Krazy
FA_Q2
These basically do not change at this point (I know each of these players very well and am very confident in my read now):
The Worst Toranaga Fredrick A Campbell*I am hoping I am not suffering from Taly!Syndrome but I still feel strong about this read
Saudade
HeWhoSwims horrordude0215
Saudade
HeWhoSwims horrordude0215
Likely town:
texcat
-- I know texcat's playstyle pretty well and this does not look like scum!texcat. Very close to darkgreen.Havo
-- don't know this person at all, could be wrong, but lost sheep seems like a pretty likely explanationSlight townlean
Gamma Emerald I Am Innocent
-- Hammer suggests I seriously have to consider that my first impression here was wrong, but it remains quite possible that I simply overestimated Gamma's townplayCompletly Trustworthy
-- I was saying likely conftown when I was feeling more certain on Garmr and when I thought his push was harder, on rereading the slot I am less certain this is town. Still, his points have been pretty good. His points about FA/DT were correct, the distancing there was kinda "not good". I kinda think a town!CT would have responded more to my push on Garmr, but it could be that my defense of FA was just that bad and observer effect is damaging my read.Sort these for game win
Skygazer
-- Maybe Sky's early game is very different from her lategame but this feels very different than the Sky I knowBest solve for 3/3
Garmr
-- viewtopic.php?p=10397913#p10397913 this looks like scum!Garmr to me, but I have struggled with reading this particular player in the past. Wh4t
-- Basically his early posts are active!town frontloaded and then he goes into lurk mode which seems pretty scummy. OMGUS near the end of his post history seems very much at odds with the thought process and apparent scumhunting of earlier in the dayphase.RadiantCowbells
-- says he's super good at this game, so I'm less certain he's just a [redacted] Seriously there is some grade A anti-replace-in behavior from Radiant. Dude should be lynched tomorrow regardless of alignment just so the rest of you have a solid chance of actually solving the game. Since he insists he's just the best at mafia, I am no longer willing to accept the argument he's just [redacted]. And I have other reasons to suspect his claim is fake or at the very least that there is no town-sided jailkeeper so his role is at best useless. I actually thought his claim looked like something a VT would do but I think a flip would be a good way to find out at this point. The thread would be easier to read without his constant [redacted] posting. He is a player that firmly believes in open wolfing and if anyone says that he is simply VI and not scum they are probably a buddy. Lynch immediately.
