Overkill 1: Serenity/Firefly (GAME OVER)

[Toogeloo]

Aww

[Chickadee]

Oooo I like Bujaber AND Porkens wagons. What do I do??

[Jingle]

Jingle's in my pocket now and i'll sheep him.

+1, does not need correction.

[Jingle]

Oh wait, there was another thingy I was holding back.

[Jingle]

In post 1385, Jingle wrote:
On the other hand, NR strikes me as aggressively doing Smurfall, especially given that she appears to be posting once every other day. I'm totes down to drown that in a fire, pending a meta dive to determine if that is a town or scum indicative move. You know, after I'm done hitting beehives with a stick to see if anything tasty drops out.

A very casual look at the posting from that slot over the past week suggests that if it is a scumtell then they're only a scum player in all their games at the moment. :shrug: I don't want to defend the play (unlike your back bend above) but let's at least be honest that if Nico is scummy (and I agree, they're a perfectly acceptable lynch option) than so are some other slots. However other slots are getting weird pushback, which bothers me. Why isn't it pinging you and why are you doing it?

I done did some digging, and this is not the extent of what I'd expect from town NR.

Look at Blazblue. NR was useless in the thread, but useless more along the lines of TPFKAP here, not the same degree of useless as NR here. Moreover, she was actively gamesolving and obvtowning in her neighborhood. Posting well, in fact.

Further a casual look told me she is lurkery, but not apt to literally doing nothing. I would fully expect a level of engagement like the Porkens slot, not a complete lack of everything ever.

[Jingle]

Oooo I like Bujaber AND Porkens wagons. What do I do??

Do you A) believe the Porkens will be more active if we wagon them (Her? I don't remember) or B) believe the activity is more likely to come from the Porkens scum than the Porkens town?

If the answer to A or B is yes, please elaborate.

If the answer to A and B is no, note that Bujaber is voting Porkens.

[Jingle]

VOTE: Toogeloo

Toog's probably town btw, scum doesn't like to push a policy wagon that aggressively when they're getting major attention for it being a bad push. The lack of backing off makes him pretty high in my townlist.

[Chickadee]

Oooo I like Bujaber AND Porkens wagons. What do I do??

Do you A) believe the Porkens will be more active if we wagon them (Her? I don't remember) or B) believe the activity is more likely to come from the Porkens scum than the Porkens town?

If the answer to A or B is yes, please elaborate.

If the answer to A and B is no, note that Bujaber is voting Porkens.

No to point A. Unsure about Point B. I scum read Porkens everytime I play with him.

I suppose I could go for Bujaber.


VOTE: Bujaber

[Jingle]

Town:

Elsa Jay
Toogeloo
Chara
Chickadee
Skygazer

Maybetown?:

Malakittens
Thor665
Flicker

Null:

TPFKAP
NicoRobin

MaybeScum?:

Reasonably Rational
Nancy Drew Shogunate
CheekyTeeky

Scum:
northsidegal
BuJaber

Reads list is not set in stone, but is roughly in order based on my feelings at the present moment. Could probably elaborate on most of them. Not sure I would if asked.

[Elsa Jay]

Tfw the 3p is your top town read, you KNOW town's fucking up somewhere.

Thanks for the confidence though, Jingle. I wont let you down. Mostly because I dont want to die.

[Flicker]

@Jingle

: I think you forgot Gamma Emerald.

[Jingle]

Tfw the 3p is your top town read, you KNOW town's fucking up somewhere.

Thanks for the confidence though, Jingle. I wont let you down. Mostly because I dont want to die.

You will remain at the tippy top of my reads list for as long as I'm not concerned about hitting LYLO without having solved the game, FWIW.

@Jingle

: I think you forgot Gamma Emerald.

He called me a jester IRL. He doesn't get to be on my list.

[Chara]

I done did some digging, and this is not the extent of what I'd expect from town NR.

Look at Blazblue. NR was useless in the thread, but useless more along the lines of TPFKAP here, not the same degree of useless as NR here. Moreover, she was actively gamesolving and obvtowning in her neighborhood. Posting well, in fact.

