But his actions make sense from S C C U M and make no sense at all from T O W N especially going along with the tchill L Y N C C.In post 2070, ofrhz wrote:meme, someone not playing the mechanically optimal way doesn't make them scum
I think he has M O T I V A T I O N and is not just a T O W N playing poorly.
But if the D U C C is T O W N, I do not agree with the N O L Y N C C. We have two actions: L Y N C C and the H I D D. We only instantly lose if they are exactly {t, s}.
If they are {t, s} and we do not L Y N C C, tomorrow the D U C C will be dead and one other T O W N will be S H O T T. Then we L Y N C C the guilty and another T O W N will be S H O T T.
The result is 3:2 with no informative day phase d4
and the second S C C U M M I E S T player, who is actually town, will still be alive
. I think we will probably lose anyway in this case and it is not worth P L A N N I N G around.I believe we should L Y N C C the S C C U M M I E S T player. If they flip T O W N, then the D U C C should specifically look for an I N N O on null-town players (not telegraphed). If his reads are wrong, we lose, but we already have an extremely low W I N R A T E in this case.
If they flip S C C U M, then the D U C C should visit the consensus S E C O N D S C C U M M I E S T.
VOTE: Mumble
HEAL: osuka
