NY 215: HMS Erebus - Game Over!

[Malakittens]

Also I can't really meta CT off one game. So there's no other games to compare his one town game to so therefore i wouldn't actually know how he plays as scum.

AKA meta'ing him is useless and i'm going off questioning him and how he interacts etc

[Completly Trustworthy]

Here are my reads so far:
Io seems town since they have a similar way of playing to me(questioning everything), have an understandable reason for voting, and made some of the first posts that were not in the RVS stage.
I think Davesaz is town because they are asking good questions like in 65 and 94. So far they seem to be probing players who we need to know more about.
I believe its likely that at least one of Popo and Lapsa is scum. I looked very weak to a push at the time when they voted me up, so they seemed incredibly opportunistic to me. I've seen scum vote up players claiming they want a policy lynch more than I've seen town do it. However, I think it is unlikely both are scum, claiming you want a policy lynch within the first few pages is suspicious enough that two scum would probably not do it together. I'm not sure which is more suspicious. Popo has supplied less content than Lapsa, but Lapsa only claimed he wanted me policy lynched after Popo.
I have mostly neutral reads on everyone else at the moment.

[Krazy]

Votecount 1.4

Nosferatu(3)

~ Garmr(6), Completly Trustworthy(10), tictac(5)

Completly Trustworthy(3)

~ Io(11), popopopopopopo(6), Lapsa(13)

tictac(2)

~ davesaz(8), GammaEmerald(9)

Umlaut(1)

~ Malakittens(7)

Garmr(1)

~ Nosferatu(12)

GammaEmerald(1)

~ Purrcocet(6)

davesaz(1)

~ Umlaut(1)


Not Voting (3): ManWithNoName(0), Akarin(0), Killthestory(0)

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline is in (expired on 2018-09-19 07:00:00)

MOD REMINDERS

ManWithNoName has never posted. Please verify player interest.
Akarin has never posted. Please verify player interest.
Killthestory has never posted. Please verify player interest.

Garmr is still V/LA

NOTE

KTS and MWNN have yet to pick up their role PMs. I have a replacement already lined up so they have 24 hours from this post before they are immediately replaced.

[Nosferatu]

Are you going to dismount your high horse and play soon?

what makes you think i havent already

[Nosferatu]

i am very down for a policy lynch on this guy im not reading those posts

angling for a 3 of a kind this game

[Io]

Hmph, if all of you town read me I can't deduce which of you are scum trying to suck up to me.

Nos, I need you to take over for a bit.

[Io]

Actually nevermind. It's definatly CT who is sucking up to me.
"Io seems town since they have a similar way of playing to me"

[Nosferatu]

Alright

here's what we're not doing

we're not lynching CT *today*

ive played with people like that and his stiff tone makes it feel like hes always buddying or trying too hard.

[Nosferatu]

here's who we are wagoning atm, VOTE: malakittens

[Lapsa]

VOTE: Malakittens

[Io]

I don’t know if I can kill that.
My weakness is cute kittens.

[davesaz]

What do you think about Lapsa's apparent need to sheep?

[Lapsa]

speaking about sucking up gives permission to suck up

[Completly Trustworthy]

Why did you vote for Malakittens Nosferatu? I looked through their ISO and saw nothing suspicious except their vote on Umlaut, which seemed pretty weak. Was it because of that?

[Gamma Emerald]

Why did you vote for Malakittens Nosferatu? I looked through their ISO and saw nothing suspicious except their vote on Umlaut, which seemed pretty weak. Was it because of that?

I think Mala's Umlaut vote seems fair but that's because I also find Umlaut's behavior suspicious in the post she voted him for

[Nosferatu]

Why did you vote for Malakittens Nosferatu? I looked through their ISO and saw nothing suspicious except their vote on Umlaut, which seemed pretty weak. Was it because of that?

it doesnt really matter

[Purrcocet]

here's who we are wagoning atm, VOTE: malakittens

you spelled gamma emerald wrong

[Purrcocet]

I think Mala's Umlaut vote seems fair but that's because I also find Umlaut's behavior suspicious in the post she voted him for

..........................his rvs post and only single post

[Umlaut]

@Mod: Please replace me out.

Sorry, I thought I'd have more time for this game but I have too much on my plate IRL.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think Mala's Umlaut vote seems fair but that's because I also find Umlaut's behavior suspicious in the post she voted him for

..........................his rvs post and only single post

So? Point is I think Mala's logic is fair

[Nosferatu]

you spelled gamma emerald wrong

mala >> gamma >> ?

[Nosferatu]

Io is gonna deepwolf either way

[Nosferatu]

I think Mala's Umlaut vote seems fair but that's because I also find Umlaut's behavior suspicious in the post she voted him for

so that's why you didn't vote with her?

[Io]

VOTE: Malakittens

Gamma-Mala could be a thing.
119 is very pingy.

[Nosferatu]

how many scum we agreeing on btw? I kinda assumed it was 3 but apparently this isn't a mini