Starcraft Mafia -- Game Over!

[Irrelephant11]

Oh 4 days not 3, not as bad as I first thought
I’ve decided Skitter is definitely town
I don’t think she feels weird about Keyser & others’ lack of townreads unless she *really does* have a bunch of townreads to compare that feeling to

Oh yeah, this

[Shoshin]

I think we're overthinking this.

VOTE: Not_Mafia

[Not_Mafia]

I think you need to think harder, cos I'm town

[Varsoon]

VOTE: Not Mafia
You aren't town
You're Not Mafia.

[Varsoon]

Man did I botch that one too?
Should I have gone with
"Just because you're Not Mafia doesn't mean you're town."?

[the worst]

intent to marry entire playlist

@Nauci I had already read that entire scumchat to be able to read Skitter better in another game. Nothing was new to me, and I’m not townreading Skitter for any of her easily fakeable reasons, so nothing stood out to me there either. The fact she hasn’t pushed many players makes sense to me; I don’t have many scumreads either. The way she’s handling the AlmostNancy slot feels especially town for her. I forget what my third reason was, but it wasn’t something I thought Skitter had the foresight to fake

^^^^^^^
also the way in this game it's almost like you can feel like you're totally comfortable with realtime interactions with someone then
BOOM skitter echoing your reaction/first impressions
and in spite of very nuanced reads as scum, and ability to smell two steps ahead of the gamestate and slip herself in there intuitively, I think that's something scum!skitter struggles a lot with

this is a towntell for her like almost every time I'm pretty sure

[the worst]

I think you need to think harder, cos I'm town

Where the fuck then

[Nauci]

I think we're overthinking this.

VOTE: Not_Mafia

The game state was so weird I felt like I needed to start exploring zanier ideas

[the worst]

I think we're overthinking this.

VOTE: Not_Mafia

The game state was so weird I felt like I needed to start exploring zanier ideas

I have this feeling like regardless of who the d1 flip is if it's town I'm gonna yell FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK regardless and this resonates deeply

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: the worst

GG

[Keyser Söze]

TW, Shoshin, Varsoon, Mitillos, Keyser, Irrelephant, Nancy: can y'all post up-to-date full read lists?

On it now.

[Keyser Söze]

Currently wondering about my town-lean on Mit... possibly premature there... May relegate him back down to null-green (suspicion: pocketing. I took a step back at his ISO, and I feel his ‘movements’ have been ‘too measured’... maybe too controlled?)

[Keyser Söze]

VOTE: the worst

GG

[Irrelephant11]

NM is L-3
We have 29 hours left
Just as a recap

[Keyser Söze]

I think Nauci achieved upper town status with Post 2044.

I think this is the first time this game I’ve seen vintage-town-Nauci.
- townie ramblings (I feel until then she was holding back(?), or we were witnesssing a Nauci impersonator), but now she provides a content-driven push to directly move our focus. Instead of adding snippets on the players already in the spotlight (including me which I didn’t like).
- I like that her paranoia on Relly has only come into fruition NOW, and when I was pushing Relly as scum and them as scum-partners (which I concede looks unlikely now) I feel like scum-Nauci may have felt the urgency to talk about Relly sooner. Instead Nauci kept saying: ‘I’m going to leave Relly for now”... (not what you call classic distancing)
- nauci also probably taps into my fear about Skitter too here: (he has been one of the most pro-active players, but somehow he’s not a cemented/strong read as a Soshin/TW town read. Perhaps the ‘tone’ (?) I’m not fully believing

[Irrelephant11]

Currently wondering about my town-lean on Mit... possibly premature there... May relegate him back down to null-green (suspicion: pocketing. I took a step back at his ISO, and I feel his ‘movements’ have been ‘too measured’... maybe too controlled?)

I like this from you because I’ve felt all game he’s been getting stronger townreads than he deserves
I sorta 3p-read him because I feel like he doesn’t deserve a scumread, but also doesn’t deserve a strong townread
But meh there might not even be a 3p

Anyway, this is a good look for you

I was thinking about this game yesterday and decided if this is Varsoon’s scumgame, it’s super unique and fascinating. I guess this thought doesn’t really go anywhere, but I’ve typed it up, so here it is

[Keyser Söze]

This post surprised me:

But seriously tw, you know I adore you but if you honestly don’t think you have the proper timr to sort slots in this game, perhaps you should either hydra with someone or even consider replacing out. Your reads and votes, have an important effect in the game and it honestly isn’t fair to the rest of the playerbase, if you’re just too swamped, stressed out and busy to pay proper attention to the game until late December. :/

I don’t like this from AlmostNancy

Just gut-read it as scum talking to town.

[Nauci]

(I feel until then she was holding back(?), or we were witnesssing a Nauci impersonator),

I think you should take my words at face value that I've been burned out and trying to get away from the wall posting stuff. Yesterday was the first time I cracked open my laptop for anything at all. It should be easy to read me this game because I've been interacting in real time excessively; it's a lazy approach to continue to only see me as town when I perfectly simulate my meta, instead of for my actual thoughts and point of view which have been transparent as air all game.

[Keyser Söze]

I have been thinking about your PGO claim too:- it makes more sense as coming from town, as it only works in your favour as scum on the short term, not longterm (long term you wouldn’t escape a policy lynch debate). I don’t see it as a fake claim for a one shot unlynchable scum either. You’d basically be banking on everyone town reading you...

[Nauci]

This post surprised me:

But seriously tw, you know I adore you but if you honestly don’t think you have the proper timr to sort slots in this game, perhaps you should either hydra with someone or even consider replacing out. Your reads and votes, have an important effect in the game and it honestly isn’t fair to the rest of the playerbase, if you’re just too swamped, stressed out and busy to pay proper attention to the game until late December. :/

I don’t like this from AlmostNancy

Just gut-read it as scum talking to town.

I thought this was a rude post but one that more likely comes from frustrated town

I'm not sure if any scum would just goad one of the game's top town reads and active players about replacing out, but it's plausible that someone frustrated with and focused on the microcosm of TW reading them would have this moment

[Keyser Söze]

(I feel until then she was holding back(?), or we were witnesssing a Nauci impersonator),

I think you should take my words at face value that I've been burned out and trying to get away from the wall posting stuff. Yesterday was the first time I cracked open my laptop for anything at all. It should be easy to read me this game because I've been interacting in real time excessively; it's a lazy approach to continue to only see me as town when I perfectly simulate my meta, instead of for my actual thoughts and point of view which have been transparent as air all game.

Partly agree. I have tried to read you outside of high-effort Nauci (but obviously my history is restricted to those few games with you, which I think should play a role here)

It wasn’t the question of effort for me anyway, but the excitement and paranoia in that post from you that promoted you to ‘upper town’.

Don’t worry you’re still not my top town read

[Shoshin]

Irrel, can you clarify your role for me? I read the wiki but I'm still confused. What exactly do you do? You shoot anyone who visits you, regardless of the type of role?

[Irrelephant11]

That’s how I understand it, yeah

[Irrelephant11]

Perhaps importantly(?) my “kill flavor” is bullets

[Keyser Söze]

Interesting...