Forgotten Hourglass [Game Over]

[MariaR]

It doesn't because the logic stems from moment

[Sakura Hana]

Oh ok.
I still want someone to explain to me why muffin tries to kill Katsuki N1 and moreover has an inno on him and then poisons Katsuki

[Wisdom]

im here to switch to muffin if one more does

[MariaR]

Wasn't it conf that the Muffin inno was fake? Am I wrong on that? UNVOTE:
The poison logic can just be because Kat claimed an invest yeah?

[Sakura Hana]

Wasn't it conf that the Muffin inno was fake? Am I wrong on that? UNVOTE:
The poison logic can just be because Kat claimed an invest yeah?

It's possibly fake, it's possibly isn't, but a scum muffin that knows that katsuki's inno was fake and that his cop shots were super useless doesnt go killing Katsuki coz he's not a threat, and moreover it's defending him.

[Sakura Hana]

Like I just dont see that poison coming from a scumteam that knew what happened between muffin/katsuki in the hood.

[Sakura Hana]

However if a scum team believed that Katsuki had a correct inno, they have way more incentive to poison him, no?

[MariaR]

You have a point.

[MariaR]

Wouldn't they know kat was an inno regardless cause brain?

[MariaR]

Does scum Muffin kill the doc save ye? Or do they leave kat alone

[MariaR]

mmmm Muffin's play late game today has been so bad compared to prof though.

[Sakura Hana]

Wouldn't they know kat was an inno regardless cause brain?

im not saying that kat was an inno, im saying katsuki's announced inno on muffin.
And even then we still dont know the nature of the inno, could be faked or couldnt be faked.
Regardless if muffin's scum i dont think what he learned from the hood would make him consider Katsuki a threat, and Katsuki would defend muffin because inno.

As I said, if scum team believed that Katsuki correctly got an inno on muffin they have more incentive to poison Katsuki.

[Sakura Hana]

I dunno muffin looks more like he hasnt had time than just lurking.

[MariaR]

I don't think the inno part is why Muffin would kill Kat. It's that Kat was clear in the first place

[Sakura Hana]

Over the people pushing him?
At this point in the game where Kats was defending him?
And we don't even know the nature of the inno, it might be true, or it might be deduction from whatever result katsuki got.

[MariaR]

im not even caught up on the game, if you couldn't fucking tell from me quoting something like 25 pages back rofl

thanks for looking out for me, dunnstral

Kill him before we says something about the "inno" - if he ever does

after claiming for me to prevent me getting lynched

Kill him before he can check other people, making his job harder

while he's claiming an inno on me

Kill him so it looks like he's cleared before Katsuki can elaborate

even though cupcake could have "elaborated" at any point d2 if this was the case

yeah, not sure how i ever stood a chance against the your amazing deduction skills

i'm reading spiffeh as town for something i probably shouldn't be town-reading him for and i'm not going to talk about

=]

i think he's more likely to be town than scum anyway

and i doubt sakura is scum

which leaves you and mariar as potential poisoners

(unsure which of the gunsmiths haven't been checked yet but really those should all be double-checked by multiple sources if we dont hit poisoner today, just in case)

i wouldn't kill nancy because i don't think she's good at finding scum lol

prodge

1 week of content compared to prof like. I would feel bad not lynching this over Prof like do you think Prof late game play is really scum when they were about to be lynched? The inno isn't the issue here imo It's the doc save itself.
VOTE: Muffin
Scum Muffin kills the Doc and Poisons there friend who they know won't go after them for that day phase. Seems pretty likely to me no? Supporting a fake guilty etc
Pedit: Didn't someone say that Kat outright said the inno was not reliable in the hood? I'll go look myself but I'm pretty sure I remember that.

[MariaR]

uh sakura can you link the pt's for me whenever I click the next page the tab is fking up for me.

[Sakura Hana]

Well yeah, but all we know is what Kat said in the hood is not like we know what kind of result he got or what kind of role he had.

As for prof. I still dont like how he opened the day going like "Why arent we killing the people that Math mentioned"

[Sakura Hana]

Arent they in the first OP, called Step 1, Step 2, etc.

[Sakura Hana]

Actually it says Hourglass 1st Turn and Hourglass 2nd Turn

[MariaR]

Oh ty

[MariaR]

Subject: Hourglass 1st Turn PT

the hilarious thing about this game is

i actually have a cop ability
it's just awful and virtually useless until further into the game and is basically one-shot, requires two targets to yield a result and prerequisite is that the first target has to die before the second works properly

So if it's 1 shot where did the inno come from and who was the 2nd target

[Sakura Hana]

He's a JOAT, what makes u think he used that cop ability and not one of his supposed other 2 1-shot abilities to get an inno on muffin.

[Moment]

VOTE: Muffin
Since Spiffy isn't happening.

Huh? Isn't everyone else a townread given that me and Spiffeh are scum? Why is Prof a townread because of preflip associations but muffins isn't?

[Sakura Hana]

Like idk, all the evidence points to muffin being mechanically clear, yet people STILL want to lynch him.
I'd expect SCUM muffin to be able to lynch cop innos and save cop guilties considering how his scum game is, but this is just >___>