Open 740: Hope Plus One [Game over]

[Clemency]

cool alonzo's the last scum

[Almost50]

What even was the EgiX case again

tldr i made an ill-thought push on the cop

And the voted the doc lol

A50's not a doc. #StayWoke

Egix, I swear if you turn to be the other Doctor I'm going to request the game be replayed with the same roles and get you lynched on D1!!!

@Other Doctor: Plan is still intact. >I< will protect Clemency tonight. If he dies then I'll -obviously- be the next day lynch.

[Egix96]

What even was the EgiX case again

tldr i made an ill-thought push on the cop

And the voted the doc lol

A50's not a doc. #StayWoke

Egix, I swear if you turn to be the other Doctor I'm going to request the game be replayed with the same roles and get you lynched on D1!!!

@Other Doctor: Plan is still intact. >I< will protect Clemency tonight. If he dies then I'll -obviously- be the next day lynch.

I already claimed VT, calm down dude. I just don't believe your claim. You could be gambiting just like Assassin was.

[DS]

That's not a smart scum play tho with one member already down

[Almost50]

You probably don't understand how a town gambit works then.

SA totally believed my claim. He then proceeded to provide cover for me and the unclaimed Doctor. So, when I said they should be on Clemency, the real Doctor knew whom to target anyway.

Now SA is gone, and I'm giving instructions .. AGAIN. If it's a gambit then either BOTH the real doctors will protect Clemency (that's what I told them to do earlier), or they both will NOT protect him (that's what I said recently), and in BOTH CASES Clemency would be exposed, so can be shot by scum, and I would get lynched for it, and the game goes chaotic, since any SCUM can now claim Doctor and not be CC'd because each Doctor will assume that's the other Doctor in the setup.

So, it is fundamentally bad for you to assume Town!me would be gambitting at this point. I am either a TOWN DOCTOR or I'm Scum faking Doctor.

If I'm Scum I would still be dumb to fake Doctor now and give directions to protect Clemency. As Scum I would want him dead, and I can't kill him when he is clearly under my protection. If I was Scum I would have retracted my claim by now in hopes both Doctors will protect Clemency tonight, so that I can shoot him tonight.

So, the ONLY logical deduction you could come to if you were thinking straight is that I'm for real. I am one of two Town Doctors in this setup, and by outing I am indirectly giving my fellow Doctor a heads up on what to do so we won't end up both protecting the Cop on the same night which would be equal to no protection at all.

I hope that helps.

[Egix96]

Fine fine I get it, you're a doc.
But really I just wanna go to DVC already.

[Alonzo]

Yeah Gammas a decent push.

Apologies for being rubbish in this one, Pretty sure A50 is town.

I am quietly uncertain of the Dave/RoS duo tho

[Clemency]

ok so just ignore the main wagon then

[Alonzo]

egix could be scum could be town, They have quite a new join date which unless they are an alt of a more experienced player, that they probably mistook Balmost and Belsa for scummy.

[Alonzo]

that is the crux of the case against them IIRC?

[ChibiBear]

Eh, fine. A50's explanation makes sense from a town doc POV so I'm pushing aside my bad feelings about him for now at least, pending whatever happens during Night 2.

UNVOTE:

Still not sold on Egix as scum though.

[DS]

a50's wine is in front of them


or is it

[Gamma Emerald]

What even was the EgiX case again

tldr i made an ill-thought push on the cop

And the voted the doc lol

A50's not a doc. #StayWoke

Egix, I swear if you turn to be the other Doctor I'm going to request the game be replayed with the same roles and get you lynched on D1!!!

@Other Doctor: Plan is still intact. >I< will protect Clemency tonight. If he dies then I'll -obviously- be the next day lynch.

I already claimed VT, calm down dude. I just don't believe your claim. You could be gambiting just like Assassin was.

He was Town gambitting. So...?
This looks shady tbh

[ChibiBear]

I remember very little about what's happened in this game beyond the past few days.

We have a bit of leeway for now, so if I rule out my 4 previously mentioned townreads, townlean DS, plus probably doc A50, that leaves Gamma/Reaper/Dave/Alonzo.

I'd probably be up for wagoning any of those 4 right now because I'm pretty lost tbh.

[bristep123]

You did the same fence sitting, 'let's wagon someone else folks' last day phase when we were wagoning Volxen.

[ChibiBear]

Well I got nothing better, sorry. Narrowing it down to 4 with 2 scum remaining is as good as I'm going to get, especially if this super slow pace keeps up. I can't remember anything and even going back and reading isn't really helping me make a more definite decision.

If Egix flips scum feel free to mislynch me tomorrow, we have the leeway anyway. Just don't drag it out, I'm not doing too well in the game as you've already noticed so I'm no great loss.

[Almost50]

I think I'll try harder tomorrow (that's in 12 hrs or so)

[ChibiBear]

I still maintain that I want the cop to check me btw. But if you feel that your check is better used elsewhere then I respect that too.

[Almost50]

yeah, you maybe Town but your reads aren't that great tbh (no offense). I'd keep say Clemency checks whomever he likes again. His N1 on Bambi was good enough for me.

[ChibiBear]

I mean in my last game my top 3 scumreads all flipped town within the space of 48 hours. Which was actually pretty funny. That's why I'm trying to solve through POE instead, starting with town reads.

Btw you don't actually

know

that my reads are bad yet unless you're scum

I mean statistically speaking they probably are but still.

[Almost50]

Yes, I do. You didn't vote Scum yesterday and you were SRing both the Cop on D1 and me on D1 and most of D2. What else do I need to know?

[DS]

yeah, you maybe Town but your reads aren't that great tbh (no offense). I'd keep say Clemency checks whomever he likes again. His N1 on Bambi was good enough for me.

Yeah I agree. In case we don't hit scum today we don't want the cop telegraphing his check so that Clem can reaction test people tomorrow with fake checks

[ChibiBear]

Whatever.

I've lost interest in this game, have it your way.

VOTE: Egix

[Egix96]

VOTE: Egix

Boom bye scum?????

[ChibiBear]

I mean I'm happy either way.

If Egix is scum, we lynched scum.
If Egix is town, I get to finally have a correct read. It's a win-win for me.