the worst Idea Mafia - Game Over!

[BNL]

Guys we're here to play Mafia not to play hangman

Por que no los dos?

[BNL]

Actually I replaced into this game not knowing that it was supposed to be a shitposting game, so if it was supposed to be a shitposting game I'm sorry for ruining you guy's fun. Just keep in mind I will not be participating in it.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: CeeJay

[BNL]

Anyway I am also townreading POTUS because of the way they nonchalantly mentioned where they got their town role from.

But I find the entire ceejay wagon stupid because he claimed a powerful role and I'm going to defend him to death for like 2 days at least. I'm not even sure why his sanity is an issue because it's mentioned in the Grand Idea thread that his sanity is explicity unknown.

I'm going to join a wagon now
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Carcalilly

Also dolphin flips as just dolphin and not town dolphin etc

[BNL]

One thing I should probably mention is that I did not get any dolphin or even sea-themed roles at all

[Gamma Emerald]

GC: YOU SM3LL L1K3 OR4NG3 CR34MS1CL3S

TG: what

TG: youre aliens do you even have orange creamsicles

GC: OF COURS3 WH4T K1ND OF 4WFUL C1V1L1Z4T1ON WOULDNT 1NV3NT OR4NG3 CR34MS1CL3S

GC: NOT ON3 1D W4NT 4NYTH1NG TO DO W1TH

Votecount 1.2

Carcalilly (3): Invisibility, ceejayvinoya, BulletNLynchproof
RCEnigma (1): Something_Smart
ceejayvinoya (3): POTUS, RCEnigma, CheekyTeeky

not voting: Shock Value, lane0168, NicoRobin, Carcalilly, alban, theslimer3

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2018-10-27 14:40:00)

[Invisibility]

CEEJAYVINOYA WHATS UR READ ON CARCALILLY
CARCALILLY WHATS UR READ ON CEEJAYVINOYA

[RCEnigma]

CEEJAYVINOYA WHATS UR READ ON CARCALILLY
CARCALILLY WHATS UR READ ON CEEJAYVINOYA

What makes a cop with unverifiable sanity powerful in Grand Mafia?

Even with that being said I don't like Ceejay's claim, we either lynch him now or we end up giving him 2-3 days under the guise of figuring out his sanity, doesn't sit great with me.

I'm concerned because TW is doing more scumhunting than a majority of the in game slots.

I would be fine lynching Ceejay, Shock, Vax, Alban, maybe cheeky idk yet.

Town circle is POTUS, Slimer, Invis probably kind of maybe, SS is like on the outer edge of town along with Carca.

Idk how I feel about BnL with the complaints about shitposts without doing much about it. That and the passive play is coming off weird to me.

[Invisibility]

I mean actually we can verify his claim if we lynch carca

[Invisibility]

but like let’s wait a little? Day would be super short if we lynched right now

[theslimer3]

Isnt there also the possibility that hes a lyncher? I mean in this game, claims like that are kinda dangerous if everyone sheeps

[POTUS]

his slot as said literally nothing game-related thus far besides playing hangman (which indicates that he's clearly following along yet not contributing)

sorry i'm retracting this cuz i made a mistake - i thought he replaced nicorobin for some reason and not lane
lane did have some content although i can't remember any of it offhand
and i still don't like how vax hasn't done anything besides play hangman

==

But I find the entire ceejay wagon stupid because he claimed a powerful role and I'm going to defend him to death for like 2 days at least. I'm not even sure why his sanity is an issue b

ecause it's mentioned in the Grand Idea thread that his sanity is explicity unknown.

i still can't tell if that was a serious claim

and if it was he doesn't know what his sanity is ... ? how is this a powerful role if he doesn't know his sanity? he'd need to flip several people before he could really tell

can you link the bolded? i'm having trouble finding cop role cards (ie i put 'cop' in the search bar and get told that there are 'no suitable matches found'

What makes a cop with unverifiable sanity powerful in Grand Mafia?

