A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[NicoRobin]

No I think NR is actually just bad at the game

You can be bad at the game while being scum

Mini Theme 1936.

Not ecologically valid

Why isn't it valid?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_validity

More bs. It's a perfectly valid game, one where I was not dumb. You are dismissing it so you can continue to portray me as dumb, which fits your narrative. Thus, you are merely proving my point.

[Vecna]

who received my visit last night?

[Jingle]

Um, NR, who is your alt in that game?

I got 4 pages in before realizing you weren't on the player list.

[Jingle]

who received my visit last night?

That's weird, he's not in the game.
/don't hit me for the bad dad jokes/

[Gamma Emerald]

Mastina shouldn’t gladiator nico unless we’re already going to lynch nico. If we choose to have her gladiate while she is the lynch target, she targets not nico so we still get a conftown if nico is faking the guilty. Additionally, if mastina flips disloyal, nico is p town based on use of role and thus a bad cop target anyway. If we’re lynching nico, sure, mastina gladiators there.

Again: what motivation does mastina have to give any more clears as scum? With Ari it was clearly an oversight, but yours looks like misleading.
And btw this is a to everyone that you should probably be eyeing Jingle after mastina flips scum.

Do the words insurance policy mean anything to you?

Not in this scenario no

[Gamma Emerald]

Scum no killing on purpose is dumber than the one where they kill me to frame you and not just because I'm obvtown

Why do you assume you were their prime target?

[Jingle]

Ok, I'm getting nothing out of reading that game page by page, so I'll go back when the NR alt is made public for me.

Great post restriction tho.

[Gamma Emerald]

So Nico is lying, and Porkens can back me up here.

I was told, "Nico is demanding your role; you have 48 hours to comply, or she becomes a triple voter for you."

She CAN'T have a result yet. I've allowed it, so she will get one, but she doesn't have one RIGHT NOW.

I'm not voting her though, because I am 100% positive she's just town fakeclaiming. This is PRECISELY the kind of stunt she'd pull.

Also, pizza is delicious.

stop. nico is lying.

might be a mastina and nico both as scum plot. but nico is lying.

WHAT THE SHIIIIT?

[Creature]

Also, everyone needs to stop claiming, in case my last post doesn’t make that clear. Only claim if you actually have useful information at this point.

I'm mason with Invisibility

[Gamma Emerald]

She will get proven as scum anyway if she refuses to gladiate me.

The hell kind of response to Mastina calling your guilty faked is this

Please corroborate if you did indeed lie and then you get to explain why

Yes, I lied.

It was for reaction test which both you and Jingle failed. You kept parroting how she was town and never considered the possibility that she could be scum, not even once. Any rational town would at least consider that possibility too.

Wait so did you not get your result yet, or did you get the proper result?

[jjh927]

Um, NR, who is your alt in that game?

I got 4 pages in before realizing you weren't on the player list.

She's Yume, the player the game was built around. The playerlist was assembled specifically out of people who were not only willing to play with Yume, but would also have been on board with the core concept of basically being a showcase for Yume actually playing the game. Thus, a playerlist who would be less inclined to lynch or kill her than average that in turn would be even further dissuaded from lynching or killing her and a game designed around her preferences as a player make for EXTREMELY poor ecological validity as an actual representation of her abilities as a player.

[Creature]

No. If she’s scum, a successful disloyal gladiate is still a townclear.

If she’s scum, we don’t have a guaranteed way of lynching scum because she could easily be faking the trigger condition for her gladiate ability to setup a fake guilty.

The only solid way we can be sure of their alignments is if the gladiate is successful, in which case nico is town and mastina is scum. If we decide that that is the likely case anyway, then hell yes I want to have an insurance policy in case we chose wrong.

More excuses not to lynch her ever.......

You are suggesting leaving a possible scum alive till endgame just because she could clear people.......

Scumteam of jjh+Jingle+mastina solidifies.....

Agree on mastina and Jingle

[Jingle]

Also, everyone needs to stop claiming, in case my last post doesn’t make that clear. Only claim if you actually have useful information at this point.

I'm mason with Invisibility

HURT:

[jjh927]

Scum no killing on purpose is dumber than the one where they kill me to frame you and not just because I'm obvtown

Why do you assume you were their prime target?

Because I know how to get nightkilled, I'm deathproof, and there was a no kill

[Invisibility]

he's not, if that wasnt clear
also nico is scum

[Invisibility]

he being creature

[jjh927]

Also, as a player, I have magical powers that prevent Yume from killing me in RC upicks

[Creature]

he's not, if that wasnt clear

Aww should've let players react

[Creature]

The reactions would be priceless

[Creature]

Damn, can't believe northsidegal fooled town yet again

[jjh927]

Creature stop spamming I want people to see this I swear it's funny

Also, as a player, I have magical powers that prevent Yume from killing me in RC upicks

[Creature]

Creature stop spamming

What?

[Creature]

I'm not even spamming

[Creature]

This string of posts is nothing

[jjh927]

I know