Mini 2014: Succinct Mafia (Over)

[EeveeLution Army]

Now you're just making me laugh.
So im not lying considering you said lying basically 4 times just to make sure your point got across

[Umlaut]

MathBlade, all your reasoning about hypothetical bodyguards is based on the premise that scum have to kill it first because it stops them from killing their preferred target. If you had thought for two minutes about what the bodyguard actually does you would know this isn't true because they would just shoot at their preferred target and if a bodyguard prevents them it dies in exactly the same way as if they'd shot the bodyguard directly. This alone would be sufficient evidence that your hypoclaim is meritless, but there's also this:

Gonna be afk today and tomorrow. I am an okay mislynch if y’all can’t see I am town.

This is not something a protective role says. You're not a bodyguard and you're not fooling anyone into believing you might be.

I say you are Eevee's scumbuddy looking for an excuse to extend this 1v1 another day. There is just no way you have this strong an objection to resolving a 1v1 between protectives with no other PR to protect but were perfectly happy to push for a lynch of Fuzzy the uncountered cop claimant with a hidden protective still around.

This also explains perfectly why Eevee would counterclaim when he did. Ordinarily I'd think it was a bad decision vs. just shooting Pine that night, but if the only growing wagons were on him and his buddy Math then they had to do something drastic to avoid a scum lynch.

If you think I am the bodyguard then please listen to your one PR role when they tell you to back off.

Scum are going to want to get rid of the PR. The proper play is always to force scum to NK PRs.

If you townread me trust me on this.

I don't townread you any more. Nor do I think you're a PR even if you are town. And even if I did, PRs aren't handed out according to reasoning ability so I see no reason to listen to you over and above anyone else. Nice AtE though.

[Umlaut]

Anyway, it seems you and Eevee have both declined my conditions.

VOTE: EeveeLution Army

That's a hammer.

If Eevee flips red, lynch MathBlade next. Else lynch Pine, then look at {MafMen, Hiraki, Wisdom}. Start with MafMen as a Hiraki-Wisdom team seems unlikely.

[EeveeLution Army]

I guess town loses now if that is hammer, since pines gonna end up alive tomorrow night

[MathBlade]

MathBlade, all your reasoning about hypothetical bodyguards is based on the premise that scum have to kill it first because it stops them from killing their preferred target. If you had thought for two minutes about what the bodyguard actually does you would know this isn't true because they would just shoot at their preferred target and if a bodyguard prevents them it dies in exactly the same way as if they'd shot the bodyguard directly. This alone would be sufficient evidence that your hypoclaim is meritless, but there's also this:

Gonna be afk today and tomorrow. I am an okay mislynch if y’all can’t see I am town.

This is not something a protective role says. You're not a bodyguard and you're not fooling anyone into believing you might be.

I say you are Eevee's scumbuddy looking for an excuse to extend this 1v1 another day. There is just no way you have this strong an objection to resolving a 1v1 between protectives with no other PR to protect but were perfectly happy to push for a lynch of Fuzzy the uncountered cop claimant with a hidden protective still around.

This also explains perfectly why Eevee would counterclaim when he did. Ordinarily I'd think it was a bad decision vs. just shooting Pine that night, but if the only growing wagons were on him and his buddy Math then they had to do something drastic to avoid a scum lynch.

If you think I am the bodyguard then please listen to your one PR role when they tell you to back off.

Scum are going to want to get rid of the PR. The proper play is always to force scum to NK PRs.

If you townread me trust me on this.

I don't townread you any more. Nor do I think you're a PR even if you are town. And even if I did, PRs aren't handed out according to reasoning ability so I see no reason to listen to you over and above anyone else. Nice AtE though.

Bodyguards die for their townreads be it through lynch or NK.

I have said similar when I was a bodyguard and hammered a scumJailkeeper in a game I was in and got NK’d night one and saved the masons.

I know exactly how to WiFoM scum if you only let me

Army being lynched was stupid and she flips town.

[Umlaut]

You mean we’re amazing and caught you. Awesome.

[Umlaut]

If Eevee flips red, lynch MathBlade next. Else lynch Pine, then look at {MafMen, Hiraki, Wisdom}. Start with MafMen as a Hiraki-Wisdom team seems unlikely.

I have no idea why I momentarily thought Wisdom was on this list. {Mafmen, Hiraki, Lycanfire} as I said before.

[Wisdom]

yay we lynched both prs
we're rocking this

[Pine]

Yeah I'm looking at Wisdom next for his implausible certainty.

[TrinityNZ]

@mastina, is that a lynch?

[mastina]

VOTE: EeveeLution Army
That's a hammer.

<<< Indeed. >>>

[mastina]

<<< MafMen has requested replacement. Seeking. >>>

[mastina]

End of Day Votecount

EeveeLution Army - 6 (MafMen, Pine, Hiraki, TrinityNZ, Dunnstral, Umlaut)

Pine - 2 (EeveeLution Army, Wisdom)

Not Voting - 3 (Lycanfire, MathBlade, LuckyOtter)

6 to lynch.

[mastina]

I'm impressed at your dedication!
You really wanted to play mountainous!

EeveeLution Army

,

Town

Jailkeeper

,

Lynched D2

.

Spoiler: Role PM:

EeveeLution Army, Town Jailkeeper

EeveeLution Army

, you are a

Town

Jailkeeper

.
You may talk and vote during Day. During Night, you may target a player. They will be protected from harm and prevented from acting.
You win if all

mafia

are dead.

Game thread.
Confirm role via PM.

<<< Night 2 begins now.
Deadline will not be set until all slots are filled. >>>

[mastina]

<<< Jingle replaces MafMen. >>>

[mastina]

<<< N2 Deadline: (expired on 2018-07-27 16:19:46). >>>

[mastina]

Night action is locked in, but I lack computer access.
While I can ALMOST mod this game on my phone, I can't quite manage the feat.
As such, day start to come once my mom stops using the computer.

[mastina]

Umlaut

,

Vanilla Townie

,

Killed N2

.

Spoiler: Role PM

havingfitz/Umlaut, Vanilla Townie

havingfitz

Umlaut

, you are a

Vanilla Townie

.
You may talk and vote during Day, but have no powers.
You win if all

mafia

are dead.

Game thread.
Confirm role via PM.

<<< Day Three begins. >>>

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Pine

First

[TrinityNZ]

My thoughts exactly.

VOTE: Pine

[Pine]

What! How the fuck is this possible! Moderator lies! Bastard game!

VOTE: Mastina

Say what you want. I went from L-1 and flushing out the Doc and getting her lynched in my place.

*Mic drop*

[Hiraki]

Vote: Pine

[MathBlade]

<<Intent to vote Pine>>

I just don’t want this day to end yet til I can get a read on Jingle and Jingle can catch up and be off work sched from hell.

[Lycanfire]

i haven't read a damn thing in the last week, sup

[Lycanfire]

it's prob best just to lynch this so there's less to talk about when one of us drop dead tomorrow. i doubt jingle can break the game, and even if he does, he's gonna die. if you think he's town and don't want to evaluate how badly you want to kill him, shouldn't you want to give him MORE time?

VOTE: Pine

L-2