Heroes Wanted! (Game Over)

[Sakura Hana]

Well uh:

well, actually, if I feel weird, it's because I really really want that neighborizer role

Not saying this makes FA scum, but just saying that it looks obvious to me what he took N1, and that's probably what scum thought as well.

If ank really had AND used BP then the only option is it's one of those 5

[Sakura Hana]

If anything if FA predicted what Ank took N1, why didnt she just shoot Ank N1 then instead of shooting Cerb who kept saying he'd take BP anyway.
I dont think FA is scum in any scenario.

[Sando]

@Thread Can I please go to bed now? Omg

Yeah go to bed

[Titus]

Actually it wouldn't be a bad gambit in a world where the remaining scum are Titus, You and two ohers. Titus knows Cerb well enough to help fake it and you just had plenty of time to go rummaging through logs of our hydra conversations. The only flaw in such a gambit is that it occurred to me to ask questions where the answers aren't anywhere on the site.

So, you can ask something only you and Cerb know. Like a comment in a hydra pt. Remove me from the equation.

Also, ftr I haven't readily accepted Shiro as town or scum.

[Titus]

If anything if FA predicted what Ank took N1, why didnt she just shoot Ank N1 then instead of shooting Cerb who kept saying he'd take BP anyway.
I dont think FA is scum in any scenario.

Which is good bc she'll like the powers tonight.

[Sando]

So, you can ask something only you and Cerb know. Like a comment in a hydra pt. Remove me from the equation.

He has...Cerb is refusing to answer...apparently

[Sakura Hana]

This game is making my head hurt...

[Titus]

So, you can ask something only you and Cerb know. Like a comment in a hydra pt. Remove me from the equation.

He has...Cerb is refusing to answer...apparently

Yes. Which then makes Drixx whole I'm coaching Shiro by Cyrano absurd so I decided when he does talk, just remove me from the equation to reduce noise.

[Frozen Angel]

If anything if FA predicted what Ank took N1, why didnt she just shoot Ank N1 then instead of shooting Cerb who kept saying he'd take BP anyway.
I dont think FA is scum in any scenario.

I also gave a person who I was about to kill a power role? like what?

I could simply give it to another scum partner and claim as such saying I didn't trust cerb well enough or some jackshit. I won't give someone a potential bp and try to kill them at night as scum. Taking night actions risk is not my scum meta. I believe scum should play natural and safe - should not force anything unnecessary and should always play optimum.

[Frozen Angel]

Titus whar do you think about cerb refusal to prove himself?

[Titus]

This game is making my head hurt...

Me too. I get the feeling that my scum game will suddenly be described as sextuple voter from Hell and my town game will be described as utter trash. Like Drixx and Math are really needing bdd

[Sando]

Yes. Which then makes Drixx whole I'm coaching Shiro by Cyrano absurd so I decided when he does talk, just remove me from the equation to reduce noise.

That's...not how this works. He's pointing out a reason for Shiro to do what he's doing as scum, which includes you. It's an associative read from what I can tell, you don't just get to remove yourself from the equation.

[Frozen Angel]

Do you think cerb medium is real or are we at devil's proof gambit?

[Sando]

It’d be a Titus gambit...
What did I tell you all was the one rule about Titus scum?

Fuck, you went to bed.

Explain please if you see this, repeat the one rule if necessary.

[Shiro]

He think it's a useless set of votes because he is confident he can read people without this particularly even happening.

As for being mediumed by anyone else, he says he would never answer such a question, especially if he was suspicious of me.

@Sakura he says that op specifically leaves room for other though it doesn't identify them.
Why do you object the supposition when you didn't at day 1 when it was talked about a lot and specifically the reason Titus was suspicious of Cerb
@Fa he says he thought you were referring to n1

[Sakura Hana]

@Sakura he says that op specifically leaves room for other though it doesn't identify them.
Why do you object the supposition when you didn't at day 1 when it was talked about a lot and specifically the reason Titus was suspicious of Cerb

????
Could you rephrase this? i dont understand what you're saying/asking here.

[Shiro]

He says you should all go back to playing mafia and stop giving unknown alignment! Shiro ways to hide by talking to him.

[Titus]

Titus whar do you think about cerb refusal to prove himself?

It's midnight in the US. Anything worth asking Cerb might fail due to fatigue. Give it 24-48 hours. There's enough questions here that cannot be searched I feel.

That being said, gun to my head, my gut says Shiro did not pick Cerb. The why not question is unsettling though. If scum lying, then who would help well enough and why wouldn't "Cerb" confirm immediately to avoid heat? If town lying... WTF would Shiro be doing?

No suggestion feels right.

[Shiro]

@Sakura he says that op specifically leaves room for other though it doesn't identify them.
Why do you object the supposition when you didn't at day 1 when it was talked about a lot and specifically the reason Titus was suspicious of Cerb

????
Could you rephrase this? i dont understand what you're saying/asking here.

I mean i would if I was certain what Cerb meant myself xD

[Shiro]

Boy this is more exhausting than I anticipated

[Drixx]

The only plausible reason for Cerb not to answer is to maintain doubt and suspicion on Shiro. The only reason to do that is if Cerb thinks that scum can shut off the ability.

The problem is that if Shiro actually has the ability and is town, then scum will shut it off the moment the scumbutt who can do it shows up. Cerb won't have the 48-72 hours to put an infodump together. He has to do it as rapidly as possible. Confirming that Shiro really is medium costs us nothing. It doesn't confirm Shiro as town even. It does allow us to move on with evaluating Titus and other things though.

Like ... if the world we're in has a town!Shiro who is a medium who is really talking to Cerb ... then scum either can or cannot do anything about it. Cerb confirming it doesn't impact that in any way.

And Cerb is way beyond smart enough to know that.

QED: Cerb isn't talking to Shiro.

[Sando]

As for being mediumed by anyone else, he says he would never answer such a question, especially if he was suspicious of me.

This makes no sense, you can't twist his words without giving yourself away to him.

The utility of not answering the initial question would be to put you, Shiro, in the position of saving your own hide by looking it up yourself, thus scumconfirming you to him. You've now, twice, said this wasn't his intention.

[Shiro]

I am though sooooooooooooo ha

[Sando]

It doesn't confirm Shiro as town even.

Would Cerb ever be silly enough to think you/others are silly enough to think it does?

[Shiro]

@Sakura

He is talking about scum factional a