Mini Theme 2043: You've Got Mail - Game Over!

[Thor665]

This is so obvious to me either I'm utterly insane or you're being a dolt.
I'm pretty sure I'm sane.

[Celestial Coordinates]

flotsam jetsam now I've got her boys the boss is on a rollll

with these poor unfooortunate souuls

[Celestial Coordinates]

Hey TIC are you going to vote your supposed tied top scumread or was it just something that you were going to pay lip service to but not actually vote?

[Flubbernugget]

CC

Will you vote fft with me tomorrow if I vote TiC today

[Thor665]

flotsam jetsam now I've got her boys the boss is on a rollll

with these poor unfooortunate souuls

Why the hell are you aggressively avoiding conversations with me?

[Celestial Coordinates]

cuz you were pushing a shit wagon on gamma which i was ignoring then i realized you were scum and you weren't worth engaging with because of that

[Performer]

Votecount 1.07

shortaru :
Carcalilly: SirCakez
SirCakez:
Fuwa Fuwa Time : ThoseInCharge
Gamma Emerald (4): Thor665, BBmolla, Fuwa Fuwa Time, Flubbernugget
Thor665 (3): Gamma Emerald, Celestial Coordinates, Wisdom
Celestial Coordinates:
ThoseInCharge : shortaru
Flubbernugget:
Creature: Akarin
BBmolla:
Wisdom:
Akarin:


Not voting : Creature, Carcalilly
No lynch: no one
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 ends on (expired on 2018-11-07 16:12:53)

-----------
Moderator notes: rules updated regarding v/la, in the op. Akarin is on v/la through Sunday.
V/la: v/la considerations are acceptable. Prods are extended to every 72 hours instead of every 48 hours. My rule here is please try to still post at least once every 72 hours, otherwise you will get prodded. Once prodded, please post in the public thread within 24 hours of the prod or I will have to seek a replacement.

Votecount history will be included in post 1 for end and start of days - start of d1 not included...as that is simply on page 1 of the public thread.

[shortaru]

cuz you were pushing a shit wagon on gamma which i was ignoring then i realized you were scum and you weren't worth engaging with because of that

Why is he scum?

[Creature]

VOTE: Fuwa Fuwa Time

[shortaru]

I'm digging the wagon composition on Thor.

VOTE: Thor

Just wish you guys saw it back when I was voting him the first time.

[Flubbernugget]

Do you think gamma and thor are both scum?

[Flubbernugget]

Honestly, I am not following the trajectory on either your thor or gamma reads at all

[shortaru]

Do you think gamma and thor are both scum?

No.

Honestly, I am not following the trajectory on either your thor or gamma reads at all

I tend to bounce around in the early game.

[Gamma Emerald]

More explicitly - he wouldn't vote me over it even if he was super hard line about site rules.
Open your eyes.

I never voted you until you clammed up.

[Gamma Emerald]

Do you think gamma and thor are both scum?

No.

Honestly, I am not following the trajectory on either your thor or gamma reads at all

I tend to bounce around in the early game.

So you think it’s one but not both?

[Flubbernugget]

Shortaru

You said you completely understood what thor was getting at with his gamma case. Do you reject that case now that you are voting for thor?

[shortaru]

Do you think gamma and thor are both scum?

No.

Honestly, I am not following the trajectory on either your thor or gamma reads at all

I tend to bounce around in the early game.

So you think it’s one but not both?

Yes

Shortaru

You said you completely understood what thor was getting at with his gamma case. Do you reject that case now that you are voting for thor?

It's all to do with stuff that I'm really not familiar enough to judge so I'm tossing it out and reverting back to my initial Thor read.

[SirCakez]

Gonna be honest I started skimming the whole Gamma debate b/c it started going in circles and getting repetitive. And tbh it wasn't making sense to me lol. I can only read vague references to "meta" so many times before I glaze over. I guess the people directly involved get it more. Like I skipped 517 b/c it's such a mess of words and I can't process it. No offense Thor.
I also think the Thor v Gamma v Short dick-measuring contest is killing the motivation of other players, myself included.

Depends on Gamma's flip.

If red, he's probably town and you're scum wagoning him to defend Gamma.

This is pretty bad logic. What if Flubber and Fuwa are both just town? It seems like your whole Flubber scumread is just b/c the naked vote on Fuwa during Gamma wagon.
I actually do think Flubber is town here irregardless of Gamma flip, his posting gives me the good vibes.

Reading Thor's posts looks complicated

me_irl

@Wisdom - my case on him isn't a criminal mastermind case, it's that he's denying something that he knows is legit to try to weaken a push on him. If anything I'm suggesting he's not being clever, yeah?

How does this translate to him being town?

Tryhard newb doesn't reveal alignment, not sure what you're getting at.

I've never seen tryhard newb scum - can you show me an example of what that looks like?
Tryhard newb town is easy to see - they think they're uber clever and basically have infinite paranoia. It's a valid town tell in my experience.

I can't think of examples off top of my head since it's been ages since I played heavy amounts of mafia but I have dealt with them b4 offsite.

I could lynch ThoseInCharge but then I feel like the whole Thor/Gamma/Short shitfest is just getting shoved off for day 2. I'd rather lynch one of those three (IMO no way all three are town). Or Carca ofc but that also delays cleaning up the said shit.

[SirCakez]

I'm feelin pretty lost this game honestly, my heavy workload this week is keeping from getting concentrated which blows.

[RadiantCowbells]

ok cakez if you wanna lynch 1/3 then why don't you vote thor

[Wisdom]

i agreed with most of what you said but frowned at "no way they (thor/gamma/short) are all town"
Why cant they all be town?

[SirCakez]

I feel like the amount of shit flinging they're all doing has to have at least one scum fueling the fire of it. Like clearly nobody else cares about the minutiae of their argument but they keep vomiting it all over the thread, which makes me feel like one of them has to be doing it intentionally to keep fucking the thread.
idk maybe that's a fallacy but it's the vibe I'm feeling

[Gamma Emerald]

@Cakez pls address my 523

[SirCakez]

I agree that Thor's onemindedness is scummy.
But what makes your tunnel better?

[Carcalilly]

How is Thor scum???