SUPP 2017 MAFIA: COMPLETE

[Errantparabola]

Krazy replaces Chara. Please welcome him.

[Krazy]

Hi we're in day?

[the worst]

o hey krazy welcome

yes, we're in day 3

[Dunnstral]

Hi we're in day?

Games aren't typically open during night on this site, it is day

[Krazy]

unvote

Cool. What's up guys? Do we have an estimated scum count? Seems like a lot of good guys are dead.

[the worst]

considering we probably have a serial killer

prolly like 4-5 maf + 1 sk?

[guacamole]

nvm

Guacamole do you understand all the mechanical role stuff right now

Pretty much. The one i think is least likely to be lying is shep. Whether shep is correct about anything is uncertain. I dont consider any of the “cleared” results to be Reliable enough to be conf. Needs flips to resolve.

[guacamole]

If shep is town, >90% likely they think its protown to withhold some details.

[Krazy]

Well this looks like a mess.

Vote Vaxkiller

Why do people think Shepherd is better than this?

[Dunnstral]

MariaR claimed an inno on Vaxkiller

[Krazy]

Unvote

Ok let me understand a bit more. What is even possible in large theme? There's so much wacky nonsense, we're thinking mafia/sk is not immune to det?

Well there's three others anyway.

[Krazy]

Vote DeasVail

[DeasVail]

deas where are your reads at roughly

My reads are along the lines of the following:

Don't want to lynch:

Punreader
Espeonage
Dunnstral (Not as much of a townread if Fire is scum)
Vaxkiller (Would re-look at this slot if Maria is scum)

Probably don't want to lynch:

Shoshin (Townread based on play)
Fire Assassin (I don't even know what's going on with him but I'm back to thinking that the cop claim fumble is probably from town?)
Krazy (Still think that the townreads on Chara were a bit excessive but I don't scumread the slot as much as others)

Would lynch:

Commander Shepard (I do have reservations about the slot being scum, but over the last couple of RL days, I have come to think of their play as scummy, rather than just town-nonsensical. I can go into specific things about the slot that concern me tomorrow if I decide to go back to their wagon)
The worst (Not much about his play specifically that concerns me, but I really fail to see anything much in the slot that pops out to me as town, and compared to others who I believe do have indicators pointing to them as town, this makes him a good candidate imo for coasting scum)
MariaR (My scumread here as strengthened a little over the last couple of days. Despite the fact that town is completely confuddled at the moment, and her own sporadic engagement with the game, her posting is very composed and there is not the "lost" aspect that I'd expect from town struggling to engage with the game, nor is there evidence of an attempt to engage the town and get things moving. While I feel that the worst's play fits with coasting scum, I actually think that Maria's play is indicative of it).

[DeasVail]

Vote DeasVail

This is unlikely to be helpful

[DeasVail]

But hello and welcome to the game. It's nice to see someone I recognise from my early days on the site!

[the worst]

The worst

(Not much about his play specifically that concerns me, but I really fail to see anything much in the slot that pops out to me as town, and compared to others who I believe do have indicators pointing to them as town, this makes him a

good candidate imo for coasting scum

)

obvious coasting scum guys let's powerlynch my ass

I find it incredibly difficult to believe you actually have this read on me rn

[DeasVail]

You had a few arguments you could have used to counter my "coasting scum" comment, yet post count actually seems one of the weaker such arguments to use despite being visually impressive.

[the worst]

I was going for striking and visually impressive hoping you would elaborate.

[the worst]

if I was like "ye sweet I'm gonna coast thru this game so I'm unreadable" going for #1 poster position with fluffy content and drawing maximum attention to myself surely seems counter intuitive

[DeasVail]

your content is not entirely fluffy though. You have posts which on the surface do appear to be useful. The impression I get, however, is that you are scum going with the flow, while making posts that appear helpful. But I overall doubt that you actually care for town to win this game. This is why I am considering you likely to be scum.

Your response to my suspicion of you is a bit strange, since you mention finding it suspicious, yet I feel the majority of your content since has been bravado which could be to fend off further suspicion?

I am going to bed now but I will think more on this tomorrow.

[DeasVail]

like

"hmm DV's suspicion of me is difficult to believe and possibly suspicious"

"Oh har har how silly of anyone to think I am scum! What a ridiculous notion!"

[the worst]

I'm actually more alarmed that you're reading my posts in such a surface way

I think there's elements of my play this game that's mislynchable. elements of it that are definitely in line with my more powertowning self. and some stuff that probably looks down right shady.

it feels like you're stuck at level 1 of the above which is like.....pushing on tunnelling a mislynch territory

so no I'm not shocked that I'm being scumread categorically, just find it a bit shady that you're doing it on such 2 dimensional grounds

[the worst]

I'm gonna have to think on this too. my read on you is standing on one foot on top of the Eiffel Tower. xD

[Commander Shepard]

MariaR claimed an inno on Vaxkiller

OMG will people stop saying this as if it is fact.

I am claiming a guilty on Vax because he isn’t dead and because of the number of vigs.

2 mechanical reasons guilty > 1 mechanical reason innocent

We should all be on Vaxkiller

Not hard

[Shoshin]

I'm never lynching on a "mechanical reason" because we just don't know what role scum have.

DV's the one player who is actually playing this right but going back to behaviors.

Maria's a very good lynch on that front.

The fact that she's impossible to lynch because of all the players defending should make all of you even more wary of her.