Heroes Wanted! (Game Over)

[zMuffinMan]

@nancy,

probably not

and i have no idea what you're asking in the second paragraph. unless you're saying i'm disregarding the possibility that titus is town who scum elected? i'm not entirely, it's just far less likely than the alternative based on a. her play, and b. the fact that titus was a likely lynch candidate today if not for the leader thing so why waste it on her purely to induce paranoia? otoh, i do think she'd be vain enough to ask her team to make her unlynchable

[Nosferatu]

Get someone to vote you for stupid reasons, works for me.

i mean you hammered while stipulating a scum team that makes exactly 0 sense but hey i guess its dumb that you lined up lynches after a day of totally useless posts

[Nancy Drew 39]

@nancy,

probably not

and i have no idea what you're asking in the second paragraph. unless you're saying i'm disregarding the possibility that titus is town who scum elected? i'm not entirely, it's just far less likely than the alternative based on a. her play, and b. the fact that titus was a likely lynch candidate today if not for the leader thing so why waste it on her purely to induce paranoia? otoh, i do think she'd be vain enough to ask her team to make her unlynchable

I have no knowledge of her scum meta. I do know that she was the defacto GOAT in the team hydra game I played with her, eventhough we still lost.

She does seem definitely less charismatic today then on D1 but I’m kind of smug whenever I’ve been IC in a game, which I know is obviously not the same thing here.

I guess, the only theory that I absolutely don’t buy was that Titus’ election was mostly an alltown effort like she seems to think, mainly because of her being the counterwagon. However, in Necromancer I went from almost being mislynched in the first couple of hours to being viewed as locktown D2, so I wouldn’t have been shocked to have been elected leader in that game - had the mechanics allowed for it - despite that.

[Sakura Hana]

nah muffin's play this game doesn't align with what i remember of his scum game.

[Nancy Drew 39]

nah muffin's play this game doesn't align with what i remember of his scum game.

What is his scumgame like? I’ve only played with him as town.

[Sakura Hana]

nah muffin's play this game doesn't align with what i remember of his scum game.

What is his scumgame like? I’ve only played with him as town.

It's kinda hard to explain, it feels like it's lacking cockiness, basically I remember he'd done the opposite of things I'd expect scum to be doing. Meanwhile there's a game solving kind of tone in his posting in this game, that's similar to Minuet's.

[Nancy Drew 39]

nah muffin's play this game doesn't align with what i remember of his scum game.

What is his scumgame like? I’ve only played with him as town.

It's kinda hard to explain, it feels like it's lacking cockiness, basically I remember he'd done the opposite of things I'd expect scum to be doing. Meanwhile there's a game solving kind of tone in his posting in this game, that's similar to Minuet's.

Yeah I agree but what do you make of the tone diference? He acknowledged that on D1 but never explained it.

[Sakura Hana]

He acknowledged that on D1 but never explained it.

I don't feel any difference in tone, and i don't see him acknowledging it, it feels like his "how observant" was directed at your overall post and not specifically the tone part, I could be wrong tho.

[Kokichi Oma]

I'll read later

[Toranaga]

your spat with FA is only clearing her further if you're scum, and tilting and antagonizing her if you're town.

I'm actually really conflicted about her being scum rn.

I mean all evidence points to it, and I think she is saying many alarming things she doesn't actually believe in, especially with regards to leader votes.

but what if she is just too proud and ego to admit she might have been put there by scum? or otherwise, that you being leader "has" to be scum motivated for some reason.

I just don't understand what the longterm for titus is by picking a fight with you on d1 instead of going through the motions with non-alarmbells.gif stances.

and some of her posts really feel towny too. it may be because titus looks better on her natural environment, but I don't remember her wolfgame looking natural like that.

still d3's lynch unless she townsides like crazy I think.

[Gamma Emerald]

either titus is being voted to become the leader as a way for framing her or she is really scum and is open wolfing/double bluffing us by choosing herself as leader.

