In post 1090, TrinityNZ wrote: In post 1089, MathBlade wrote: In post 1086, Dunnstral wrote:Eevee said they claimed because they "didn't think town was going to lynch pine"
Now they're talking about claiming while afraid of dying and the votes on them not showing if they're scum
Also like I said they were probably the lynch without that claim - I think they're scum who afraid of being lynched once their target claimed doctor decided to counterclaim and then push theory as for why their claim makes sense
VOTE: EeveelutionArmy
This is stupid
The post by Army is clearly sarcasm.
Trinity saying she doesn’t read my posts is a fucking scum claim
If I die tonight fucking lynch Trinity
I have just read all your posts again and still cannot see anywhere were you said this.
In post 1092, TrinityNZ wrote: In post 1063, LuckyOtter wrote:Speaking of Mafmen, he hasn't posted here since Monday, pre-claim business
@Mastina, prod please
If we're deciding between claims, Eevee's seems more plausible and I don't see Eevee making that counter as scum at that moment. Eevee's play does seem scummier but it just feels like a bad move lynching him.
If we're going to let the NK resolve it (which really isn't a bad idea), I have no clue anymore. Trinity keeps giving me bad vibes.
@Trinity
Maybe you didn't see it, but immediately following your Math vote I asked you to explain the basis of it.
--
Math, are you trying to get a hypoclaim going because you think it plausible both Pine and Eevee are lying?
--
Umlaut, most of your argumentation depends on associatives and there are a couple I'm not sure about. Maf's straight up "Pine is town without a doubt" seems pretty bold for a scumpartner, don't you think? If anything, it makes more sense to me if Maf is scum and knows Pine is town, or Maf is town and is just being opaque with his reads (as he seems to like to do, given that he called anyone who suspected you "daft" without explanation until asked for it).
The second problem is the Trinity+Eevee combo. Trinity was scumreading Pine, then after Eevee's counterclaim, scum!Trinity would have been able to sit on a Pine vote and stay out of the way and get the mislynch. Instead, scum!Trinity busses her partner who just counterclaimed? It seems equally plausible (or implausible) that scum!Trinity could have been trying to bus scum!Pine who appeared to be going down, then took the opportunity to change her mind as soon as Pine claimed (which she might have known he would do anyway). Following Eevee's counter, Trinity decides to believe Pine over Eevee, for pretty underwhelming reasons.
So I don't know. Sticking to Pine for now.
OK, so Otter I’ve been going backwards and forwards on MathBlade. I didn’t like him at first because he’d pushed really hard on Fuzzy, who turned out to be town, and I thought he’d been pretty instrumental in that mislynch. His posts have been cavalier and rude at times, and I asked him a few questions that he never bothered to answer. He has also tried to say I haven’t been reading posts, when I have. So I was finding him pretty tiresome and conflating that to mean he must be mafia. But, having done an ISO and reading all the posts at once, I think he has been scum hunting pretty hard, and I understand his reads on me, as I don’t tend to do the most in-depth posting, which leaves me open to being read as scum I guess. So I’m currently reading him as town, and am still all for lynching Eevee.
Then you’re not reading Trinity or you’re scum
The past few pages have been nothing but
“if I am X”
“Someone might fake claim”
And I highly doubt you read all of my posts again unless you read greater than 200 WPM and if you did good luck on actually comprehending that shit, if anyone cares I can do the math later
@Umlaut
If I am a bodyguard that would be dumb as nails to do because that just ensures me as the NK and my top townread of the two gets lynched.
Scum want to remove a PR role today. Lynching in that only helps scum.
If I am the bodyguard then scum will have to kill me eventually, me Pine Army endgame just doesn’t happen
If I am not the bodyguard and we lynch Pine scum, scum kill Army as they have no choice unless they shoot me thinking I am giving Army an extra night.
If I am not the bodyguard and we lynch Army scum, scum kill Pine as they have no choice unless they shoot me thinking I am giving Pine an extra night.
This means scum KNOW they have to decide the wifom now else risk a conf Town tomorrow.
This also means if we lynch the scum right today and I am not the bodyguard scenario in the Pine town scenario no more saved kills. Army then has to guess who is actually going to shoot.
By forcing this to be open if you don’t think I am the bodyguard then you force scum to reveal to use who in Pine and Army is likely scum AND make sure the protective has a chance to save a kill.
If you think I am the bodyguard then please listen to your one PR role when they tell you to back off.
Scum are going to want to get rid of the PR. The proper play is always to force scum to NK PRs.
If you townread me trust me on this.
Y’all better learn to love the word if for the rest of the day.
