The Fifth Fortnight (Game Over!)

[Marquis]

BBmolla
BrightEyedFish - town
Cogito Ergo Sum
DrippingGoofball
Errantparabola - town
Firebringer - town
Gorkington - town
Katsuki - town
kuribo/reck - town enough
Marquis - town
Mewtaph - meh
Ramcius
Shoshin - town enough
SirCakez - meh
Spiffeh - meh
Untrod Tripod
xyzzy - town

VOTE: UT here

[Marquis]

Can we not go back to this lol plz

Today would be a lot less annoying if everyone's only future posts were 1) a full reads list so I'm not searching the info across multiple ISOs and 2) a vote

[Firebringer]

what posts of kats made you think same?
I just went through his iso. idgi

[Firebringer]

this is my list of suspects right now:
katsuki
dgb
spiffeh
bbmolla
cognito
UT

and i want to trim this here but i find ur kats read weird.

[Katsuki]

Feels like I have too many townreads but for once I'm unbothered

It's a really easy game to get townreads in, especially combined with the setup being the split that it is.

[Errantparabola]

The optimal play would be to force everyone to give opinions on everyone else at once. I don't like being that kind of person who tells everyone what to do but Im pretty sure the thing that would leave me the most fucking salty would be some scum winning because theyre one of many not having interactions with the fleed scum.

BBmolla -- bad lurker
BrightEyedFish -- would be surprised if scum bc of transparent (and occasionally transparently wrong) posting throughout the game
Cogito Ergo Sum -- dont have an issue with his posting other than he doesnt do it
DrippingGoofball -- seems town to me but maybe just biased from the townslip
Firebringer -- seems pretty town to me, could be underestimating, just working with him as town rn
Gorkington -- town
Katsuki -- swinging around to town katsuki rn actually
xRECKONERx -- kuribo's posting was pretty bad and reck's posting is contentful but not exceptional in a town sense
Marquis -- scummy at beginning, coming around to town based on his concern about interactions but he's hard to sort
Mewtaph -- i liked 501
Ramcius -- his gambit thing makes him town among other things but yeah probably town
Shoshin -- shoshin has really dropped in impact which might just be an ebb and flow but it's surprising to see
SirCakez -- should be lynched eventually although if we don't its not a huge deal
Spiffeh -- still town i think, otherwise the "secret scumread" would be a quite creative play from scum
Untrod Tripod -- his cakez tunnel feels roughly genuine
xyzzy -- town

primary pool: reck, cakez, molla
secondary pool: marquis, shoshin, ut, mew, ces

[Errantparabola]

put molla in secondary actually like he's not scumlurking he's really just lurking

[Ramcius]

I can't win with you guys
If I voted UT I would get shit from Ram for leaving the vote on Molla

i could care less, if you voted UT. But what you gonna vote next? Another shiny that someone throw in the thread?

you say you can't win, but please explain me why people should townread you?

[Spiffeh]

Firebringer if it helps you can just remove me from your list of suspects and never consider I am anything other than town for the rest of the game?

[Marquis]

Ram and Spiff, what do u think of BBmolla, BrightEyedFish, Cogito Ergo Sum, DrippingGoofball, Errantparabola, Firebringer, Gorkington, Katsuki, xRECKONERx, Marquis, Mewtaph, Ramcius, Shoshin, SirCakez, Spiffeh, Untrod Tripod, and xyzzy? Be honest

[Ramcius]

Ram and Spiff, what do u think of BBmolla, BrightEyedFish, Cogito Ergo Sum, DrippingGoofball, Errantparabola, Firebringer, Gorkington, Katsuki, xRECKONERx, Marquis, Mewtaph, Ramcius, Shoshin, SirCakez, Spiffeh, Untrod Tripod, and xyzzy? Be honest

null, town, null, null, town, null, town, null, null, null, null, obv town, null, leaning scum atm, null, null, town

[Marquis]

Well that was very nice of you but also less helpful than I thought it would be

[Marquis]

*chanting* more. reads. more. reads

[Gorkington]

Firebringer if it helps you can just remove me from your list of suspects and never consider I am anything other than town for the rest of the game?

how does it feel that half ur posts in this game are this post (:

[Ramcius]

Well that was very nice of you but also less helpful than I thought it would be

well, i don't know what you expected, when only handful of people are doing stuff in this game, while rest are either lurking or waiting for Cakez lynch

[Spiffeh]

It feels fine, I have nothing else to say really!