Further a casual look told me she is lurkery, but not apt to literally doing nothing. I would fully expect a level of engagement like the Porkens slot, not a complete lack of everything ever.

this is about what i expect from scum Robin as well. could still go either way, we'll see.

[CheekyTeeky]

I keep misreading Thor's aggressive tone as scummy I think. Rereading his ISO, his aggression seems directed towards genuine sorting, and it's done in such a way that it's likely to ruffle too many feathers if he were scum.

i don't find aggressive tone to be scummy, which i mention only to say that it has nothing to do with my Thor scumread.
can you talk about where he's genuinely sorting? it seems more like wagons for the sake of them, which Thor isn't hiding. and that's not scummy by itself, it just means we don't agree on methodology.

Yes, but he pushes each wagon he's on, which to me is more likely to come from town as it provides everyone with content to sort the slot with. When I first read his ISO I thought he was just shading but upon closer inspection I see a need to sort for a preferred lynch - rather than intense tunneling. I also like that he's provided some firm scumreads and townreads early instead of waiting to sheep concensus. I also really like his push on Tor after he started the game townreading him - again it's like he's genuinely trying to determine alignment imo.

There were a few moments I didn't like e.g. forced questioning at the beginning of his ISO and one question he didn't follow up which went unanswered but I think overall the intent is town.

I agree with your mala read. I could see mala/Tor as early distancing. The early push on mala from him which changed to "oh mala/rc townread each other so could be masons" just doesn't make sense on any level. I had to chase up NDS on why the read had changed and that explanation left more questions than answers.

[CheekyTeeky]

Yeah I'm vibing pretty hard with Jingle's reads. Him scum reading me is usually indicative of town for players who aren't familiar with me.

[Skygazer]

@AP if you haven't found a replacement I can come back if you're willing to let me cancel my replacement. I approached my boss about my work schedule today and he's cutting me some slack going forward since it's my recital semester.

[Chara]

UNVOTE:
i can accept Jingle's Toog townread. don't agree with Rational scum, however, but i'm not confident enough to bet the game on them either.

need to look at Cheeky's post here when i'm home.

pedit: Cheeky i was townreading you heavily based on both tone and content but certain reads and stances and the timing of them make me nervous. i could go and get them in more detail though Jingle did outline a few in posts i liked.

peditx2: yay!

[McMenno]

I have been tasked with replacing into this game. why I accepted? maybe because I'm a masochist. who are the scum?

[Almost50]

Replacement

Replacement Announcement

Skygazer

is replaced with

McMenno

effective immediately.

P-edit: Too late now

[Elsa Jay]

@AP if you haven't found a replacement I can come back if you're willing to let me cancel my replacement. I approached my boss about my work schedule today and he's cutting me some slack going forward since it's my recital semester.

I have been tasked with replacing into this game. why I accepted? maybe because I'm a masochist. who are the scum?

... This is awkward.l

[NicoRobin]

Evening.

[Chara]

also Jingle gets all my points for townreading the posts i was specifically making to be townread by town for. (and yes that's different than being townread by scum, shh.)

pedit: oof. another one bites the dust. hello McMenno.

[McMenno]

@AP if you haven't found a replacement I can come back if you're willing to let me cancel my replacement. I approached my boss about my work schedule today and he's cutting me some slack going forward since it's my recital semester.

I have been tasked with replacing into this game. why I accepted? maybe because I'm a masochist. who are the scum?

... This is awkward.l

it's only awkward if you make it so!

[Elsa Jay]

Hi.

yo

Evening.

These are your last 3 posts, Robin.

Since everyone abandoned Flicker despite my wishes, I have no reason to keep my vote there. But since I don't think I'll learn anything from the Robin slot...

This is hard. I'll accept the compromise of you getting shot in the face if town doesnt hang you. UNVOTE:

[Chara]

Yeah I'm vibing pretty hard with Jingle's reads. Him scum reading me is usually indicative of town for players who aren't familiar with me.

what are you usually getting scumread for?