In post 1191, Chickadee wrote:Don't panic unless there's a reason to. I decided to catch up since there wasn't much, and at the end of my catch up it was already revealed. So why panic at that point?
on the surface I thought I understood this but when I think a bit more about it it doesn't make any sense
quick definitions
Time A - Pine making the second guess
Time B - mod revealing second guess was right
the panic point should have been seeing Pine make a second guess (Time A). NSG is saying town have reason to panic when they see that, and your lack of panic indicates scum mindset.
You are suggesting you arrived at some point between A and B, and started working on a catchup post. But town shouldn't have known that there was no reason to panic until after Time B. So you're not refuting what NSG has said.
Then, you say after Time B, there's no reason to panic. Which is true, but runs contrary to your suggestion that you were actively catching up between Time A and Time B.
So I feel you are being disingenuous with this explanation and conflating two different times (prior to Time B, post Time B) to justify a suspicious lack of panic that should have happened between Time A and Time B.
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
