Newbie 1902 l Amphibians l Game Over

[Doughboy]

meh,back to here for now

VOTE: crusty

I have just caught scum. Why are you not voting him?

[skitter30]

i don't think he's scum

[skitter30]

You keep shading me without saying what I’ve done that’s antitown.

I could argue you pushing something that’s nai as AI and blatantly ignoring my explanations, role fishing, and misleading people as antitown if you aren’t scum.

So what exactly am I doing that’s anti town?

wrt to the hammer thing - i don't think having a differing opinion as you wrt whether or not the quickhammer was ai and pushing someone based on that opinion is scummy

idon't think he was ignoring your explanations, more not understanding them

i don't think he rolefished

i don't think he was mislreading people, i think he made a mistake

[Doughboy]

Asking me to claim when no intent was given isn’t role fishing?

Asking me if I’m doc isn’t role fishing?

Saying if I don’t claim to be doc, then I basically scum slipped isn’t an attempt at rolefishing?

Are you scum with him?

[skitter30]

i think he initially thought you said you knew there was a doc, and the ensuing convo was based on that mistaken assumption

[Doughboy]

i think he initially thought you said you knew there was a doc, and the ensuing convo was based on that mistaken assumption

At what point are you going to stop making excuses for him? There is no way he should have made the first mistake, but there is no way at all he saw me claim doctor.

The first one maybe was a mistake, the second is impossible to be one.

[Doughboy]

doctor

His reason he thought I was doctor is because I said the word doctor. Like wtf?

He said doctor first. I was talking about his mistake.

Impossible to think I claimed doctor.

[Doughboy]

@doughboy you said doctor in your ISO, Let me look at it again.

Quote fail

[skitter30]

idk

none of the reasons you're giving for scumreading him really feel scummy to me rn

[Doughboy]

Look. We can win this game easy peasy if he is scum. Especially if this is column c, which it is if he’s scum.

Tracker is clear, I’d be clear, numbers and the quick hammer would be cleared and any person tracked is either clear or caught.

[Doughboy]

idk

none of the reasons you're giving for scumreading him really feel scummy to me rn

My reasons are better than anything he’s given.

[skitter30]

and if he's town tomorrow we're in lylo?

and i'm not scumreading him rn?

[Doughboy]

Well if he’s scum you are lock his partner

[skitter30]

ok, we can talk about that after he flips, sure

[Doughboy]

Great. Let’s flip him.

The fear of mylo shouldn’t stop anyone cause that’s the same fear for whom we decide.

Y’all chose somebody, ran them up (without good reasons mind you) and they claimed tracker.

The votes came on me for no reason.

Now you’re voting somebody else for no good reason.

See a pattern?

I’ve outlined some of the best reasons given this game. You can disagree with them but haven’t provided anything better.

If this is actually column c, he looks really bad. We don’t know for sure though until we get somebody claiming doctor which isn’t
Going to happen.


We have to take an educated risk as we do with all lynches. The best one points to lynching thespio. You disagree? Fine I’ll hope others agree with me.

[Thespio]

Well if he’s scum you are lock his partner

I mean m8 you did say doctor first.

He hopes that maybe he can get the doctor that claim thus making it easier for scum to win.

Remember, im using a tiny iphone in a govt building, where i have 10 minutes between where i start and end posts because of my work.

Your points are:
He pushed a point i dont find scummy
He pushed someone for a reason that everyone but I believes is odd.
He missread a chart which i corrected so it had no impact
and he thought i claimed doctor when i hadnt

Cool.

You are dissuading positive town action and i think your mad i find you anti-town. It would be funny if someone sided with you.

@all, I would be ok dying today, im bad in lylo situations and with this anti-town play coming from doughboy I dont see us not Being in lylo after today.

If we lynch him and hes scum cool, if we do were in lylo.

@doughboy i know you dont want tips, but tunneling one person kind of screws the town.

PEDIT:
Doughboy calling to flip into lylo XD, thinks in our situation more info hurts town.

[NotNova]

You keep shading me without saying what I’ve done that’s antitown.

I could argue you pushing something that’s nai as AI and blatantly ignoring my explanations, role fishing, and misleading people as antitown if you aren’t scum.

So what exactly am I doing that’s anti town?

wrt to the hammer thing - i don't think having a differing opinion as you wrt whether or not the quickhammer was ai and pushing someone based on that opinion is scummy

idon't think he was ignoring your explanations, more not understanding them

i don't think he rolefished

i don't think he was mislreading people, i think he made a mistake

I generally believe the above. I think Doughboy is really overestimating the strength of his read on Thespio and it REALLY bothers me that his initial read was FMPOV basically noncomparative i.e. presented in a vacuum, with little regard to other players. I'll explain more when I'm on my computer again.

I still think the wisest lynch is in Numbers or crusty — crusty's play is still really bothersome to me and regardless of whether or not Thespio vs Doughboy is SvT I think crusty has a very good chance of flipping scum and is an overall good slot to flip if they flip town and we go into LYLO.

[Doughboy]

I mean m8 you did say doctor first.

Uh. You said it first.

Why the blatant lie?

[Thespio]

I still think the wisest lynch is in Numbers or crusty — crusty's play is still really bothersome to me and regardless of whether or not Thespio vs Doughboy is SvT I think crusty has a very good chance of flipping scum and is an overall good slot to flip if they flip town and we go into LYLO.

Im honestly leaning to numbers rn, even though doughboy is running this weird anicdotical antitown scheme I think hes probably just new enough to thing a hard tunnel will yield results.

VOTE: NoVote

Im going to rebuild a case on numbers and repost

[Doughboy]

Remember, im using a tiny iphone

So am I. All my posts come from a phone.

[Thespio]

I mean m8 you did say doctor first.

Uh. You said it first.

Why the blatant lie?

Yours : 364
Mine : 370

Im done interacting with you at this point im sufficiently convinced you are just a poor player not scum.

[Thespio]

Remember, im using a tiny iphone

So am I. All my posts come from a phone.

If you have questions, ill answer them, if you have reads ill react.

[Doughboy]

anicdotical antitown scheme

Except I’m not.

Either stop calling me antitown or provide your reasons why you think I’m antitown.

I just proved site meta leans toward quick hammers as being non AI, that was you wrote off as anecdotal.

This site disagrees with you, which makes your opinion anecdotal since you have no evidence to support your assertion and i do.



Fuck it.

I claim doctor.


Now lynch this piece of turd

[Doughboy]

I mean m8 you did say doctor first.

Uh. You said it first.

Why the blatant lie?

Yours : 364
Mine : 370

Im done interacting with you at this point im sufficiently convinced you are just a poor player not scum.

And 292 is before both of those.

You lose.

You know we are in column c and you tried to put the doc.

At least the tracker can confirm that skitter is your buddy or not.

[Doughboy]

*out the doc

Thespio/skitter imo.

Good night