Mini 2034: DnD uPick (Town Victory!)

[RightKnight]

So you think Kokichi's partner did that and the voodoo was fake?

I don’t know what to think.
It’s just confirmed that it’s weird AF.

~~Castle

[RightKnight]

Is there anyone else we can conf town now that we know what the scum action was in the first place?
Ceejay is conf town cause he gave sas the msg
eragon is because of the gunsmith
So is gamma right?

Assuming you got a message that would indeed be scum yes.

I just wonder if there IS an action
Voodoo + Thunderwave + message is a lot
And other people were voodoo’d and did not claim to receive a message

~~Castle

I would want a list of all abilities and go through it again.

[MariaR]

Ohhh so you think I could be fake claiming with Kokichi?

[RightKnight]

Dunn would be confirmed town no matter what if kokichi is scum as whoever the gunsmith was that got redirected would never be able to lynch them. 4 scum would be insane.

~~Castle

Scum might just wanna concede here.

[RightKnight]

Ohhh so you think I could be fake claiming with Kokichi?

Yes

~~Castle

[MariaR]

To counter that point:
1) Why would a scum team of Kokichi and myself both ask for sas to use there oracle action on me that would conf me as scum
2) Why would I out Kokichi today in the first place and not just roll with the friendly neighbor plan we'd be down a partner already that makes no sense to uselessly bus.
3) Do me and Kokichi's actions really read svs to you.

[MariaR]

I think it's pretty obvious I can't be scum partners with Kokichi.

[RightKnight]

Meh Dunn could lack a gun and still be scum like a gf.

Blah unlikely.

~~Castle

[RightKnight]

To counter that point:
1) Why would a scum team of Kokichi and myself both ask for sas to use there oracle action on me that would conf me as scum
2) Why would I out Kokichi today in the first place and not just roll with the friendly neighbor plan we'd be down a partner already that makes no sense to uselessly bus.
3) Do me and Kokichi's actions really read svs to you.

Your actions don’t make sense as town either
So I don’t know what to make of you.

~~Castle

[RightKnight]

You did roll with FN btw you claimed you got it.

Which makes no sense if you’re town.

~~Castle

[MariaR]

To counter that point:
1) Why would a scum team of Kokichi and myself both ask for sas to use there oracle action on me that would conf me as scum
2) Why would I out Kokichi today in the first place and not just roll with the friendly neighbor plan we'd be down a partner already that makes no sense to uselessly bus.
3) Do me and Kokichi's actions really read svs to you.

Your actions don’t make sense as town either
So I don’t know what to make of you.

~~Castle

What doesn't make sense.

[MariaR]

You did roll with FN btw you claimed you got it.

Which makes no sense if you’re town.

~~Castle

Yeah but I disproved it after asking Ari questions when I got worried about it myself.

[RightKnight]

If you rather I have 5 votes you're all here and we can do the song right now. It's your call the song is better with more people given the second part of it but I understand not trusting me enough so it's your call. (Although I feel me outright begging sas to check me should clear me enough but meh)

This doesn’t mean jack. I have begged to be checked as scum.

~~Castle

[RightKnight]

You did roll with FN btw you claimed you got it.

Which makes no sense if you’re town.

~~Castle

Yeah but I disproved it after asking Ari questions when I got worried about it myself.

You mean after we started poking at it hard?

~~Castle

[MariaR]

Also I think the first point is pretty damning unless you have a counterpoint to why me and Kokichi would do that if we're partners
Pedit: That's not a counter point. You're saying just because you've said to be checked as scum that's a counterpoint. It's not you're basically saying me and my partner asked sas to check me the whole time which would end in a guilty leaving Kokichi as not conf town and in the hot seat.
Pedit2: You didn't start poking until I asked in the first place.

[RightKnight]

You’re not a scum lock by any means but you’re still in the PoE.

~~Castle

Pedit as scum you’d manipulate Saske and try to make him seem innocent. Boost up friendly neighbor
You’d think spell thief wasn’t in play yet.

Or you’re a godfather or you have townie sounding abilities

I am sure I could think of some reason

Otherwise town you never confirms Kokichi and votes him when he claimed his second ability
It’s weird no matter how you look at it
If this game had neutrals I would put you there

[RightKnight]

It’s not named spell thief Saske but it has a similar effect if that matters to you

~~Castle

[MariaR]

I'm not saying I'm scum lock I'm saying your logic for having me as a scum partner with Kokichi is outright wrong. We asked Sasuke to ask
"Is there 1 scum who has the power to steal votes" you can't get around a godfather set up question like that.

[MariaR]

Along with Kokichi's interactions with myself. (I assume you haven't read those at all) I don't see how you can think of us being scum. Scum isn't going to claim the messenger and with the spot we're in right now scum me and Kokichi would've just conf town a bunch of people putting us in auto loss. Think for a moment me and Kokichi can't be scum

[MariaR]

Regardless it's not like I'll be lynched anytime soon so do me a favor and go see who'd be cleared assuming the scum is the messenger

[Eragon]

VOTE: Kokichi

In case Eragon still doesn’t shoot Kokichi. Like please omfg
He also said he had to do something antitown to the person who got lynched.

If he started off with Friendly Neighbor or “not friendly neighbor” then Thunderwave then how would he have a third ability to do anything antitown on the lynch. Likely answer it’s a one shot scroll of a buddies.

There is just too much stuff here screaming Kokichi is scum.

~~Castle

I’ve always wanted to shoot Kokichi

0.0

[RightKnight]

I'm not saying I'm scum lock I'm saying your logic for having me as a scum partner with Kokichi is outright wrong. We asked Sasuke to ask
"Is there 1 scum who has the power to steal votes" you can't get around a godfather set up question like that.

You can.

Hence why Saske is suspicious
Because he knew stealing stuff was in the game and therefore anyone can look town
(Again why you should really claim what you are informed of Saske)
And scum might have an ability to fuck with votes to frame you
Or maybe Saske didn’t want to ask and confirm town

I don’t know

Something is still fishy and until I sort it you’re in my PoE

RC and Nancy (amazing hydra partner) won’t let me lynch you if you’re town.

~~Castle

[MariaR]

Math me Saske and Kokichi all can't be scum so that logic doesn't make sense. Try again

[MariaR]

If you want to use the logic of sas being sus that makes me town
if you want to make the logic of me being sus that makes sas town
you can't use logic from both outcomes and put them together like it works.

[Eragon]

Ima flip a coin between kokihi and wisdom