In post 124, Chara wrote:yes, in retrospect it's more 118 that gave me the possible feeling.
what did you think of my answer?
Would you have been satisfied by your own explanation at the time, Chara?
For the record I was sitting at a net townlean on Aubrey, and scumlean on Irrelephant11, before you made your post implying townreading them both.
It's not a big deal though, I wouldn't say that I am exactly enamored by your answers. But there isn't really a productive way to continue this line of enquiry.
i think my explanation was pretty satisfactory. :> i thought it was obvious that in the first post i was still townreading elephant, and by the next i had reconsidered. you compared the two posts to each other as though they couldn't coexist.
my question was to skitter, though, but i appreciate the answer nonetheless.
"Sibling," Farkran asked, starting slowly.
"The CORE is full of lasers, and Chemist1422's entire existence depends on her eye. If she looks into a laser, she will almost certainly die. Did you think about that?"
"Oh yes, my brother. I love thinking about that."
Sure, I wouldn't want to put words into skitter's mouth (nor do I think anyone can)!
Given that you called out 118 especially, it felt appropriate to chime in.
Aubrey
aslightrain
Skygazer, skitter30, Irrelephant11, Gamma Emerald
no lunch
My Milked Eek
confidence goes down as i proceed down the list. no scumreads as of right now.
pedit: that's true, i did! was there something you didn't understand about my reads having changed, or was that just your way of asking for more clarification on
why
they had?
"Sibling," Farkran asked, starting slowly.
"The CORE is full of lasers, and Chemist1422's entire existence depends on her eye. If she looks into a laser, she will almost certainly die. Did you think about that?"
"Oh yes, my brother. I love thinking about that."
actually might resort that entire middle row, after putting it down i immediately reconsidered. might be less explicit about my non-coalition reads now that i think about it.
"Sibling," Farkran asked, starting slowly.
"The CORE is full of lasers, and Chemist1422's entire existence depends on her eye. If she looks into a laser, she will almost certainly die. Did you think about that?"
"Oh yes, my brother. I love thinking about that."
@nsg: is the final coalition allowed to have a member set to be lynched? for example, lets say we have a coalition, and in the event there's scum in the coalition, we'd like to see a certain member of the coalition immediately flip
not sure if i worded that well, just got off work and need to nap now. basically i feel like there are scenarios in which the highest info D1 flip could be a member of the failed coalition
the way he flipped suddenly on no lunch then flipped back looks like it comes from town, like it shows early townie engagement imo
i thought the way he intially pushed back against no lunch after misreading the post was slightly +town in a generic sense since i feel like scum would have maybe read the post a bit better given that no lunch was proposing a plan that might adversely affect scum
however i also think that gamma in particular as scum might have just misread the post by accident anyways just from how i've seen him play in the past if that makes sense
In post 124, Chara wrote:yes, in retrospect it's more 118 that gave me the possible feeling.
what did you think of my answer?
it just kinda was
like i understand what you said and it makes sense and i don't really have anything else to say about it
In post 127, Chara wrote:i think my explanation was pretty satisfactory. :> i thought it was obvious that in the first post i was still townreading elephant,
and by the next i had reconsidered
. you compared the two posts to each other as though they couldn't coexist.
my question was to skitter, though, but i appreciate the answer nonetheless.
although i understood your answer to be that you were still townreading irrel to some degree at the time that you had hurt him, just to a lesser extent than you were townreading aubrey, and not enough to still be in your coalition
In post 129, Chara wrote:pedit: that's true, i did! was there something you didn't understand about my reads having changed, or was that just your way of asking for more clarification on why they had?
Let's call it somewhere in the middle. There was not enough information for me to read the change in your reads one way or another. I didn't necessarily dislike it, I was just curious firstly what caused it and secondly why it was so unexplained.
I am a little busy today, but I will have a proper think through your responses and come back to you with something shortly.
@nsg: is the final coalition allowed to have a member set to be lynched? for example, lets say we have a coalition, and in the event there's scum in the coalition, we'd like to see a certain member of the coalition immediately flip
Whether or not the final coalition succeeds is independent of the lynch vote. Whether or not the coalition succeeds will be determined first, and then lynch will be resolved.
In post 88, skitter30 wrote:a little bit guttown on gamma but idk why exactly
So did this change, or can you better explain it now?
not really; it's just about the same
reading him on gut/tone has worked for me in the past (in my admittedly small sample size tbf)
it's not a strong read or anything; i don't super trust gut/tone reads that i can't explain but i kinda pay attention to them
(also i'm pretty sure he hasn't posted since i wrote that so i'm not sure what you think would have prompted a change)
==
In post 141, no lunch wrote:Skygazer, skitter30, I hope you don't mind me being intrusive. What inspired you to play into this setup?
it looked like it would fill faster than games in other queues + i thought the mechanic was intriguing + nsg is a good mod + irrel was playing and i like playing with him
In post 142, skitter30 wrote:(also i'm pretty sure he hasn't posted since i wrote that so i'm not sure what you think would have prompted a change)
Spoiler: Reason
In post 136, skitter30 wrote:i thought the way he intially pushed back against no lunch after misreading the post was slightly +town in a generic sense since i feel like scum would have maybe read the post a bit better given that no lunch was proposing a plan that might adversely affect scum
however i also think that gamma in particular as scum might have just misread the post by accident anyways just from how i've seen him play in the past if that makes sense
^ This just feels like it should be a null read to me than a slight push for town.
--
I personally am having trouble pin pointing how I feel about your slot.
Aubrey: would like to wait for aslightrain to report back before i elaborate too much, but i like the post now more than i did upon first reading it. mostly the part about Aubrey and elephant.
and i'm assuming aslightrain is relatively new here, which has to do with my read.
"Sibling," Farkran asked, starting slowly.
"The CORE is full of lasers, and Chemist1422's entire existence depends on her eye. If she looks into a laser, she will almost certainly die. Did you think about that?"
"Oh yes, my brother. I love thinking about that."
In post 142, skitter30 wrote:(also i'm pretty sure he hasn't posted since i wrote that so i'm not sure what you think would have prompted a change)
Spoiler: Reason
In post 136, skitter30 wrote:i thought the way he intially pushed back against no lunch after misreading the post was slightly +town in a generic sense since i feel like scum would have maybe read the post a bit better given that no lunch was proposing a plan that might adversely affect scum
however i also think that gamma in particular as scum might have just misread the post by accident anyways just from how i've seen him play in the past if that makes sense
^ This just feels like it should be a null read to me than a slight push for town.
--
I personally am having trouble pin pointing how I feel about your slot.
i mean that particular thing felt nullish to me but the overall vibe i get is guttown
cannot for the life of me decide. you and no lunch both are players of the type i find difficult to read.
i think a lot of what no lunch is saying is right and makes logical sense. that's about all i can say about it.
"Sibling," Farkran asked, starting slowly.
"The CORE is full of lasers, and Chemist1422's entire existence depends on her eye. If she looks into a laser, she will almost certainly die. Did you think about that?"
"Oh yes, my brother. I love thinking about that."
But there isn't really a productive way to continue this line of enquiry.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
