Open 740: Hope Plus One [Game over]

[Almost50]

We're going to need any doctors still out there to CC now aren't we.

^2nd Scum^

In what world should a Doctor out when we've already decided on lynch that has claimed scum?

[Almost50]

I mean, REALLY. To what purpose should any one CC TODAY?

[Almost50]

if i'm gonna investigate someone it should probably not be one of the doc claims, to avoid redundancy

You do you. No one should give you directions today. Go with your own reads, because either way you're going to confirm someone as Town or Mafia.

[Almost50]

Ok so I don't think this is like the proper strategy but I'd rather not lynch anyone who has claimed PR (up until this point) until after D2 when we have more info from flips and stuff, just in case.

And the 3rd Scum is here.

[Almost50]

ofrhz has requested replacement.

we'll want eyes on this slot

Yup. A 4th scum in a game with 3 scums!

I guess one of bri/Chibi is just bad Town. But which one? Is it the one that wanted to out both Doctors on D1? Or is it the one who suggested we keep a caught scum alive?

[Almost50]

Almost recommended it,

And you said it's not gonna happen, which is what lead me to believe you were softing Cop.

[Almost50]

I'll reiterate:

Sleepless Assassin will be on Clemency

. The other Doctor will protect elsewhere.

Also, bri made yet another scummy post: Both Doctors protect the Cop = Protection fails. Good one. Then he wants Bambi checked = Bambi is Town and Scum are happy they won't be checked.

I know I said not to give instructions to Clemency and let him pick his pwn target, but if I was in his shoes I'd check Chibi tonight and lynch bri on D2 anyway. If Chibi is Mafia the game is theoretically over on D2 (Chibi should just surrender when we lynch the 2nd scum and there' a guilty on her). If Chibi is Town then we still lynch bri and Clemency will have the chance to check someone else of his own choice.

But then that's just me, and I still think Clemency can check just about anyone he pleases.

[Clemency]

i feel like a toddler who's being told they can be anything when they grow up

[Almost50]

i feel like a toddler who's being told they can be anything when they grow up

[Clemency]

i'm really afraid volxen is gonna flip town just because that happens every time i have a confident scum read like
i know it'd be impossible because i know i'm cop but
somehow it still feels like the universe is gonna take me out somehow???
never underestimate the power of stupidity

[Gamma Emerald]

Ok so I don't think this is like the proper strategy but I'd rather not lynch anyone who has claimed PR (up until this point) until after D2 when we have more info from flips and stuff, just in case.

And the 3rd Scum is here.

Explain

[Bambietta Basterbine]

i'm really afraid volxen is gonna flip town just because that happens every time i have a confident scum read like
i know it'd be impossible because i know i'm cop but
somehow it still feels like the universe is gonna take me out somehow???
never underestimate the power of stupidity

If a fish can claim to be a Daycop in a 10p, you know people can be bad. It's not your fault. But if he flips cop you obviously die next.

[Clemency]

oh yeah obviously, which is why it's good that that literally can't happen

[Clemency]

but i swear to GOD if he's town

[Clemency]

if we've got our heals planned out i claim intent unless anyone objects btw

[Almost50]

i'm really afraid volxen is gonna flip town just because that happens every time i have a confident scum read like
i know it'd be impossible because i know i'm cop but
somehow it still feels like the universe is gonna take me out somehow???
never underestimate the power of stupidity

You think it's a BEF alt??

[Clemency]

i'm really afraid volxen is gonna flip town just because that happens every time i have a confident scum read like
i know it'd be impossible because i know i'm cop but
somehow it still feels like the universe is gonna take me out somehow???
never underestimate the power of stupidity

You think it's a BEF alt??

i don't remember the details but it happened in the game before that one as well

[Almost50]

Ok so I don't think this is like the proper strategy but I'd rather not lynch anyone who has claimed PR (up until this point) until after D2 when we have more info from flips and stuff, just in case.

And the 3rd Scum is here.

Explain

Not lynching outed scum on D1 is a waste of the day. You either mislynch or you no lynch instead, and neither is as good as lynching scum.

[Almost50]

if we've got our heals planned out i claim intent unless anyone objects btw

State intent and wait for SA to confirm being on you then hammer away.

[Clemency]

sounds like a plan

[bristep123]

We're going to need any doctors still out there to CC now aren't we.

^2nd Scum^

In what world should a Doctor out when we've already decided on lynch that has claimed scum?

I'll reiterate:

Sleepless Assassin will be on Clemency

. The other Doctor will protect elsewhere.

Also, bri made yet another scummy post: Both Doctors protect the Cop = Protection fails. Good one. Then he wants Bambi checked = Bambi is Town and Scum are happy they won't be checked.

I know I said not to give instructions to Clemency and let him pick his pwn target, but if I was in his shoes I'd check Chibi tonight and lynch bri on D2 anyway. If Chibi is Mafia the game is theoretically over on D2 (Chibi should just surrender when we lynch the 2nd scum and there' a guilty on her). If Chibi is Town then we still lynch bri and Clemency will have the chance to check someone else of his own choice.

But then that's just me, and I still think Clemency can check just about anyone he pleases.

First post is superceded by the second. The first was my initial reaction to the situation, the second was a thought process/theory that I thought might give us the best chance while leaving the potential doctor(s) still out there unknown to the scum.

My 2nd post; the one you said is scummy is based on a) you absolutely being convinced that SA is definitely a doctor, and this whole 'I claimed doctor but I might not be, but I'm definitely town so don't worry if I get proven to be a liar' you've been pitching. I said both should protect Clem based on my own thought; that one of you is lying so by telling you both to protect Clem ONLY ONE DOCTOR WILL BE PROTECTING CLEM. I specifically said that the other doctor, if they are out there should protect Bambi - but only based on the assumption from the previous posts that Clem was going to investigate Bambi. If it's not Bambi then it should be the person who Clem is investigating. If you are both town players then the scum will have no way of knowing which/both/neither are telling the truth and will be taking a big risk in targetting either of you/Clem/investigation target.

If we protect the investigation target then that means the scum have to go elsewhere for their NK. If we don't and they kill the investigation target then we only have 1 town player confirmed overnight, this way we'll have 2 (or 1 confirmed town and 1 confirmed scum if the read goes that way). That gives us twice the contextual meta to investigate on N2. I don't see how that's a bad thing?

My whole post was centered around trying to make things difficult for the scum covering all the options based on what's out there, speculative and factual (fact : we have 2 claimed doctors. speculation : one of them is probably lying).

Anyway - You pick up my post as scummy but ignore that I've been on Volx's case from the get go. Unless there's somehow a townflip here then I'd expect him to be royally pissed with me if we were scumbuddies.

[Bambietta Basterbine]

Dude, why would scum kill me when they got a juicy doc claim? Killing me wastes a possible investigation, but leaves both doctors and the cop for round 2. They only attack me if they're stupid.

In no universe does sleepless live to see another day.

[Almost50]

@bri: before I respond.. are you an alt? You don't have to out your main if you are. Just a yes/no will suffice.

The reason I ask is your join date is almost 8 years ago, yet you have less than 400 posts overall.

[Bambietta Basterbine]

Probably only played like 2 games in 2010 then I guess.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Ok, I'll protect clemency.

Unvote, Vote volx