Mini Normal 2040: Day 4

[DrDolittle]

vote count 2.02

Day 2, Vote Count 2

Carmen

(3) : Not_Mafia, Clemency, Almost50

Sashaddin

(2) : DVa, ofrhz

ofrhz

(1) : Carmen

Elsa Jay

(0) :

Almost50

(0) :

Clemency

(0) :

DVa

(0) :

Not_Mafia

(0) :

Not voting:

(2): , Elsa Jay, Sashaddin

with 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

day two will end with no lynch in (expired on 2018-11-16 19:00:00)

[Elsa Jay]

Well your claim basically invalidates the hypo-claiming entirely. Sigh.

But im gonna Currently even out the roster so 2 people are at L-2. I need actual information from Carmen first.

VOTE: Sashaddin

Since NotMaf isnt on this wagon, consider him basically at L-1.

[Almost50]

Well your claim basically invalidates the hypo-claiming entirely. Sigh.

But im gonna Currently even out the roster so 2 people are at L-2. I need actual information from Carmen first.

VOTE: Sashaddin

Since NotMaf isnt on this wagon, consider him basically at L-1.

How's that? Both myself and ofrhz claimed he was not a VT!

[Sashaddin]

Since NotMaf isnt on this wagon, consider him basically at L-1.

What's the best move here? Claim, or do nothing since you wanna hear from Carmen first?

[Clemency]

Well your claim basically invalidates the hypo-claiming entirely. Sigh.

But im gonna Currently even out the roster so 2 people are at L-2. I need actual information from Carmen first.

VOTE: Sashaddin

Since NotMaf isnt on this wagon, consider him basically at L-1.

How's that? Both myself and ofrhz claimed he was not a VT!

felt the need to defend myself

[Elsa Jay]

I don't see any other PRs being in a 10p though if he is legit. He could always not be legit, of course, but that's the point. A hard-claim destroys the hypo-claims ATM.

Pedit: from you, Sash? Just wait for Carmen.

[Almost50]

I don't see any other PRs being in a 10p though if he is legit. He could always not be legit, of course, but that's the point. A hard-claim destroys the hypo-claims ATM.

Pedit: from you, Sash? Just wait for Carmen.

It would help if YOU also hard claim for me to understand what you're saying. So far the ONLY hard claim we have is a 2-shot BG, and we also had a 1-ahot Vig + a glorified townie flips. There HAS to be at least one investigative, which is probably nerfed, but at least one.

P.S. @EJ: Remember we once discussed a specific setup on PMs? DO NOT OUT ANYTHING IN THREAD, but just keep that one in your mind. I'm of course referring to the setup >I< ran by you and asked if you see the trick

[Clemency]

spicy

[DVa]

I would have preferred the leading wagons be between Clem and Sashaddin tbh

Still think Tictac was a bit more likely to flip town based on her rvs push of me

You know it just occurred to me it's weird to think of "Clem" (the name) as anyone other than a young black girl in the midst of zombiegeddon

[Elsa Jay]

Why do you think I keep saying Clementine?

RIP Telltale games. I only pray somehow she at least gets a conclusion to her saga.

[Elsa Jay]

La la lala la.

Where's the people. We get a PR claim then suddenly ww all go silent. Entertain me while I get delivery and pet my doggy.

[Almost50]

Dogs and wolves.. they don't get along so well.

[DVa]

@mod prod Carmen plz

Carmen has been Proded.

[ofrhz]

Sasha what are your scumreads?

[Sashaddin]

Clemency has the higher chance of being scum imo. I think she's dodging a lot and didn't go in depth. I also doubt his claim of being a bodyguard.
Not_Mafia would be second. I got a feeling for this but I won't say why now.

Is it a good idea to say that I think that X got the town power role Y?

[Almost50]

Is it a good idea to say that I think that X got the town power role Y?

Not unless you rolled Doctor with 2X BP.

[Almost50]

@Jay: Do you really think scum would ask the question Sasha just did?? I mean, seriously?

[Elsa Jay]

If they have no idea if it's a good strategy or not and they're asking, then that is NAI there.

Plus, he could have been told to do it in scumchat or something.

[Elsa Jay]

VOTE: Carmen

Decided to do a quick activity check, and research points to scum apathy as a possibility here. Considering that even if Sash is scum they are less of a threat and my original suspicion on Tic Tac...

The only thing holding me back is Clem's behaviour but somehow I gotta pray his role resolves itself.

@Almost: what if we make Clem stay on you or someone elsa here? I know Strongman or Roleblocker is a possibility, but it's better then nothing, right?

[Almost50]

@Almost: what if we make Clem stay on you or someone elsa here? I know Strongman or Roleblocker is a possibility, but it's better then nothing, right?

It's a two edged sword. On the one hand we keep someone we trust most alive. On the other hand, we give scum a road map on where NOT to shoot. I say let's him pick his protection target himself, unless you do NOT trust his claim. Personally I have no reason to think he's faking.

[DVa]

I think Carmen might be siteflaking tho

[Not_Mafia]

I think Carmen might be siteflaking tho

Scum tend to do that when backed in to a corner

[Elsa Jay]

Siteflake still doesn't make her not scum tho. And with Clem's claim, do you see any other viable lynch?

[Elsa Jay]

@Almost: what if we make Clem stay on you or someone elsa here? I know Strongman or Roleblocker is a possibility, but it's better then nothing, right?

It's a two edged sword. On the one hand we keep someone we trust most alive. On the other hand, we give scum a road map on where NOT to shoot. I say let's him pick his protection target himself, unless you do NOT trust his claim. Personally I have no reason to think he's faking.

But guiding the scum shot with 8 people left and 2 of them being Scum seems viable. Maybe 1 scum left though with Carmen's flip.

[DVa]

How is Sashaddin not a threat as scum? I'd rather lynch low activity scum than siteflaking town...

and idk, still not really blown away by Clem's claim personally