the worst Idea Mafia - Game Over!

[Xtoxm]

Ok I blocked shock, so he is like 99.9% confirmed town

Should expand

99.9% confirmed double lynched/no ability

Which makes him confirmed not mafia/killing/harmful neutral

Why not Mafia

who didn't shoot Vax

?

Becuase they still would have ability

We have his role, so no there would not be another ability. This game has things like aliens to consider. Your evidence clears him of killing last night.

[Xtoxm]

I have a result on a living player. I don't believe it's productive to reveal.

[Xtoxm]

Based on discard it's a soft-town result

[RCEnigma]

What was your role again?

[Xtoxm]

I don't believe I've said.

[Something_Smart]

Ok I blocked shock, so he is like 99.9% confirmed town

Should expand

99.9% confirmed double lynched/no ability

Which makes him confirmed not mafia/killing/harmful neutral

Why not Mafia

who didn't shoot Vax

?

You think they were double bussing for shits and giggles?

[Something_Smart]

That's exactly why I asked. You said you blocked them. How do you know you didn't block whatever ability they had? RB's do not get confirmation they successfully blocked an action.

Because if they had attempted an action they'd be dead. Eragon's the backup, remember?

[RCEnigma]

Ahh rolecop I remember.

[BNL]

Eh I want to scumread Xtoxm based on VCA but I'm townreading his play here

VCA is pretty trash in likely multiball GIM anyway

[Eragon]

Ok I blocked shock, so he is like 99.9% confirmed town

Should expand

99.9% confirmed double lynched/no ability

Which makes him confirmed not mafia/killing/harmful neutral

Why not Mafia

who didn't shoot Vax

?

Becuase they still would have ability

That's exactly why I asked. You said you blocked them. How do you know you didn't block whatever ability they had? RB's do not get confirmation they successfully blocked an action.

Becuase I kill anyone that uses an ability

[RCEnigma]

Mmkay so I think the Vax vote day 1 is significant again. With Slimer off of that wagon (5 votes) and taking 7 to Lynch. What incentive did he have to stay off of that wagon?

Keep in mind he had already expressed that he thought Vax' could be scum.

It shouldn't have grown to that size to begin with (look at that discard) but it did, in his scumread, 2 votes from a Lynch on arguably scums hardest mislynch.

[Almost50]

@S_S / @Eragon: Sorry. Not tryharding in this game, since any setup spec is virtually impossible (balance is not guaranteed) so I haven't been taking notes.

[Eragon]

Ok I blocked shock, so he is like 99.9% confirmed town

Should expand

99.9% confirmed double lynched/no ability

Which makes him confirmed not mafia/killing/harmful neutral

Why not Mafia

who didn't shoot Vax

?

Becuase they still would have ability

We have his role, so no there would not be another ability. This game has things like aliens to consider. Your evidence clears him of killing last night.

my evidence clears him of using any ability

[Xtoxm]

Your lack of comprehension is very irritating.

[Eragon]

uh, shock value did NOT use an ability last night.

done and final.

now tell me, what evil faction thats harmful does not use an action?

thats right, NONE.
unless you want to say mafia had a GF that didnt use the kill, and sacrificed a differnet action
or you want to say that theres a neutral we should kill that doesnt have an ability

[Almost50]

uh, shock value did NOT use an ability last night.

done and final.

now tell me, what evil faction thats harmful does not use an action?

thats right, NONE.
unless you want to say mafia had a GF that didnt use the kill, and sacrificed a differnet action
or you want to say that theres a neutral we should kill that doesnt have an ability

Eragon, can you please calm down? Thank you.

First of all, I do believe you (regarding having targeted Shock Value last night). I also believe you believe the conclusion you came to. You want more? I am not even going to argue against them in particular.

Now let's take a step out of this particular game for a minute. Let's go back to the Mimes game where you were the Watcher, shall we? One Mafioso does the kill and the other stays put. So, let's say

hypothetically

you had this Action Jammer ability in that game (just a hypothetical proposition for the sake of argument). Now let's say you targeted Thor's partner (I don't even remember whom it was). Would they have died? No. Why? because they didn't act. Does this tell you ANYTHING about their alignment? The same applies to the Mimes. If you had targeted the one that didn't use the block they would not die, because they didn't act. Yes, I do remember lane was lynched on D1. I am just making a point. What if you targeted the other Mime who went for a couple of night without acting? They won't die.. because they did not submit an action. Right?

Also, what makes you think you didn't get RB'd yourself? If Scum have a RB of their own and regardless of SV's alignment who do you think they would have used it on?

Again, I am not arguing that Sv is scum here, and I'm not arguing that you were/weren't blocked. All I'm saying is you're jumping to conclusions based on assumptions and not facts. Yes, you did target the slot and yes they are still alive which "most probably" means they did not submit an action, unless you were RB'd yourself, but even if you were not then they simply did not submit an action and it tells us nothing about their alignment still.

Now let's step back into this here game. OK.. SV is very likely Town. I'll take that. So who do you think should we lynch? Do you like RCE's proposition for a Carca lynch? Do you think Xtoxm is a good lynch target? Am I? Give me a little peak on where your head is at right now.

[BNL]

This is a game

[BNL]

VOTE: Almost50

[Gamma Emerald]

Do you like dogs or cats more?

Votecount 3.1

Almost50(1): BulletNLynchproof

not voting: Xtoxm, Eragon, Shock Value, Chara, Almost50, Carcalilly, RCEnigma, Something_Smart

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2018-12-06 02:10:00)

Unofficial prodding update: Shock Value, Chara, and Carcalilly must post within (expired on 2018-11-25 05:40:00) or they will be prodded.

[Almost50]

Do you like dogs or cats more?

Votecount 3.1

Almost50(1): BulletNLynchproof

not voting: Xtoxm, Eragon, Shock Value, Chara, Almost50, Carcalilly, RCEnigma, Something_Smart

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2018-12-06 02:10:00)

Unofficial prodding update: Shock Value, Chara, and Carcalilly must post within (expired on 2018-11-25 05:40:00) or they will be prodded.

I'm a cat guy all the way. Why do you ask?

[Something_Smart]

hmm

I don't know who I want to lynch today

it might be RCE's time to go, he doesn't have a useful ability and xtoxm/eragon both do.

A50 might not be a bad vote either... I forget, did he claim?

[RCEnigma]

I mean I just spearheaded scums death but, k.

[Shock Value]

RCE is still town so *shrugs*

[Something_Smart]

RCE is still town so *shrugs*

Who's scum then, other than Eragon and Xtoxm?

[RCEnigma]

Bnl/Chara/a50. I reconsidered the carca/a50 thing but it only works one way really.