[Spiffeh]

Like I understand the crusade against lurkers/inactive players and in most circumstances would support it but the nature of this setup makes me hesitant to abandon the player who I feel has exhibited the scummiest behavior and lose momentum there in exchange for what is mostly a crapshoot.

And I don't really talk about other reads because I feel if I'm too aggressive about it like usual and we mislynch my ~secret scum read~ will flee (although I've cooled down VERY slightly about them fyi) and then I'd be left without really any idea of what to do

So yeah all I have left to do is make sure I'm not the most accused player because that's an auto-loss!

[Ramcius]

Like I understand the crusade against lurkers/inactive players and in most circumstances would support it but the nature of this setup makes me hesitant to abandon the player who I feel has exhibited the scummiest behavior and lose momentum there in exchange for what is mostly a crapshoot.

And I don't really talk about other reads because I feel if I'm too aggressive about it like usual and we mislynch my ~secret scum read~ will flee (although I've cooled down VERY slightly about them fyi) and then I'd be left without really any idea of what to do

So yeah all I have left to do is make sure I'm not the most accused player because that's an auto-loss!

well, you can always accuse Cakez, if your secret scumread escapes

[SirCakez]

I've been mislynched in the scenario he's describing Ram

[SirCakez]

I can't win with you guys
If I voted UT I would get shit from Ram for leaving the vote on Molla

i could care less, if you voted UT. But what you gonna vote next? Another shiny that someone throw in the thread?

you say you can't win, but please explain me why people should townread you?

I'm interested in the room of lurkees who are doing jack basically (UT, Mew, Molla, Cogito). I probably would not vote elsewhere.

And idk bro I'm not playing for townreads I'm playing to play
I'm still somewhat baffled on what the majority (I;e not gork, ep, you or spiffeh) are scumreading me for because they've all just sort of piled on with no explanation.
I'm excited to talk about this post-game when laziness and confbias are gone. Esp with Gork who I feel like has gone into confbias mode and doesn't want to consider other possibilities. Will be interesting to see what happened there.

[Gorkington]

"im so excited to talk with gork about his confbias when im WAY TOO IRRITATED by his push to even explain why im unable to convincingly case anything outside of people being lurkers this game when it was literally trivial for me to do so in another game that just finished with only 4-5 pages of content to work with"
sorry bud.
not buying the AtE even a little bit.

there isnt a shred of scumhunting in your ISO that i believe and i think if you were town you would be pretty aware as to why given the comparison points im looking at here.
the incredulousness does not add up even a little bit.

[Gorkington]

like, you straight up know that you cant compare this game against anywhere that youve actually been town because youd have to actually genuinely try to frame all of your pushes in other games against here and you know that it would make you look terrible to do so.

[Ramcius]

I can't win with you guys
If I voted UT I would get shit from Ram for leaving the vote on Molla

i could care less, if you voted UT. But what you gonna vote next? Another shiny that someone throw in the thread?

you say you can't win, but please explain me why people should townread you?

I'm interested in the room of lurkees who are doing jack basically (UT, Mew, Molla, Cogito). I probably would not vote elsewhere.

And idk bro I'm not playing for townreads I'm playing to play
I'm still somewhat baffled on what the majority (I;e not gork, ep, you or spiffeh) are scumreading me for because they've all just sort of piled on with no explanation.
I'm excited to talk about this post-game when laziness and confbias are gone. Esp with Gork who I feel like has gone into confbias mode and doesn't want to consider other possibilities. Will be interesting to see what happened there.

do as you please, it's your right, but stop playing victim then

at this point your actions feels more like desperate scum than desperate town. You try shift focus from you to any wagon that you can without putting any actual effort

[Gorkington]

if you were demotivated town acting differently than you normally do you would understand the scumreads.
if you were playing like you normally do you would be scumhunting as per usual and you would be able to explain why my comparison is wrong.

neither of those things are happening.
its just woe is me why why is this happening
gork is so mean this is so unfair
scum is just lurking this isnt cool ughhhhhhh

[Firebringer]

i am so tired i don't want to go to work today.