Fallout Mafia - Commonwealth Edition (Day 8)

[Ankamius]

Should've trusted my gut when I saw the progression from day five to now

Oh well, I made a huge mistake on day two that probably cemented the late game loss so I can't really complain about it

[Dunnstral]

And if one of our claimed prs was one of two pun alive right now? The balance would be way off

So I don't believe this ATM

[Dunnstral]

---

Fallout Mafia - Commonwealth Edition

Players

1. Wilky
   
2. hebichan/OnTheMark,
   Commonwealth Strong Roleblocker
   , killed Night 4.
   
3. Kaede Akamatsu,
   Commonwealth Innocent Child Action Passer
   , killed Night 5.
   
4. ManWithNoName,
   Commonwealth Vanilla
   , killed Night 1.
   
5. MariaR,
   Institute 1-shot Bulletproof 1-shot Strongarm Reconnoisseur
   , lynched Day 4.
   
6. Wraith,
   Commonwealth Vanilla
   , lynched Day 2.
   
7. Ramcius/YT2980/Prof Fridays
   
8. Ankamius
   
9. Ouroboros (AnonymousGhost + RadiantCowbells),
   Commonwealth Modified Neighborizer Tracker
   , killed Night 2.
   
10. Tchill13/punreader
    
11. Dunnstral
    
12. verylazy/Kokichi Oma,
    Commonwealth Vanilla
    , lynched Day 6.
    
13. Impossibear (EspeciallyTheLies + Jingle),
    Commonwealth Compulsive 1-shot Bulletproof Conditional Vigilante
    , killed Night 3.
    
14. davesaz,
    Commonwealth Miller
    , lynched Day 5.
    
15. Ventriloquist,
    Institute Factional Ability Swapper
    , lynched Day 1.
    
16. Alchemist21,
    Commonwealth Weapon Vendor
    , killed Night 6.
    
17. Nero Cain/projectmatt,
    Institute Rolecop
    , lynched Day 3.
    
18. REALMEN ONLY JUNGLE

These don't look like "5 scum in 18 person game" power roles

[Ankamius]

Shhhh Dunnstral I still have my strong double kill remember

[Punreader]

17 players is a 4 scum game, 21 players is a 5 scum game, this game has 18 players

Blame GuyInFreezer.

I didn't make the broken setup; I just exploited it.

Oh well, I made a huge mistake on day two that probably cemented the late game loss so I can't really complain about it

If it makes a difference to you, Ank, I really did want to nightkill you, I just never got a chance because I had better kills to make. Safer kills that weren't neon signs pointing to me being pun. There's high praise of you mixed with healthy dosages of fear in the pun PT.

[Ankamius]

How did you two react to me supporting you on dave

[Punreader]

How did you two react to me supporting you on dave

Cried tears of joy that it actually worked.

I'm also quite surprised you didn't notice that I used a classical old trick there; put all stock into one punread and then continuously be lost afterwards to justify mislynching prior townreads.

[Ankamius]

I think the part that fooled me more was your overall lack of presence day six and knowing that it wasn't AI

[Punreader]

I think the part that fooled me more was your overall lack of presence day six and knowing that it wasn't AI

It wasn't. I'd have been just as inactive as town. Arguably more.

I do confess to overextending myself a little, so I am quite pleased I have one less commitment on my hands.

I am sad the town didn't win since you played more than well enough for it and at every stage I felt guilty for lynching these players that I knew I should by all rights be defending.

Alas. 'Tis what it is.

[Ankamius]

Anyways

I think if I had tried to be a rock for Kaede and pushed my wraith townread harder, I think the game would've been a lot different. The Wraith lynch was devastating in effect since it meant Impossibear had to push for the projectmatt lynch day three instead of having it day two and having them be around for a push on... potentially Ramcius?

[Ankamius]

I think the part that fooled me more was your overall lack of presence day six and knowing that it wasn't AI

It wasn't. I'd have been just as inactive as town. Arguably more.

I do confess to overextending myself a little, so I am quite pleased I have one less commitment on my hands.

I am sad the town didn't win since you played more than well enough for it and at every stage I felt guilty for lynching these players that I knew I should by all rights be defending.

Alas. 'Tis what it is.

Nah I don't think town deserves a win, the early game was a massive mess and the ones of us that were left didn't pick up the pieces well enough

[Punreader]

Anyways

I think if I had tried to be a rock for Kaede and pushed my wraith townread harder, I think the game would've been a lot different. The Wraith lynch was devastating in effect since it meant Impossibear had to push for the projectmatt lynch day three instead of having it day two and having them be around for a push on... potentially Ramcius?

I mean I did tell you Wraith was town.

Of course my plan was to push Ouroboros instead of Wraith, but being V/LA without advanced knowledge of the gamestate while you're eager for a lynch will do that. (My punbuddies were rather unhelpful in regards to helping me catch up. Which I never properly did, mind you. I coulda during the night, but I always got distracted by other obligations, so I really never did read the game.)

[Punreader]

Nah I don't think town deserves a win, the early game was a massive mess and the ones of us that were left didn't pick up the pieces well enough

That's because the players most critical to cohesion, minus yourself, were also the players who held the strongest roles in the game. So their deaths had the unfortunate side-effect of disrupting town cohesion.

I do hold that the town really does deserve to win this game.

It's just that with this lynch they didn't.

[Ankamius]

You never would've gotten away with an Ouroboros lynch, he's the type of player I don't generally townread, so having that strong of a read was going to stop me from ever agreeing to it

[Punreader]

You never would've gotten away with an Ouroboros lynch, he's the type of player I don't generally townread, so having that strong of a read was going to stop me from ever agreeing to it

Well how was I supposed to know that given you had an identically-strong townread on projectmatt?

[Ankamius]

You don't unless you know my history with both of them, which is why it's probably good that you didn't get to go that route

[Ankamius]

my history of reading Nero Cain is abysmal and I've never played with pmatt before, so

I used to be able to tell the difference between RCs towngame and scumgame, but I both don't remember what the difference is not think that it's relevant anymore

[Punreader]

You don't unless you know my history with both of them, which is why it's probably good that you didn't get to go that route

Well it ended up good for

me

...

[Ankamius]

Actually I don't have an abysmal read rate with Nero Cain, but I don't have a set way of reading him like other players

[Ankamius]

You don't unless you know my history with both of them, which is why it's probably good that you didn't get to go that route

Well it ended up good for

me

...

Tbh if I had caught you on day two amongst the locktown reads a lot of people had on you, that would've probably made me even more useless after the townblock dwindled

[Punreader]

You don't unless you know my history with both of them, which is why it's probably good that you didn't get to go that route

Well it ended up good for

me

...

Tbh if I had caught you on day two amongst the locktown reads a lot of people had on you, that would've probably made me even more useless after the townblock dwindled

Were people townreading me that much on D2? I honestly thought it wasn't until D3 or D4 that started to happen.

[Ankamius]

I thought so? It might have been D3 idk

[Ankamius]

Now that I think about it, your response to my setup questions were scummy too

[Dunnstral]

If wilky doesn't end the game we lynch Punreader

They're going to claim it was a reaction test of course, I think it looks like a scum gambit

[Ankamius]

shrug

I don't think that's a gambit solo-scum Pun does but who knows