like to me, my main issue with BnL (Single) this game is that
A) It really seems like you're doing nothing to solve the game
B) It seems like as soon as somebody questions your kind of shoddy reasoning, you just pull out altogether and try to redirect it
If you’re saying that you didn’t like my reads because they were too generic, that’s because I’m tired right now. I’m recollecting pings I got earlier when I wrote them. If you want I can explain them better tomorrow.
In post 76, Scoobert D Doobert wrote:you're voting him for not responding to an accusation, like right after you'd already said "nevermind this isn't a strong read at all"
Yeah, but he didn’t know I’d had said that when he goes through the thread. I think it will be natural for town to do so.
A) It really seems like you're doing nothing to solve the game
B) It seems like as soon as somebody questions your kind of shoddy reasoning, you just pull out altogether and try to redirect it
I don’t have many strong reads yet, so a lot of my reads at this points are really stretches. The truth is that my reads are still weak at this point, just that I don’t show it. So I see what you mean by A, and explains B
In post 68, singletonking wrote:I definitely interpret accusations of being opportunistic as being scummy. Why are people saying otherwise?
Doing something scummy =/= scumread. If town never did scummy things this game would be a lot easier. I’ll also say again, this game won’t be that black and white given the variety of possible wincons in play.
Though now with another vote jump I’m starting to slight scumread you. Not enough to change vote yet though.
In post 41, RCEnigma wrote:Well if you think he's scum then we trade one for one right? I think that's a town sided exchange unless it's like 5 mafia 4 town, then we'll...unfortunate. To be fair I'd rather vote you first hence the vote.
You know, the more this gets posted, the worse it looks.
How does this point of view make any sense from a town perspective? Especially if it's not a reaction test?
OK so the progression from my side was very linear.
A.) Not a good scumread from Singleton on Doc
Insert post, if Singleton believes this is a solid scumread then stick by it, if not let it go.
B.) Singleton realizes this was not a good basis to firm a scumread.
I'm thinking we let whatever scum kill the IC and see if we get power back at that point
Don't wanna lynch the only conftown
And if scum decide not to kill the IC then we keep a conftown, great
In post 78, singletonking wrote:If you’re saying that you didn’t like my reads because they were too generic, that’s because I’m tired right now. I’m recollecting pings I got earlier when I wrote them. If you want I can explain them better tomorrow.
Well i mean have you been tired all game? Not tryna grill you, but to me it just seems real easy for a scum member to sit on the fence all day and give out things that seem like they're hot takes, but in reality it's just "I think you're town because you are scumhunting". It's like biting into sandwich and it's just bread. So now, who knows what kind of sandwich it was?
Just my POV. Maybe tomorrow your stances will jump out at me more!
In post 41, RCEnigma wrote:Well if you think he's scum then we trade one for one right? I think that's a town sided exchange unless it's like 5 mafia 4 town, then we'll...unfortunate. To be fair I'd rather vote you first hence the vote.
You know, the more this gets posted, the worse it looks.
How does this point of view make any sense from a town perspective? Especially if it's not a reaction test?
OK so the progression from my side was very linear.
A.) Not a good scumread from Singleton on Doc
Insert post, if Singleton believes this is a solid scumread then stick by it, if not let it go.
B.) Singleton realizes this was not a good basis to firm a scumread.
I guesssss.
So you weren't really gonna just lynch one or the other
In post 84, Vaxkiller wrote:Sry I jsut bought a new house an dmoved in over the weekend, then got sick as shit, feeling better now and will be more active now i promise!
Am I the only one that is thinking if we kill Nako we might get our powers back?
Congrats on the house vax! Sorry ur sick. Moving is a bitch. Etc.
Am excited to see what you and inv have to contribute.
In post 86, RCEnigma wrote:It gets complicated because we don't know what we're up against. Or what town has for that matter.
The most troll thing I can think of is we are forced to lynch Nako and everyone is vanilla town anyway.
GTKAS:The most recent one and the only one that actually matters. | ROOMS HAVE AIR ~ Who | Not_Mafia did not submit a naive cop action. big mistake there tbh ~ xyzzy