Military School Mafia - Sudden Death - Game Over

[mathcam]

Alright, well we still have all the information from before. Since I don't remember too much about what's going on, I feel like the rank claim list is the best place to start: I'll go try and update it.


Oh, and 1000th reply! Woo!

Cam

[mathcam]

Complete Rank List:

Cadet Airman Basic

Someone

,

mathcam

,

Winnie The Foo

,

Demeech

Cadet Airman

Leonidas

, Cadmium,

Banana Bob

Cadet Airman First Class

Flying Dutchman

,

Stewie

,

Blackhawk

Cadet Senior Airman

Tehgood, Indentured Djinn

,

Chaotic_Diablo

Cadet Staff Sergeant

mlaker, scalebane

Cadet Technical Sergeant
Cadet Master Sergeant

spork76

Cadet Senior Master Sergeant

Vraak X

,

Werebear

Cadet Chief Master Sergeant
Cadet Second Lieutenant

shadyforce

Cadet First Lieutenant

Prizm

Cadet Captain

PeaceBringer

Cadet Major

EnPaceRequiescat

,

Modargo

Cadet Lieutenant Colonel

pwnz

Cadet Colonel

Dementia Blader

Key:

Claimed

Dead Town

Dead Scum

Mystery Dead

[Fishbulb]

Your lives are on the line. All semblance of order is gone. Ranks no longer exist for the ten of you.

[mathcam]

Sorry for the triple post, but it's good to get things started again. I think that list is mostly accurate, though someone might want to double-check some stuff. I wasn't positive about "Spoiled Rich Kid" being pro-town or not (BananaBob, I think).

Thoughts? FD might be kind of scummy if the Cadet Airman First Class scum distribution looks like the Senior Airman distribution.

Also funny is the pairs of roles in Senior Master Sergeant and Cade Major, whereas most of the upper roles have only one. It looks a lot like EPR and one of Vraak/Werebear made a misclaim.

All of this is mitigated by the fact that Darkblade might have (probably did?) throw things off a little just so we can't get too much information from the list.

Finally, though I put him in blue, I'm relatively sure Someone was pro-town. We were the Charlie Flight or something.

Fishbulb: Are you saying we're forbidden from using the old information? That seems kind of...weird.

Cam

[Flying Dutchman]

Ah, that's a good thing, I was pretty low in rank!

Anyways, is there anything important that we (as in 'we replacing people') should now about right now? Or is a re-read required? It may take a few days before I find the time to read 1000 posts.........

[Fishbulb]

Fishbulb: Are you saying we're forbidden from using the old information? That seems kind of...weird.

I'm just saying they don't matter any more. Some roles I received were missing that information. So, anything before that related to ranking doesn't exist anymore. It's the only fair solution to it.

[Fishbulb]

Anyways, is there anything important that we (as in 'we replacing people') should now about right now? Or is a re-read required? It may take a few days before I find the time to read 1000 posts.........

Well, it's just like you are replacing in a normal game, there is plenty of information that the ten of you can use to try to find the remaining scum. But just don't expect them to be able to defend themselves properly if you only focus on their predecessor's actions. Some players might not even know what there role was supposed to be. So, if you are able, please don't hold it against them.

[PeaceBringer]

hmm not read throught his yet and will take some time-

I have played a rank based game before though-if this game is anything like it scum will either try and obtain the highest rank or stay out of the shadow..

I am going to personally look high first.

But I need to check out hte game and not read through this yet since it will take awhile.

[mathcam]

Okay, I see your point. We will no longer be able to

gain

any useful information from the ranks. At the same time, the information is still present about what ranks had been revealed before the abandonment (B.A.), which may give us clues as to which of the remaining players are scum.

Cam

[PeaceBringer]

mathcam so without reading it all were ranks earned or assigned?

[mathcam]

All ranks were given out with the roles at the very beginning. We have no guarantees about anything in terms of distributions, though, so anything I said above about who may may or may not be guilty because of it is all conjectural.

Cam

[PeaceBringer]

so there was no earning roles or moving up or down roles then-- then what I said means nothing-- if it was an earn role or get dropped then whole other ball game.

actually should have been able to figure that out on my own but looking at the distrubition seemed there were a lot up at top rank level.

[Vraak X]

VOTE: En Pace Requiescat

The rank structure is gone, but it's been used in the past. My vote still stands on him. Why? He was a major when there was two.

And mathcam, you're wrong. SMSgt. is not high to the point where there can be two, that's CMsgt. There can only be one Chief, but there can be plenty of Senior MSgts.

We're E8s, not E9s.

[Flying Dutchman]

And mathcam, you're wrong. SMSgt. is not high to the point where there can be two, that's CMsgt. There can only be one Chief, but there can be plenty of Senior MSgts.

We're E8s, not E9s.

Can someone translate this to English?

[mathcam]

Yeah, he keeps doing that.

My point is that there's 2 at that rank, Vraak, while there are

no

master seargeants or technical sergeants. If we believe that Darkblade put at least one person at each rank, then it's probably the case that one of you or Werebear is lying about his rank, and is consequently probably scum. I'm certainly not making any argument based on the real-life practices of military school.

And I agree, since we know modargo was pro-town, we'll get a lot of information about whether or not this colletion of theories holds any water by lynching EPR. If he's scum, then I think it's extremely likely that one of Vraak or Werebear is.

Vote: EPR

Cam

[Fishbulb]

Vote Count:

EnPaceRequiescat- 2 (mathcam, Vraak X)

Not voting (8): Flying Dutchman, Werebear, pwnz, PeaceBringer, Cadmium, shadyforce, EnPaceRequiescat, spork76

6 to lynch.

[PeaceBringer]

vote EnPace

[pwnz]

This is just a post to tell you all that I am here.
I'm going to try and wade through all of the posts and see what I can come up with as far as this mafia goes. Until then I am not going to be making any blind votes.

[PeaceBringer]

unvote

I replaced tigris who did believe the person being voted on-- therefore another direction is more likely accurate.

[mathcam]

Oh right, I forgot there were other reasons to suspect that EPR might not be scum. His night-time ability has been somewhat verified...I'm not sure how much that implies he's pro-town, though.

Cam

[PeaceBringer]

vote mathcam

[mathcam]

Bwaaaa???

Cam

[pwnz]

Bwaaaa???

Cam

I like how you still signed that post, cam. It's kinda funny if you ask me.

[mathcam]

Heh. Habit. Seriously, Peace, whaddup?

Cam

[Werebear]

it's been a while since this game was a go, hasn't it...

ranks were assigned. Mafia appear to be randomly distributed, as far as we can tell.