Strong disagree that penguin's claim was scummy. N2 doc is one of the
least
scummy things you can claim at this point in the game; it makes you look somewhat bad if you're alive tomorrow, *and* it has the potential for people trying to leash you and restrict your actions more. The scummiest thing you could claim at this point is probably something like somewhere between n2-n4 cop because it would give people incentive to leave you alive until that point.
RC is being an idiot. If he is town, at least.
I think penguin's claim is a moderately strong towntell for him. It's not something that you're supposed to look at with logic like whoever it was was trying to do.