Yeah well here's the thing
If Titus is a wolf we can't do shit about it rn
So imo we should probably let things evolve and if anything transpires in the night that is not right we can probably ax her tomorrow

[Gamma Emerald]

Pardon but it's day two
Contribute or die

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't really feel like playing this anymore

Replace out

Wait what
I recall some sort of meta wrt Yume replace outs meaning something but I forget the exact rule

[Gamma Emerald]

I voted Titus for the same reason I voted Katsuki

so checking what the original reasoning is I think this is passable (not that good, but not something I want to kill on sight)

[Gamma Emerald]

Why did people vote for someone that blatantly lied is beyond me tho.

also if you're not talking about Katsuki who is this about?

[Gamma Emerald]

alright well somebody should get a lifeline on cerb and figure out who he voted if that's possible at this point

The only possibility for a medium was 123456789 last night. Not exactly a good use of the ability.

They can be mediumed tonight

[Gamma Emerald]

Mylo I have a guilty on you, thoughts?

That's... not really possible lol.

first thought is this is a town reaction
but I might have something I want to check to back it up
were you in open 717 mylo?

[Gamma Emerald]

Real quick since its still early in the game if anyone can clarify this, i just don't wanna fuck up

"5. Do not use any form of provable randomness."

What is "provable randomness" mean, like making a post that means nothing? posting off topic to the game?

@The Worst: Not gonna lie, 75 pages is quite a bit for now being on day 2. I'm still trying to make sure I got the rules right before I start reading.
@Smugleaf: oh good, lol thankyou

omg pls
provable randomness means dicerolling to pick a lylo vote etc
also lol u used smugleaf

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd be surprised by {Nico, Titus} as well. fwiw it pinged me that she actually requested replacement--in my experience with Nico she's more likely to keep trying to get re-engaged with the game until she's actually forced replaced. so that kinda felt a little maybe-encouraged to me.

but also I'm not really in the mood to vote there.

um you are aware that's Yume right
Yume has a BAD habit of flaking from games, like I don't want to list them because there's a ton.

[Gamma Emerald]

No. I was probably made leader because town wanted it. I was right yesterday in that scum wanted FA. So why wouldn't town vote for me? Let's all claim our votes to see this. If it shows I should not have been the leader, I'll eat my words. We can then put FA or majority target today as the vote leaders. If I was duly elected as the leader, we can sort the players claiming to vote me and see if any might be scum voting.

I voted for Ank btw.

Why do you believe town wanted you at all? You were suspected by several people earlier. Yes, one scum wanted FA. firstly that doesn't mean you were town's counter pick because leader can't be held consecutively, secondly that doesn't prove that scum worked to make her leader, we still don't know anything about that until we get a majority of flips of those who voted for her. And wtf are you spouting on about with "should or should not have been the leader"? Is that a judgement of how well you can do the job? It's simple: don't give scum power, and you do fine. Plus we can't fucking tell that until later.

[Nancy Drew 39]

He acknowledged that on D1 but never explained it.

I don't feel any difference in tone, and i don't see him acknowledging it, it feels like his "how observant" was directed at your overall post and not specifically the tone part, I could be wrong tho.

I’m not shocked that he voted Katsuki. He did that in Minuet as well but I don’t remember him hardcore defending him to this extent. Also, he seems different here than it that game. He was quite vocal and outspoken. I don’t know if that’s necessarily AI but his tone seems off somewhat.

how observant!

His response to me but I could have misinterpreted it. @zMuffinMan , Did your “how observant” comment have anything to do with my comment about your tone being so different from Minuet on D1?

[Gamma Emerald]

(oh, and if you ever want to push ankamius youre going to have to explain why brass sees his scum buddy spamming and gets so fed up he replaces out, which alone is enough to say they weren't scum together but there were a lot more interactions than just that)

Who says the spam caused the replace out
I'm familiar with him doing weird replaces, he left me high and dry once when he replaced out of a hydra with me as scum

[Gamma Emerald]

oh right, titus voted ankamius for leader

now wants to lynch ankamius

yeah, that happened

OH BOY this is pretty damning

[Gamma Emerald]

i missed deadline too, thats why i quoted the first bit of the gamma post at daystart

lol I thought you were going after me there
might wanna phrase your comment better

[Gamma Emerald]

i want titus to talk about things that fuckin aren't the leadership mechanic

its like her entire input this game

Yeah, well it is the entire game fmpov.

no it's not
there's scumhunting, which has worked alright so far