Look at how he interacts with Lexa, his scum partner. There's a lot of distancing there, similar to the way he's treating Profii. And then Lexa's slot goes on to win the game after Aronis is lynched...
I mean, I dunno. I could be wrong about Aronis, or wrong about Profii. I'm not as confident about this as I'd like to be, but at the moment that's where I'm leaning. Gonna take a look at Creature now.
Like I saw what you are seeing wrt their interactions and I believe it's the first scumteam that I actually posited and at some point we should definitely lynch 1/2 of them if we don't get scum elsewhere but
Idk I don't really think he's scum
Don't really think Kokichi is scum either
Don't think Shoshin is scum
Don't think NSG is scum
Don't think Profii is scum
I know I'm not scum
Stungun/NR/Creature is the left over and all of them are decent scumreads >:]
How do you expect to find the culprit when you're all worried about each other's feelings? If you're planning to expose a liar, then you have to corner them psychologically.
Right I can talk about how we chose PMs which was what I was checking with schadd so I can clarify my Koki concerns
When I read the rules I took it as “you all will be put in 2 player lists then can swap in first 72 hours”
I didn’t really clarify this but when the threads appeared I just waited for playerlists to appear
It was only when prompted that schadd made us pick a PM that I even realised we had to
so given that I would expect mod pms to all be the same, I expect we weren’t the only confused pair - especially given there seemed to be a delay to game start
So given Koki said Gamma went ahead and picked a certain PM, that means one PM appeals more than the other imo
this would be a drastic change of her reads, so why shouldn't i be concerned if without reason? she stated you as a clear scum lean provable by meta and me as town on like page 14. it wouldn't have made sense for her to change her mind that much on both of us that quickly
also, i'm talking with my friemd about sth right now, but gif certainly looks scummier to me for a particular push he made. i just want to see if my friemd sees what i'm seeing
In post 443, GirlInFreezer wrote:RC/NSG/Shoshin
Profii
Aronis/Kokichi
NR, Stungun (null)
Creature
is where I'm at rn
anyways i guess i mostly agree with this? well, maybe not entirely specifically, but if you were to squint hard enough i guess
i think creature is just honestly first and foremost, but beyond that i would put stungun above aronis and kokichi who i both think have a pretty decent shot of being scum
on nicorobin i honestly have no idea but if i had to just take a guess i would say she might not pick scum so i guess that's a minor reason to townread her
what i'm getting out of all of these are that aronis and kokichi both seem like people i'd be fine lynching at the moment
what are you thoughts then about GIF / NSG / Shoshin largely aligning with their reads in these posts
or is it just Shoshins change of direction that bugs you
In post 100, schadd_ wrote:stungun0404 (3): profii, GirlInFreezer, Shoshin
Yah, get off
creature's likely to be town this game. he got me mislynched in lynchpin mafia on d1, where him and nsg were scum, so him discouraging a repeat of that with this comment reads like it's likely to be coming from town creature. basically, the only thing that limits my thinking here is that he stated it after the wagon has already died down, so i don't know --> could be genuine, but could also see it being a wise placement of pocketing (but i find this so much less likely; it depends on whether creature!scum pockets players which i don't really think he does). so i feel safe to assume creature is town for now. occam's razor takes effect!
Like, this is a pretty good post from Stun. I don't see him making it as scum regardless of Creature's alignment.
(I don't actually think it is towny regardless of context but your mileage may vary. I do have points where I'm questioning my stungun scumread but my reasons to scumread there >>>> my reasons to townread.)
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}