Mini 588: Achewood Mafia - Game Over!

[NabakovNabakov]

mustafa15 replaces CaptainCake!

[Alabaska J]

Im not sure if i believe OG but all the same i will

unvote

What makes you not believe her? She played very poorly, but we have no evidence to the contrary that she is not the cop.


Also,

FoS: populartajo

for being so vote shy. You afraid of your scumbuddy being lynched?

Well exactly she played bad game which made us think he as scum which makes it look less likely to her being a cop.

She is a noob; that explains a lot. You'd be surprised how bad people are in there first game no matter what their role. I was horrible in my first game and was lynched day one-when I was the doc.

[populartajo]

Also, FoS: populartajo for being so vote shy. You afraid of your scumbuddy being lynched?

I seriously dislike bandwagons, whats so wrong with that?

She is a noob; that explains a lot. You'd be surprised how bad people are in there first game no matter what their role. I was horrible in my first game and was lynched day one-when I was the doc.

Then why going so hard against she?

FoS : Alabaska

PBuG, question stands.

[malthusis]

First of all,

unvote

The reason I was pushing on OG so much is that he was looking extremely scummy ( as well as being a bit rude) as well as making pointless stalling (aka OMGUS dumb townie argument) as well as really pushing on Alaska because he was your random vote. Looks like I was wrong. The moves that OG had to make has really hurt the town a lot (aka OG is probably going to get killed unless the doctor if there's one protects him). I haven't decided who I'll put my vote on so I'll wait and see.

[lulu muumuu]

This was populartajo's last vote:

Vote : Lemming.
Just for being so vocal at the beginning against PbuG and OG, then is suddenly quiet.
And just a question, @PbuG: what do you think of Lemming right now?

I seriously dislike bandwagons, whats so wrong with that?

a bandwagon is only bandwagon if it looks like a quicklynch with no reasoning behind it.
not to mention that you shouldn't vote unless you've got good reasoning. i find it strange that you're voting for lemming and then asking for PBuG's opinion on lemming

[lulu muumuu]

UGH, sorry i should have previewed...
EBWOP:

---

This was populartajo's last vote:

Vote : Lemming.
Just for being so vocal at the beginning against PbuG and OG, then is suddenly quiet.
And just a question, @PbuG: what do you think of Lemming right now?

I seriously dislike bandwagons, whats so wrong with that?

a bandwagon is only bandwagon if it looks like a quicklynch with no reasoning behind it.
not to mention that you shouldn't vote unless you've got good reasoning. i find it strange that you're voting for lemming and then asking for PBuG's opinion on lemming

[mustafa15]

Hi everyone.

I've done a pretty quick read-through, here are my first thoughts.

I'm not really liking Lemming too much. The first fake claim felt awfully suspicious to me, but I could have let that go if Lemming hadn't basically disappeared after that. It feels like Lemming realized that he had been too risky at the beginning, and wanted to lay low for a while. However, I could easily see Lemming being a nooby townie too.

I also thought that OG seemed really scummy throughout the first few pages, a Lemming-OG scumpair seemed very likely. I believe OG's claim though, because it feels very realistic, and hard to make up. I've read through Achewood a couple of times, and that does feel like the best way to make a cop (although I probably would have made Teodor the bartender, but Cornelius is fine too), so OG is pretty much clear in my eyes now.

PBuG feels pretty townie to me, but I think that he is one of the most experienced players in this game, so he might just be really good scum, but so far I doubt it.

I'm not really sure about malthusis yet, I'll have to do another readthrough to get some more opinions, but for now i'll just

unvote, FoS Lemming1607

[TBuG]

lulu:

He just fell of my radar, I dunno. I kinda blew the situation out of proportion in the first place.

tajo:

Overeaction, maybe?

Hell yeah, on both sides.

Fine with that?

For now.

[lulu muumuu]

PBuG: i wasn't questioning your thoughts on Lemming, I was wondering why populartajo voted for Lemming and THEN wants to know your reasons for suspecting him.

[TBuG]

Oh, okay, I see now.

[malthusis]

I've done a quick re-read and noticed that Lemming hasn't said a meaningful post since lulu got here. No one else is really popping out at me, so I'll

vote: Lemming

[TBuG]

Can I vote again? Seriously. Attention shifts to Lemming, malthusis votes.

[lulu muumuu]

Can I vote again? Seriously. Attention shifts to Lemming, malthusis votes.

can we

prod greasy spot

and

prod dragons of summer

who have been active in other threads but not this one?
dragons, you said you'd have something to say on wednesday, you haven't really contributed anything since may 5th

i'm worried that these two may be flying under the radar while we argue amongst ourselves, vote stays though
mal is L-2, lemming is L-4

[populartajo]

UGH, sorry i should have previewed...
EBWOP:

---

This was populartajo's last vote:

Vote : Lemming.
Just for being so vocal at the beginning against PbuG and OG, then is suddenly quiet.
And just a question, @PbuG: what do you think of Lemming right now?

