lynch for information. I lynch to kill scum like a normal person.

Yeah, so do I
But that doesn’t mean that when I don’t like the lynches for the day, I don’t go pick a lurker I don’t like and tell everyone to flashwagon them
That helps town about zero.

[xyzzy]

Isn't 1 a prime number

I went to college

1 is definitely not a prime number