A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[jjh927]

Not right now anyway

[jjh927]

Was pretty tinfoily and preflippy and tbh if you were coaching Nico into the fake guilty there's no way she'd have done this

[NicoRobin]

I've played with her as both alignments

There's some jarring differences

Well, she can manipulate her playstyle to make you think she is town even she is not.

Also, didn't you tr her on role alone?

And yet suddenly, you are talking about how you read her on playstyle as well, which kinda contradicts everything you have said up till now.

This was about you again

She played with me more often than you had, y'know

[jjh927]

Yeah well presumably we're gonna have it out and reach a conclusion

[NicoRobin]

Also, just because you played three or so games with me doesn't make you an expert on reading me.

[jjh927]

No but your extremely malleable psychological state does

[NicoRobin]

Bring it on.

[NicoRobin]

I was framed, but then you would know all about that, won't you, jjh?

After all, the three of you worked together to frame me?

Did mastina tell you to scumread me while she buddies me at the same time?

Because that kind of approach is kinda getting old by now.

[jjh927]

I'm not gonna case you just yet but I know it worries you that I will


How have you been framed? Please elaborate

[jjh927]

Pretty sure you literally just faked a guilty on Mastina btw

[Jingle]

I don’t buy this

?

[Jingle]

JJ, why does scum nico do literally anything she's done today?

[jjh927]

I'll give you a "Faked a guilty to try and get people to jump on a wagon before she gets the chance to gladiate on the off-chance people forget she's hated"

[NicoRobin]

I'm not gonna case you just yet but I know it worries you that I will


How have you been framed? Please elaborate

Simple. There are two possible scenarios:

Scenario 1) You said that I'd need to kill you if I were scum. Then you deliberately no-killed and you sprouted some gibberish about being deathproof to create an illusion that I attempted to kill you, and mastina exposed my lie, thus turning the rest of town against me, while calling me town at the same time to make me trust her.

Scenario 2) You said that I'd need to kill you if I were scum. Then the actual scum (which I still maintain include mastina) no-killed, figuring out that you'll assume that I tried to kill you come day-start

Simple enough for you?

[jjh927]

If scum wanted you dead that much they'd just shoot you

[jjh927]

Wait and how do scum know I'm deathproof in scenario 2

[NicoRobin]

I'll give you a "Faked a guilty to try and get people to jump on a wagon before she gets the chance to gladiate on the off-chance people forget she's hated"

And again, you aren't even considering the possibility she could be scum.

I give both of you one more chance.

If you are town, then you'll entertain the possibility she is scum in your next post. If you don't, then she is your partner and you're protecting her.

p-edit: Exactly, which is why scenario 2 doesn't work, meaning scenario 1 is the correct solution.

[jjh927]

JJ, why does scum nico do literally anything she's done today?

I was answering that lmao

[jjh927]

Okay, so in scenario 1, how does you faking a guilty end up in my plan?

[jjh927]

Also why have you given up on the scenario where I'm actually deathproof and scum shot me to frame you even though keeping me alive would make more sense when I have expressed that I am going to be pushing the shit out of you and traditionally nobody cares about dead people's reads

[Jingle]

I'll give you a "Faked a guilty to try and get people to jump on a wagon before she gets the chance to gladiate on the off-chance people forget she's hated"

20 alive, 11 to lynch. That assumes 9 derpvotes by town before mastina, Porkens, or any logical player joined the thread. Additionally, assumes that none of her scumteam could come up with a better way to win a fakeguilty gambit against a slot that already had a ton of suspicion for being "too powerful". By this logic, Nico Robin's scumteam is the worst players in the thread mechanically speaking. Which means they're also the people most likely to run into the fake guilty.

Derp Logic.

The only reason a scumteam pulls this gambit is to get NR derptownread. Which is only possible if there is a reasonable expectation that NR could derptown. So, we're left with two conclusions. Either NR is derping, or NR is pretending to be derping. Why do you think it's the latter over the former?

[jjh927]

No I think NR is actually just bad at the game

You can be bad at the game while being scum

[Jingle]

Yes, but why is she scum?

[NicoRobin]

Okay, so in scenario 1, how does you faking a guilty end up in my plan?

I will not argue further with scum. I asked for one simple analysis entertaining the possibility mastina is scum in your next post, and you didn't give it.

Therefore, you three are scum and you are protecting mastina.

So I see no point in arguing with you.

I will have all three of you lynched sooner or later, make no mistake about that. It starts the moment mastina refuses to gladiate me.

[Jingle]

Like, do you not understand the logic of "bad enough to fakeclaim a guilty that is easily caught as scum means also bad enough to fakeclaim a guilty that is easily caught as town?"