^^^ this basically
and like i don't think cops even get guilties on non-mafia factions (like sk or werewolf or alien etc)

==

I mean actually we can verify his claim if we lynch carca

i think we'd need to flip a few (like ~2 or 3) people he checked to figure it out
this is what makes it unpowerful for me

----- skitter

[Invisibility]

wait where was the post that looked in the gim thread for a day/night cop

[Invisibility]

I actually looked through the Grand idea thread last night and found all applicable roles. There were 4 Sane, 2 Naive, 1 Insane, and 2 Paranoid on Day 1 iirc.

By the way, how can 2 people read it as see it as obviously serious, and another 2 people read it and see it as obviously not serious? Though I must admit that my ability to sense sarcasm on the internet is really low lol.

[Invisibility]

oh daaaaang
2 paranoid sucks
yeah carca isnt a check then

[POTUS]

yeah basically

and idk which of those it really is (i'm kinda surprised that there are that few - i feel like there are prob more but the in-thread search function isn't that great)

but i want to know which rolecard he was referring to when he says it says that his sanity is unknown because i'm not sure how he'd know that without actually knowing which card it is (unless all of them say sanity is explicitly unknown?)

---- skitter

[Something_Smart]

What makes a cop with unverifiable sanity powerful in Grand Mafia?

Nothing. But the sanity will almost certainly be verified eventually, and it will provide a wealth of information when it is.

and like i don't think cops even get guilties on non-mafia factions (like sk or werewolf or alien etc)

Depends. I think the Grand Idea standard is that they don't, but I know that the Normal definition is that they do.

@Mod: Would someone whose role is "Cop" get results in the form "Mafia"/"Not mafia", "Town"/"Not town", or would it depend on the specific post the role came from?

[Gamma Emerald]

What makes a cop with unverifiable sanity powerful in Grand Mafia?

Nothing. But the sanity will almost certainly be verified eventually, and it will provide a wealth of information when it is.

and like i don't think cops even get guilties on non-mafia factions (like sk or werewolf or alien etc)

Depends. I think the Grand Idea standard is that they don't, but I know that the Normal definition is that they do.

@Mod: Would someone whose role is "Cop" get results in the form "Mafia"/"Not mafia", "Town"/"Not town", or would it depend on the specific post the role came from?

The standard would be Mafia/Not Mafia, if specified as Town/Not Town in the card it would be that.

[the worst]

personally I'd just tell the cop how good/bad their target is at hangman.
i have a ladder prepared


- r e - - / i s / - e - i - i - - s
letters eliminated (1) : s
players gone (5) : shock value, cheekyteeky, theslimer3, Vaxkiller, ceejayvinoya

[theslimer3]

@Mod: if a lynched were to achieve their goal, would we lose in turn, or would he just win and be excused from the game?

[Something_Smart]

I think I know the hangman. I'm like 80% one answer, 15% a different possible answer, and 5% I'm totally wrong.

[the worst]

I think I know the hangman. I'm like 80% one answer, 15% a different possible answer, and 5% I'm totally wrong.

You're welcome to guess.

[RCEnigma]

Can I just solve the board TW? If not Ill take D.

[RCEnigma]

Oh in that case Cream is delicious.

[RCEnigma]

What makes a cop with unverifiable sanity powerful in Grand Mafia?

Nothing. But the sanity will almost certainly be verified eventually, and it will provide a wealth of information when it is.

and like i don't think cops even get guilties on non-mafia factions (like sk or werewolf or alien etc)

Depends. I think the Grand Idea standard is that they don't, but I know that the Normal definition is that they do.

@Mod: Would someone whose role is "Cop" get results in the form "Mafia"/"Not mafia", "Town"/"Not town", or would it depend on the specific post the role came from?

And you don't see the merit for scum to claim a role that needs in excess of 3-4 nights to resolve itself?