SUPP 2017 MAFIA: COMPLETE

[ManWithNoName]

Okay, I'll just wait until it all comes together to ask any questions I may have

[Commander Shepard]

Okay, I'll just wait until it all comes together to ask any questions I may have

Do you agree with the following statement

Either
Punreader shot me and is telling the truth about doing so
Or Punreader did not attempt to shoot me and is lying.

And do you agree with punreader is likely not confirmed scum?

[Commander Shepard]

Okay, I'll just wait until it all comes together to ask any questions I may have

Do you agree with the following statement

Either
Punreader shot me and is telling the truth about doing so
Or Punreader did not attempt to shoot me and is lying.

And do you agree with punreader is likely confirmed not group scum?

Sorry typo

[ManWithNoName]

Okay, I'll just wait until it all comes together to ask any questions I may have

Do you agree with the following statement

Either
Punreader shot me and is telling the truth about doing so
Or Punreader did not attempt to shoot me and is lying.

And do you agree with punreader is likely not confirmed scum?

The first, yes.

The second for the time being I will agree to, but I'm still hesitant about how you use the word confirmed.

[Commander Shepard]

Okay now let’s look at option B) That punreader lied

This would require someone who is likely not group scum lying to me AND at least one other person in a hood. They would have to do said lying before my flip so they would have expected me to die or be in trouble themselves yes?

Now why would someone who is not group scum do those things?

Do you agree that means that punreader is much more likely to be telling the truth about me asking to die?

[Commander Shepard]

So you with me ManWithNoName?

[ManWithNoName]

Wait, there are three people in the hood?

[ManWithNoName]

Because that changes a good amount.

[Commander Shepard]

There is at least one other person.

Who is / is not I will not say.

But yes there is.

[Commander Shepard]

So do you agree with my prior statement that it is exceedingly unlikely punreader is lying?

[Commander Shepard]

(I know they aren’t but the exceedingly unlikely is for your benefit)

[ManWithNoName]

Okay. The existence of one more changes things, no matter who it is.

I will agree, then.

[Commander Shepard]

So with punreader shooting me of all people,

Now we have a “inno” in Vax claiming to have shot me. (I use that in quotes)

Do you agree that Vax claimed to have shot me?

So either A) Vax is lying
B) Punreader is lying
Or C) Lightning rod

[ManWithNoName]

But, here's the place where I feel it falls apart. Even if we assume Vax is lying, your contention is that Pun is not lying so, how do you survive even the one shot?

Why push Vax before if you also cannot explain pun's shot not killing you?

[Commander Shepard]

Sorry for late entry. I expected to be dead so I hung out at a friend’s all night.

I am confused on how I am alive and how Punreader is alive.

Kinda makes me useless now shit.

Punreader is confirmed not group scum unless they are BP as I am relatively confident they shot me last night.

Why the fuck would someone heal me?

I am a fucking weird PGO esque (not official role name). If I get shot by scum they die but shot by town:SK I die. Was trying to die so Shoshin gets lynched because Shoshin is obvScum.

Mainly I wanted a chance to confirm Punreader as not a scum vig and then save a mislynch so we would hit scum. I was a planned mislynch for scum so pretty much a safe bet to try to get punreader to shoot me and be dead.

I haven’t read at all except what I have already mentioned since I expected to die.

I have to go but something funny is going on as I should have never been healed.

I did ask about it when I started.

However I have the added bonus of knowing punreader said so pre day open that they did.

I was struggling to put this together and my first thought was I was healed.

Healed once is possible. Twice not so much. Hence why I went after Vax.

The only way Vax is truth telling is if there is a lightning rod.

[ManWithNoName]

I guess this didn't post, I'm at least going to have to rethink this all now that I understand it and see where I land.

UNVOTE:

I'll be out the rest of the night, probably.

[Commander Shepard]

I was starting from
1) Punreader claimed in hood they shot me
That is stupid to lie about preflip with another person present
2) Therefore I thought I was healed
3) Healed twice is not a thing so Vax scum or LR.

Pedit finally. I feel like a goddamn tape recorder

[MariaR]

This is a game that I am in yes.
Don't know where I want my vote out of CS or Sho I liked Sho more than CS the day before but CS is much better today

[the worst]

anyone able to get me up to speed? I'm still in a logic coma pretty much since Pun shot CShep

[DeasVail]

Shepard, just curious, did you/Nahdia get my message on night 1?

[Commander Shepard]

Shepard, just curious, did you/Nahdia get my message on night 1?

It depends do cats nuzzle up against people often? Or do they only play Christian rock in the sound of a purr?

[Commander Shepard]

Yes I did I will quit with the jokes.

I was trying to tell you “I get the hint already” that it was you. I just wanted a bit of brevity.

[Shoshin]

The cat thing was DV? Interesting.

[Shoshin]

What's a lightning rod?

[MariaR]

all actions target the player who uses the light rod