Mini Theme 2044: BTVIII - That One Time...At Boon Camp

[ChibiBear]

Is the visitor role in this game different from a visitor role in a normal game?

[shortaru]

Is the visitor role in this game different from a visitor role in a normal game?

Note the Weak modifier.

He dies if he targets non-town, if his claim is legit (basically, a crippled Hider).

That makes it investigative.

[ChibiBear]

Ooooooh. Makes sense, thanks.

[shortaru]

Kokichi Oma
UnaBombaH (visited by Alonzo and Tchill)
Shortaru
Profii
Gamma Emerald
Lamees - 2 shot neighbour (friendly neighbour?)
Invisibility
Chateau Lobby
Formerfish - tracker
Alonzo - 2 shot Bunyip
Tchill13 - 2x weak visitor
ChibiBear - told Lamees was town

Is that right?

Chateau claimed Vanilla.

Lamees clarified friendly neighbor.

Also,

Gamma Emerald - 2 Shot Loyal Vigilante

[shortaru]

Before anybody gets any ideas about mass claim, be advised that this taru doesn't claim roles unless there is a guilty result to share or it no longer holds utility. When I don't have an investigative, I take my role to the grave.

This has been a message from the floodposting taru network.

[Chateau Lobby]

Chateau, tell me why the Tracker claim isn't scum??

It could be scum it could be town. But I think FF is town.

[Lamees]

Chateau, tell me why the Tracker claim isn't scum??

It could be scum it could be town. But I think FF is town.

My reason for leaning FF is town is because if he was scum, he would know I am town. So why would he track me? He tracked me because he thought I am scum, as mentioned, in a previous game, I night killed him while I was scum. So when he saw me that was obviously on his mind still (as hinted by the RVS). Therefore looking at it psychologically, a track on me makes sense for town formerfish.

It's not really a strong reason, but we have better lynches today imo. Than a tracker that could potentially be scum (but unlikely red here).

[Chateau Lobby]

I still insist Short is our best option for the day.
Let's put him to L-1 and see what he comes up with.

It probably won't be anything good.

[Lamees]

I still stand by either shortaru lynch or kokichi oma lynch

[profii]

If Gamma shot a town person - therefore nothing happened, would FF get a result or would nothing happen?

[UnaBombaH]

Unas still Drunk in a cabin presumably.

Nah, just on a different timezone from the most(?) of you ppl.
And I had a long day at work yesterday.
As well as today.
And I'm going through a divorce.
So you could say there are some things on my plate from time to time..?

I have two days off tomorrow and Thursday, and I'm currently catching up.
I'm going to provide original content either late today (~12hours from now) or tomorrow once I get up (24h from now).

Gotta say, I like the fact that we get a lot of posting this game, but I dislike the fact that it's the same people all the time, and the discussion hasn't evolved much to any direction..!

[UnaBombaH]

So... who's down for a Chateau lynch?

Chateau hasn't said ANYTHING towards me yet.
Nothing regarding my catchup-posts.
All I wanted to hear was whether he has played with me before - that would be enough for me - but for whatever reason he avoided that question completely as well..
DISLIKE.

[UnaBombaH]

We just gotta decide as a group if we wanna keep shorty around as too scummy to be scum, or make TW's lynch look like a slowroll.

I'm starting to think shorty might be playing a "too scummy to be scum", making it "too scummy to be town"..
I def. want shorty or koki lynched today. And would prefer Chill checking the other.

unas called hands off Tchango which il respect for now.

Much appreciated.

^^this is as far as I got in the morning - now I'm off to work.

[Chateau Lobby]

All I wanted to hear was whether he has played with me before - that would be enough for me - but for whatever reason he avoided that question completely as well..
DISLIKE.

No. Maybe. Yes. No, no. I think. Perhaps.

[Invisibility]

I'm either voting everybody in the game or I have a designated mislynch, depending on who's reading. :roll:

lol actually though what am i saying
short is still scum thgouh

Looks like you’re reaching to justify your bad read

its not

[Invisibility]

why don't people like chatuea

[Invisibility]

who's claimed what i cant keep track

[Invisibility]

I don't see Bunyip or Baylip in the wiki?

yup

[Invisibility]

I don't see Bunyip or Baylip in the wiki?

It’s a Boon Bank role. TChill and I actually were in the game it stared in. That was actually my first with the Chillmeister

What do you make of him using the wrong name for the mechanics he claimed?

literally

[Invisibility]

I'm a 2 shot neighbour. I can let people know I'm town at night. I used 1 shot on chibibear which was an amazing choice (see her preventing my miss lynch, so proud :D glad the random number generator rolled 13 (her slot).

I knew ff was a PR because of the fact that he knew I visited chibibear and crumbed he was the follower. Well he out right stated to me he was the follower (surprised people missed it lol)

Which is why profii's case wasn't thought out but I know scum jumped on that wagon.

Do you share a neighbourhood with someone?
And why didn't you say Friendly Neighbour?

I checked again and yes it is friendly neighbour. You can ask chibibear the details though, all I am allowed to do is give a name and then that person will know I am town. Not sure whether she just gets a message saying I am town or also gets my role pm etc.

I dont think there is a mafia role that does that? Also there isn't any twisted roles in the game right?

that would be bastard yeah

[Invisibility]

Before anybody gets any ideas about mass claim, be advised that this taru doesn't claim roles unless there is a guilty result to share or it no longer holds utility. When I don't have an investigative, I take my role to the grave.

This has been a message from the floodposting taru network.

can we lynch this

[profii]

I'm just trying to figure this out a bit so I'll caveat this with I tend to overlook some elements of the mechanics, so correct me but here is what I'm thinking:

Alonzo is likely town because his claim explains why there wasn't a scum kill.
That also makes Una town.

I believe Lamees logic reference the track from FormerFish so I'm going along with those 2 being town also.
Doesn't particularly clear Chibi though I think? (could be wrong - going quick on lunch break here )

So then we have a weak visitor and a loyal vig to deal with. This seems odd because they are kinda both cop sorta roles. If I was going to look for a fake claim I'd pick one of these.


So what happens if, we follow town!una towards Koki and Short.

Let's lynch Short

let's get Tchil AND Gamma to act upon Koki.
Let's get Alonzo to protect FormerFish
let's get FormerFish to track TChill

If Koki dies, we verify Gamma via scum flip. If Koki Survives we have 2 reasons to believe TChill and Gamma (I don't think this is likely!)


Have I missed something obvious?

[Invisibility]

sounds like a good plan to me

[profii]

oh I had a question for ChibiBear- I see you are relatively new to MafiaScum - do you have much experience of playing mafia on other sites/forums etc?

[ChibiBear]

I played a couple of games here in like 2014-2015 but I remember very little from back then so not really.