I seriously dislike bandwagons, whats so wrong with that?

a bandwagon is only bandwagon if it looks like a quicklynch with no reasoning behind it.
not to mention that you shouldn't vote unless you've got good reasoning. i find it strange that you're voting for lemming and then asking for PBuG's opinion on lemming

I hate bandwagons, specially D1 ones. Ive seen many good and bad townies dying to good and weak arguments. I guess it's also related to the fact that I, as town, was bandwagoned to death D1 in my first non-newbie game.
And about my question to PbUg, you had to be here at the beginning of D1. PbUg and Lemming were involved in a fight to death very early that I thought both of them were exagerating things. But now, no one seems to care against the other. It somehow bothers me.

[mustafa15]

Okay, malthusis just overtook Lemming on the scum-o-meter with 210. Reading over his stuff, malthusis seemed moderately scummy, but not as bad as Lemming or OG, but it feels a whole lot like mal is trying to get a lemming bandwagon started, so I'm going to

vote:malthusis

. Keep in mind that we are now at lynch-1.

[DragonsofSummer]

Sorry everybody... finals have been a little more taxing than I planned on them being, and now I'm in the process of moving out of my appartment. I will do my best to have a post by Tuesday.

[Musher333]

Hmm... is anyone against a mal lynch, he has seemed quite scummy with attention shifting to lemming when lemming's name is mentioned.

I would vote but i wouldn't want to end it to quickly.

[NabakovNabakov]

Vote Count as of Post 216

malthusis (6):

lemming1607, lulumuumuu, OG Smokedank, Alabaska J, PBuG, mustafa15

CaptainCake

Lemming1607 (2):

populartajo, malthusis

OG Smokedank (1):

DragonsofSummer

Not Voting (3):

thinktank, Greasy Spot, Musher333

7 to lynch

Greasy Spot is receiving his final warning.

[Alabaska J]

UGH, sorry i should have previewed...
EBWOP:

---

This was populartajo's last vote:

Vote : Lemming.
Just for being so vocal at the beginning against PbuG and OG, then is suddenly quiet.
And just a question, @PbuG: what do you think of Lemming right now?

I seriously dislike bandwagons, whats so wrong with that?

a bandwagon is only bandwagon if it looks like a quicklynch with no reasoning behind it.
not to mention that you shouldn't vote unless you've got good reasoning. i find it strange that you're voting for lemming and then asking for PBuG's opinion on lemming

I hate bandwagons, specially D1 ones. Ive seen many good and bad townies dying to good and weak arguments.

I guess it's also related to the fact that I, as town, was bandwagoned to death D1 in my first non-newbie game.

And about my question to PbUg, you had to be here at the beginning of D1. PbUg and Lemming were involved in a fight to death very early that I thought both of them were exagerating things. But now, no one seems to care against the other. It somehow bothers me.

Yes. Yes it is. I had a similar experience and was shy the next game. OG-wagon was the closer to the type of bandwagon you are talking about than malthusis-wagon is.

Also, because she is a noob, her

godawful

(and I mean

godawful

) play can be understood. Before her claim, I thought she was noob scum, not horribly noob town. I felt she could be pretty bad more likely than she would be very bad. The cop claim made me change my mind. If she was more experienced, I would hesitate to unvote in this situation, as the lack of a counterclaim could be because the cop is lying low.

[populartajo]

Okay, malthusis just overtook Lemming on the scum-o-meter with 210. Reading over his stuff, malthusis seemed moderately scummy, but not as bad as Lemming or OG, but it feels a whole lot like mal is trying to get a lemming bandwagon started, so I'm going to

vote:malthusis

. Keep in mind that we are now at lynch-1.

I think its time for him to claim.

[Alabaska J]

prod malthusis

so we can get this over with.

[thinktank]

Sorry I was away, I lost internet access and just fixed that issue. Ill do a reread and post soon. Thx.

[mustafa15]

I've scanned through this thread a second time, and so far the only person besides PBuG that feels townie to me is populartajo. This isn't to say that I think that everyone else is scum, I just wouldn't be surprised to find out that anyone else is scum, and although I think that there is a possibility that PBuG or populartajo is scum, I would be surprised if this was the case.

[Alabaska J]

I felt the same way about populartajo until lately but his shyness and odd stances might stem from him being lynched early in a game so I am leaning towards him being pro-town also. Same with PBuG.

[populartajo]

What odd stances?