SUPP 2017 MAFIA: COMPLETE

[Commander Shepard]

I guess Chara was skeptical of the speed of hammers but I kind of don't think scum let Shepherd not get lynched yesterday if he's town. That's probably not very good reasoning though.

At some point I need to sit down and work up a flowchart of wtf is even going on in this game. Right now feeling better about Shepherd than anyone else though.

If you’re feeling better about me why are you voting me?

Wouldn’t you feel worse about me?

*confused*

Second off there is 11 alive likely 4 scum 1 SK and I doubt Vax is truthtelling but if he is then whatever he is.

This means 3 deaths possible overnight.
Lynch correctly or lose range

Shoshin if you have an explanation for why the fuck you are alive I wanna hear it.

[Commander Shepard]

Sheeping Maria.

Maria was a claimed cop; her death is explained as a PR kill.

I have a better idea for you.

Sheep Taly and TehBrawlGuy; neither was a PR kill, and both were kills likely on the merits of their play.

They are the players you want to listen to.

Additional reasoning for Commander Shepherd being town:
It is common belief that I am a 3p in this game. Were Commander Shepherd pun, I feel that Commander Shepherd would simply have shot our third neighbor N2 (a night we know was not a PR kill and was instead a play kill), so as to try and collaborate with me. (After all, what's the worst that could happen from a failed collaboration? They nightkill me, which they are able to do when sending the right person.)

This also works vice-versa, for why the neighbor is town. Were the neighbor pun, I'd expect the pun to have nightkilled Commander Shepherd, to try and collaborate with me. (After all, what's the worst that could happen from a failed collaboration? They nightkill me, which they are able to do when sending the right person.)

Given neither happened, it is then a safe assumption our neighborhood is all-town.

That is a pretty good argument for why I am not scum especially because TBG is a kill I don’t understand here. Like scum don’t kill a cop claim they don’t kill you they don’t kill anyone else. I don’t think they kill Dunn because Maria was a cop then why did scum kill TBG?

Like talk with me about your overarching view of the game. Because where I am at I am confused AF.
Shoshin should be dead yet no one talks about that.

Yet my wagon forms up easily in lylo.

[guacamole]

I'm confused too.

[Shoshin]

Maybe I didn't die because of role, not sure. I'm a ranking immune townie, which I thought meant I couldn't die from rankings but apparently it might extend to all roles based on rankings.

[Shoshin]

Scum usually leave cops alive when they can manipulate investigations, like godfather, lawyer, framer, redirector, sort of roles.

[Vaxkiller]

@MOD V/LA Until Sat evening.

Yeah I know its shit timing, but I will be traveling to Bethany Beach for vaca. I will be abel to catch up then, so if you guys can wait, even tho I showed no patience. If not. I'm sorry.

[Krazy]

I guess Chara was skeptical of the speed of hammers but I kind of don't think scum let Shepherd not get lynched yesterday if he's town. That's probably not very good reasoning though.

At some point I need to sit down and work up a flowchart of wtf is even going on in this game. Right now feeling better about Shepherd than anyone else though.

If you’re feeling better about me why are you voting me?

Wouldn’t you feel worse about me?

*confused*

Second off there is 11 alive likely 4 scum 1 SK and I doubt Vax is truthtelling but if he is then whatever he is.

This means 3 deaths possible overnight.
Lynch correctly or lose range

Shoshin if you have an explanation for why the fuck you are alive I wanna hear it.

Feel better about you = feel better about you (being the lynch for today)

[Krazy]

Mostly because I went to sleep and you were not hammered. Not very good but it sure does seem like there is real resistance to your wagon.

Although there also arent just a ton of people diving on fire. Still. In this gamestate hanging at l-2 for a day with this many scum seems telling to me.

[Dunnstral]

We have no reason to assume an sk

If you're not voting commander Shepard right now you're delaying

If you're not outing your cop result on the dead person you're really delaying

[Krazy]

if theres no sk then is punreader gf?

[Krazy]

the worst do you have another option other than vax today?

[DeasVail]

Hey Krazy, my thoughts on Shepard are still that they are more likely scum.

I was wanting more info from Vax though about exactly why they were convinced of Shepard being scum, but I wouldn't necessarily need that to proceed with the lynch I guess.

Also every fibre of my being is trying to revolt against suspecting Fire Assassin because how does all that mess come from scum? But I am strongly considering the idea that maybe he is just scum.

I will possibly be dropping my the worst scumread but more need more time to think on that.

I will check in more properly later.

[the worst]

the worst do you have another option other than vax today?

Shosh > Vax > Fire off the top of my head

I want massclaim tho.

[Krazy]

Well we have 11 players and at least two claims so who you waiting on?

[the worst]

everyone who hasn't claimed!!

I'm also away for the weekend so kinda obligated to half ass until I can do more work on this

[DeasVail]

I think we need Fire Assassin to check in before we consider a massclaim, though I wouldn't necessarily be opposed to it depending on what he posts.

Spoiler: Image

[Dunnstral]

I prefer me cop checking Maria than lynching her today.
Commander Shepherd is my pref lynch here.

Maria, do you think cross checking with Fire is a bad idea?

[the worst]

deas your kitty gifs are ftw

[Espeonage]

Sorry peeps, I've had a busy couple of days. I will have some time tomorrow.

[Errantparabola]

Votecount 4.2

Commander Shepard

(4): Dunnstral, Shoshin, Krazy/DeasVail

Fire Assassin

(1): Punreader

Shoshin

(1): Vaxkiller

Not Voting

(5): Espeonage, the worst, Fire Assassin, guacamole, Commander Shepard

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to achieve a majority.
Deadline in (expired on 2018-08-09 10:05:00)

[Espeonage]

Vote: Fire

Could lynch a few people though if for some ungodly reason people are going to be as stubborn as ever on Fire. (Which hint, makes me want it more, this much resistance is fucked up.)

Regardless of what people think in this Vax v Pun debate, if one of them is Sk they need scum dead as much as we do. There is no world where either of them get lynched today.

I really want to put this cop bullshit to rest, we know that Maria was town. It's time to lynch Fire.

[Dunnstral]

Or we can let punreader kill fire since his vig targets are limited

[the worst]

Intent to hammer

[Commander Shepard]

Had a long work shift destroying reapers.

Will address anything here tomorrow.

[Dunnstral]

I could vote fire today actually