Mini 2039: uPicketyPicketyPick Mafia Endgame

[ChibiBear]

I mean discussing the minigame probably qualifies as playing mafia since we get to see people's mindsets but yeah. I've only skimmed the last few pages (I'll read and respond to them properly later but it's been a very busy morning) and it seems that the conclusion is that it's every man (or woman) for themselves then?

I didn't even consider the possibility of the winner not being announced, but since that possibility exists, I definitely agree that we should all go ahead and play as intended, which is what I originally wanted to do anyway

[Elbirn]

I'm on mobile at work and legit scared to open your iso

And same, I think I'm voting someone for a weak sauce scum slip that I was pretending to believe in with all my might for the sake of discussion, as I am wont to do, but it's done nothing for the game.

I think mutant is town for some reason, does that help?

UNVOTE:

[Varsoon]

It's cus they are posting a lot, I think.

[Elbirn]

It's cus they are posting a lot, I think.

Aw man, did I townread for effort after telling you effort is NAI?

I'm really bad at this

Lowkey I only play mafia for flavor and shitposting at work

[Varsoon]

Me too, my guy.
Except when I don't.
I still love you though.

[Elbirn]

Hello.

VOTE: Firebringer

Because there can only be one pirate in these seas. Ahoy, matey!

Firebringer I just wanted you to know how much your continued support has meant to me through all these years and I've thought about you from the sidelines but until this moment I've never really realized just how much I want to be with you.

Would you do me the honour of a dance?

Someone is being unfaithful.......

Oh, and I am a Miller.

@Varsoon Why is me being Miller hard to believe? Also, why does casting a RVS vote make me anti-town?

Oh, and I am a Miller.

Why have you decided to claim this?

Because claiming it right in the beginning is the right thing to do?

Uhhhhh kill the lurker scum that claimed Miller

KILL KILL KILL

VOTE: Nicorobin

[ChibiBear]

NicoRobin needs a prod

Reading the Nibbui vs Mutant discussion is hurting my brain. This might be bias seeping over from my initial townreads of both of them, but that whole thing feels like it could be TvT. I think that there is very little chance that Nibbui could be scum at this point.

[Elbirn]

NicoRobin needs a prod

Reading the Nibbui vs Mutant discussion is hurting my brain. This might be bias seeping over from my initial townreads of both of them, but that whole thing feels like it could be TvT. I think that there is very little chance that Nibbui could be scum at this point.

Can you elaborate on why?

[Varsoon]

Lurk!Nico is probably indicative of scum!Nico, if meta is worth anything.
I distinctly recall Nico often getting paranoid of posting in the main game thread and retreating to a scum thread and not posting much.

[NicoRobin]

Claiming Miller is scum-indicative how?

[Varsoon]

Beetlejuicing hard there, RicoNobin.

[northsidegal]

did you miss jjh's part about there being no millers

i thought you were just rvs joking around with the miller claim

21. There will be 10 town and 3 mafia. Nobody will be a Ninja or Miller.

[Varsoon]

Oh wow haha
VOTE: NicoRobin

[ChibiBear]

NicoRobin needs a prod

Reading the Nibbui vs Mutant discussion is hurting my brain. This might be bias seeping over from my initial townreads of both of them, but that whole thing feels like it could be TvT. I think that there is very little chance that Nibbui could be scum at this point.

Can you elaborate on why?

Both of them seem to be working off consistent logic in their arguments, and their arguments feel like they are more likely to come from a town POV. Mutant's reasoning in the earlier posts were questionable but his later explanations make sense to me, and feel like genuine explanations of his earlier points. (Regarding the issue of Kokichi probably being the one who gets to choose since the vote will be far from unanimous.) There are a few things that he said that I found a bit iffy, but I think that Nibbui addressed them all already.

The way I see it, it makes sense for town to want to fend for themselves in this minigame, since they KNOW that they are town, and only by winning the game themselves can they guarantee no scum gets a power up. On the other hand, I can also understand Nibbui's motivations from a town perspective, except he seems to be way more optimistic about our ability to pick out town. The way he changed his mind in a logical way upon finding out the possibility that the winner may not be announced pings town to me.

[ChibiBear]

did you miss jjh's part about there being no millers

i thought you were just rvs joking around with the miller claim

21. There will be 10 town and 3 mafia. Nobody will be a Ninja or Miller.

Nice one

[ChibiBear]

Unless I'm hallucinating, there is no rule 21

[Varsoon]

UNVOTE:

Aw it was a prank.
You know impersonating the mod like that is a bannable offense n shit
I don't think this crosses the line but ffs

[ChibiBear]

Tbh I believed it for a few second before I realised that hey, fake news is a thing.

[northsidegal]

was going more for tricking nico than anyone else, haha (nor was i trying to impersonate jjh)

gotcha

[northsidegal]

although i do think varsoon's reaction is a town one

[ChibiBear]

Ah crap. I didn't realise that Nico had posted right before you said that because I was writing my post. I would have let it sit if I realised she was back.

[northsidegal]

{northsidegal}
{Nibbui, mutantdevle}
{Gamma Emerald, ChibiBear}
{Elbirn, Varsoon}
{NK15, Maria, RC, Kokichi, NR} - null
{Firebringer}

[Elbirn]

Hot take, between RC vs. Varsoon arguing and pages of mechanic spec, scum has largely left us to bang pots and pans and make tons of demoralizing and unproductive noise

Let's all hold hands and then get this Nico wagon going

[ChibiBear]

Eh. Looks like RC is pretty set on doing most of his talking in his neighbourhood and I don't really feel like lynching him, at least not at this point.

UNVOTE:

Do you think saying NicoRobin's name more will get her to post more?

Turning off the lights.

Looking into a mirror.

NicoRobin, NicoRobin, NicoRobin.

[Elbirn]