Mini 2039: uPicketyPicketyPick Mafia Endgame

[Varsoon]

Same thing I've been saying for days by the way

If Varsoon is town who is going to be confirmed why does he not wait to be confirmed and use that confirmation to lynch me?

My confirmation only confirms me as town.
Your scum play throughout the day phase is what confirms you as scum.
You, yourself, are the one who's been insisting that my IC could be very delayed, as a reason to lynch me,
Which indicates that this isn't a defense that town-you would ever take as reasonable.
You've proven you're thinking from a scum PoV.

[RadiantCowbells]

I never gave a fuck about shit you said

I cared about your actions and what they say about your alignment

Because I would expect you to be awful to me regardless of alignment

I think you would even be likely to try to policy Lynch me regardless of alignment

But I don't think you dredge this up right now as town

[Firebringer]

Varsoon u started the 1v1

[Varsoon]

Follow the logic here:

If town, RC's complaint about my claim is that it potentially delays my IC confirmation to day 7.
If town, though, that's no defense for RC to say 'just lynch me when you are confirmed as IC'.

As scum, though, RC using the delayed IC confirmation to day 7 as a rationale for pushing my lynch NOW before I even get a single shot at it makes plenty of sense.
As scum, RC saying 'Just lynch me when Varsoon confirms' makes plenty of sense if he thinks my IC confirm won't even come out during the rest of the game.

[RadiantCowbells]

You, yourself, are the one who's been insisting that my IC could be very delayed, as a reason to lynch me,
Which indicates that this isn't a defense that town-you would ever take as reasonable.

No I said that since your IC is delayed and you're probably scum but can be dealt with later, that we deal with it later or kill you if you refuse because you have no town motivation to refuse.

When the entire game has agreed to lynch me if you flip town and to leave you alive til much later you have no motivation to do this as town.

[RadiantCowbells]

You yourself said that you were pretty likely to be conftown by day 3

You're not playing like that statement was anything other than bullshit

[RadiantCowbells]

And Firebringer

When I ask you to vote Varsoon

I'm not asking as RadiantCowbells the mafia player

I'm asking as RadiantCowbells the person

And in a situation like this I would do the same for you

[Varsoon]

Varsoon u started the 1v1

Eeeh, did I?

I know I taunted RC because I (rightfully so) realized it was far more likely the dude was interacting in PTs and wasn't posting in thread, which was a huge red flag for me, but he ALSO wasn't coming to any really strong informed reads from those PTs (another red flag). I voted him for being absent and nebulous. RC then made it into a huge 1v1 from what I remember.

Also there's this:

you didn't actually want to 1v1.

When what I'm advocating for is literally a 1v1 between me (Varsoon's top scumread) and Varsoon, which is essentially the only way for town varsoon to get the W here

[Varsoon]

You yourself said that you were pretty likely to be conftown by day 3

You're not playing like that statement was anything other than bullshit

You're the only one who has ever played like it hasn't been the case.

[Varsoon]

I'm not asking as RadiantCowbells the mafia player

I'm asking as RadiantCowbells the person

And in a situation like this I would do the same for you

Yeah that's cool use out-of-game appeals
not like that's against site-wide rules too.

[RadiantCowbells]

You yourself said that you were pretty likely to be conftown by day 3

You're not playing like that statement was anything other than bullshit

You're the only one who has ever played like it hasn't been the case.

You're the one trying to all in me when I'm guaranteed to die on day 3 if you're actually gonna be IC

All you had to do was wait till nights pass and I'm dead

Funny how you are insistent on making that happen before days start passing and people question your claim more and more

[Elbirn]

I'm not sure what you expect differently from me. I'm trying to sort your alignment to the best of my ability. I'm sorry if I'm not as good at it as you want me to be?

It honestly doesn’t feel like ur trying.
And I am starting to think you hooded me only because you believed I was the only person you could easily convince to vote with you regardless of alignment and time thinking that was ur goal there thinks I don’t want to help you.

Presume you're town. Why does scum-rc give a triple vote to anyone but a scumbuddy?

[RadiantCowbells]

If you think that's an out of game appeal

You think that I'm town

So why are you voting me?

[RadiantCowbells]

It's almost like you're scum and don't actually think I'm scum!

[Varsoon]

The RC I know would re-evaluate and come to a proper read on actual scum instead of insisting on a contentless death-tunnel on town.

Yeah this post makes it fairly clear that I'd expect town RC to re-evaluate and Scum RC to continue to death-tunnel me
Then RC insisted on doing that so
Dude's scum.

[Firebringer]

I'm not sure what you expect differently from me. I'm trying to sort your alignment to the best of my ability. I'm sorry if I'm not as good at it as you want me to be?

It honestly doesn’t feel like ur trying.
And I am starting to think you hooded me only because you believed I was the only person you could easily convince to vote with you regardless of alignment and time thinking that was ur goal there thinks I don’t want to help you.

Presume you're town. Why does scum-rc give a triple vote to anyone but a scumbuddy?

Elbirn, I townread RC.
I am just not voting with him

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm not sure what you expect differently from me. I'm trying to sort your alignment to the best of my ability. I'm sorry if I'm not as good at it as you want me to be?

It honestly doesn’t feel like ur trying.
And I am starting to think you hooded me only because you believed I was the only person you could easily convince to vote with you regardless of alignment and time thinking that was ur goal there thinks I don’t want to help you.

Presume you're town. Why does scum-rc give a triple vote to anyone but a scumbuddy?

Because they know it'll get analyzed? (read: WIFOM)

[RadiantCowbells]

It's almost like town scumreading someone doesn't knee jerk accuse them of essentially trust telling themselves town!

[Varsoon]

Presume you're town. Why does scum-rc give a triple vote to anyone but a scumbuddy?

Role as written only works with town.
I've made that role before.

[RadiantCowbells]

The RC I know would re-evaluate and come to a proper read on actual scum instead of insisting on a contentless death-tunnel on town.

Yeah this post makes it fairly clear that I'd expect town RC to re-evaluate and Scum RC to continue to death-tunnel me
Then RC insisted on doing that so
Dude's scum.

It's almost like

I gave magical town you an opportunity to live to confirm yourself as town when I could have easily lynched you

It's almost like there's no scum motivation in anything I do but you keep calling me scum using cases that make less and less sense

[Varsoon]

If you think that's an out of game appeal

You think that I'm town

Not really.
I think you're scum willing to do anything (even provoke a ban) to get me lynched.

[RadiantCowbells]

If you think that's an out of game appeal

You think that I'm town

Not really.
I think you're scum willing to do anything (even provoke a ban) to get me lynched.

Wow weird I would have thought I wasn't the person who played this game in a manner to eat a ban

[Varsoon]

Town doesn't browbeat town by offering not to lynch them in return for being townread.

[RadiantCowbells]

Oh yeah I wasn't good to know

[Elbirn]

If you think that's an out of game appeal

You think that I'm town

So why are you voting me?

This doesn't logically follow, a scum-rc still has a feud with varsoon...

RC I had a lot easier of a time working with you when you and varsoon werent at each others throats. Can ya put that boy on ignore and look elsewhere? I still dont grasp your mariaR scumread and I dont know that you've ever elaborated on it, can we go there?