In post 522, Tchill13 wrote:Why share all my raisins exactly?why let scum know if I'm on them and why I'm on them?
Because town don't have a PT to discuss these sorts of things? Like huh? Scum already know they're scum so they won't be learning much (except I guess what to avoid in the future, but it's too late to change what they've already done) - in fact they usually start playing worse when they feel caught, making it easier to lynch them.
In post 523, Tchill13 wrote: In post 518, Irrelephant11 wrote:okay but like, what's the test?
Also agreed with whoever said Nauci is sadly low content lately
As is NSG who I would happily wagon atm
I don't see a case on alchemist so please do elaborate
The test is creating actions and reactions, content on day 1.
Okay, what do you think/how do you read the actions and reactions? You've provided very little of this, especially as pressure has come your way.
Like you said at the beginning of the game that you didn't answer my question as a reaction test. Then you got my reaction, and you said now you know my playstyle, but not my alignment. How does that help? Is it my town playstyle or my scum playstyle? In retrospect it sounds like you already knew I was town and wanted to know how to deal with me. You also didn't provide any thoughts on the other players who reacted then. In every "reaction test" you've done since, you've failed to clear up what the test is FOR, how it helps you sort other players, etc. <--- Makes me think you're not actually trying to sort, because you're scum who doesn't need to sort.
In post 526, Tchill13 wrote:Irrelephant what's your stance on players that scum can use to make it easier for them to win? Do you not feel that those players are tools for scum to use? Essentially a lesser form of a PR for scum.
Can we at least agree that if you were scum you'd want lurkers in lylo?
Why am I scum exactly? Because I'd like to push an easy lynch on a lurker day 1?
Answer all those in order please.
I don't think any player is a "tool". I like to give all players a chance to towntell. You're also conveniently ignoring my point that PRs do a lot of the sorting that you seem to want to use our lynch to do. Without any successful protections, we get
at most
6 lynches this game (if it goes to 3p lylo). I don't care to waste any lynches on someone who's hard to sort just because I'm afraid of a potential lylo (unless townreads and PoE leads me there). It's up to lurkers to play the game; if all the lurkers are town this game and we lose because they're hard to sort then we lost as a team because half the team didn't play. Unfortunate. But I'm also not going to spend every game riding lurkers for lurking if it's not a scumtell for them.
Yes, if I were scum I'd want lurkers in lylo. If I were scum in a game with 5 lurkers, though, I might just line them up as lynches and go down the line, who knows?
You're scummy because you don't want to lynch players you think are scummy, you want to lynch players you think are hard to sort. There are better ways to sort, and lynchbait is called lynchbait
because
they're easy lynches for scum in the info void that is D1.
Also I'm voting Kop (one of the lurkers) while other players are voting you - why do you feel the need to appeal to me so much about this?
I did my best to answer all your questions, I don't think they're in perfect order but there you go
