Heroes Wanted! (Game Over)

[stungun0404]

And plus so i can see the town hints shiro gave off

[Frozen Angel]

a player can use factional and super powers in same night:

9. Unless otherwise specified, players may only use one Superpower per Night Phase. For Aspiring Villains, this is in addition to any factional abilities they may have (including their factional nightkill).
10. Factional Abilities for the Aspiring Villains are not treated as Superpowers.

Derp

Then still why nothing N2? I am having trouble thinking of a town reason to not do it.

He was playing in MU anniverssary - a 131 player mafia game - at that time. I believe when he say he forgot.

[MathBlade]

Furthermore Drixx was in no way sketchy.

well he was for a decent portion of the thread

I think nancy would have been a better mimic target tbh. She wasn't the topic enough and is just coasting and getting powers by me cause she looks cute :/ It's the day we should resolve her/talk about her more imo.

Also the day 1 was trog town meta 100%. his last minute protectiveness of titus is making me a little bit worried though. one thing about trog is that he over protects his scum mates. Like even if he wants to force that through he will.

No. He wasn’t lol

I guess for the ufo bit but it doesn’t sit right.

And regarding Nancy I agree. Just I am a bit confused on something

[Frozen Angel]

I can see a team like toog katsuki and nancy remaining.

Maybe kokichi, nosfertu

the worst

idk. I actually think toog/katsuki has a definite scum in it

[MathBlade]

Leaders can choose 5 people with them a total of 6

I have nancy in my list too

I was thinking about rechecking the slot.

With the powers you have chosen how would you recheck the slot?

[MathBlade]

I can see a team like toog katsuki and nancy remaining.

Maybe kokichi, nosfertu

the worst

idk. I actually think toog/katsuki has a definite scum in it

I am pretty sure Nancy is town and this is just paranoia FA.

[Frozen Angel]

I was short on my fifth pick back then.

I was thinking about isoing nancy to choose her as fifth. I asked several people about their reads on her

I did skim read her and she just sounds pure af so i went with it

[stungun0404]

Mathblade, you would know this as well as anybody. Is it a mistake for me to base many reads off titus associatives?

[stungun0404]

That is the majority of how i got a hard scumread on shiro, so i am thinking it might be

[MathBlade]

I was short on my fifth pick back then.

I was thinking about isoing nancy to choose her as fifth. I asked several people about their reads on her

I did skim read her and she just sounds pure af so i went with it

Pure as fuck generally (but not always) is town. What makes you suspicious of her?

[Frozen Angel]

I can see a team like toog katsuki and nancy remaining.

Maybe kokichi, nosfertu

the worst

idk. I actually think toog/katsuki has a definite scum in it

I am pretty sure Nancy is town and this is just paranoia FA.

I just want us to talk about and challenge the last slot who could be a scum that titus gave power to a little more.'

why is she town?

[Toranaga]

a player can use factional and super powers in same night:

9. Unless otherwise specified, players may only use one Superpower per Night Phase. For Aspiring Villains, this is in addition to any factional abilities they may have (including their factional nightkill).
10. Factional Abilities for the Aspiring Villains are not treated as Superpowers.

Derp

Then still why nothing N2? I am having trouble thinking of a town reason to not do it.

I just forgot

like you know, you in that alisae game.

like people who forget to vote leader.

/shrug happens

[Frozen Angel]

if titus wanted to go with an all town list she could pick drixx who was also in her list and would make way more sense for her cause like who beleives drixx is town and doesn't give him power?

I'm just trying to spin this chess board to see why titus made that choice back then and why scum are killing people who can protect themselves this easily.

[Frozen Angel]

Also I'm not saying she is neccessirly scum. It's just a poe that I want resolved so can you explain your reads on her a little more practical?

[MathBlade]

Mathblade, you would know this as well as anybody. Is it a mistake for me to base many reads off titus associatives?

It is mostly a mistake until you figure out Titus’s narrative.

Titus didn’t completely abandon the plan so it’s likely she tried to survive the day. This means that when she was dying bussing an ally with powers would be silly. So Creature is likely vanilla town.

It’s mainly about starting from truth and working from there
Rather than Titus pushed X therefore X is town

[stungun0404]

Creature could be scum without a power though, as titus was scum WITH a power. so i would not say creature cannot be scum here

[stungun0404]

As leader she has first dibs on picking a power, right?

[Frozen Angel]

what do you mean first dibs?

[MathBlade]

It's okay, after Titus flips scum it'll be very telling if Shiro DOES link her.

She won't, I am pretty certain if that.

Shiro, if scum kills you you won’t get to spirit link ANYONE ELSE in the game.

You’re seriously not risking your life for Titus, are you?

Reasons Nancy is town
1) Her high post count. Nancy if memory serves said she hasn’t drawn scum tend to be a bit less posty and chatty because they back themselves into a corner
2) She advocated for Shiro to BP himself. It seems like a really odd post to do if scum “Hey person we’re gonna kill please put on a bulletproof vest” if Nancy had power negation and was scum this would be irrelevant as the night action would have to resolve so Nancy as scum gains nothing by doing this
3) As you put it her genuiness

For starters

[Frozen Angel]

I never saw nancy scum but this is way more purer than her last town game I saw. i admit. I really want to know what did she do night 2.

[MathBlade]

Creature could be scum without a power though, as titus was scum WITH a power. so i would not say creature cannot be scum here

I don’t find that very likely. Not only is Creature townpinging while here (and he is an easy meta read) he didn’t try to stop the Titus lynches and he seems more concerned with catching up and getting reads than attacking anyone.

[MathBlade]

I never saw nancy scum but this is way more purer than her last town game I saw. i admit. I really want to know what did she do night 2.

As do I but there is no reason to attach the could be scum in order to obtain it.

[Frozen Angel]

I never saw nancy scum but this is way more purer than her last town game I saw. i admit. I really want to know what did she do night 2.

As do I but there is no reason to attach the could be scum in order to obtain it.

Sure

[MathBlade]

I picked power negation night 2. Haven't used it so far though.

and also yeah fair point math. I think the people titus suggested strongly and pushed strongly yesterday and the day before are not the ones she gave power negation too if any yep

Can you tell me why you didn’t use this?

Something is pinging me about your power statements.

[MathBlade]

Especially with your whole “power negation” talks before.