In post 172, Nibbui wrote:Skitter my argument is that he would know beforehand that he shouldn't act this way around me if we were partners because the first, and I really mean the first, thing I say in scum PT is to not buss or not interact weirdly. If it's not serious and just a suspicious it's ok though. Also it's apparently him and not me anyway.
I read the recent posts and I don't feel like there was as much to it as I imagined.
This game feels like will be a spicy read though.
fair enough, fair enough; i didn't get at first that you say that literally first thing in every scum pt
and yeah, it's not on your end, it's on his
and no, it's not like a serious push - it was more like something i kinda thought as i read through so i wrote it down because sometimes if i'm around in lategame i go back and read my previous posts to see what i was thinking at various points to make sure i hadn't forgotten anything important; this was sort of a note to future!me in case i was still around and one of you had flipped scum that i had gotten partner-y vibes if that makes sense
the first feels a little bit like you're leaving room for people to talk you out of your vote
and the meta-read felt like a pretty big 180 from where you were pushing earlier - i guess i don't understand the strength of the read here; it feels almost too strong to me
eh i can see where youre coming from with disliking the 180
generally i just put a lot of trust in meta and my original read on him was never actually that strong or off of very much,
but the few things i disliked about him seemed to appear in his village game and not in his wolfing
can you elaborate a bit?
is it just that you think he's more tense/less laid-back as scum or is there more to the meta-read?
his super aggro/confident/interacting with me in the way that he did was what got me to snap w read him but after reading through his v games i thought it's just in his playstyle because he plays like that in most games as v, and then from his w games i just feel like he's definitely the type of wolf to avoid that type of stuff and lay more low
are you saying you think sheep or mastina is town here?
sheepy
ah ok
what are you thinking wrt mastina?
she's shiptoasting which is cliche scum indicative but it's also something she does as town but she's like uniquely less serious as she is as either alignment and she's a little wolfy which is slightly town indicative but she's not wolfy in her usual wolfy way so I'm not really happy putting stock in that
In post 109, sheepsaysmeep wrote:idt i should really be w reading for this but it's kinda fishy that nsg townreads all of the current posting people,
including tw who has like 0 content yet,
and then dislikes nibbui's 33 substantially long posts where he's talked about a lot of stuff for of all things 7 hmmms
You were one to say that I and TW were mostly surely town here, so why do you have a problem with NSG giving him a town read?
I might have more content than him but that's no reason to say that he has "0 content" when you actually is town reading him as well.
I don't understand this part of your post tbh.
it's just pointing out she's basically townreading everyone in thread
ye I also can't really see NSG looking at the thread going "hmm these guys are town but Nibbui is scum manipulating them" and then retaliating against Nibbui with such a wishy washy take kinda holistic gamestate vibe type deal but if she's town I'm not sure what she's doing
In post 177, sheepsaysmeep wrote:his super aggro/confident/interacting with me in the way that he did was what got me to snap w read him but after reading through his v games i thought it's just in his playstyle because he plays like that in most games as v, and then from his w games i just feel like he's definitely the type of wolf to avoid that type of stuff and lay more low
ye check the newbie game we were in together his reads were good and he was technically powertowning but he managed to piss off the entire town so badly he looked like he was openwolfing lmao
are you saying you think sheep or mastina is town here?
sheepy
ah ok
what are you thinking wrt mastina?
she's shiptoasting which is cliche scum indicative but it's also something she does as town but she's like uniquely less serious as she is as either alignment and she's a little wolfy which is slightly town indicative but she's not wolfy in her usual wolfy way so I'm not really happy putting stock in that
i've never played with her
i feel like she's being purposefully abstruse which is kinda like generically scummy but she could be doing it because she's feeling like whimsical or like she wants to be mysterious or something, idk
like it's generically scummy and it's the sort of thing i want to scumread but i think it might not be ai here, i can't tell
i do want to know why she's so certain you're scum tho because i'm not feeling it rn
mastina and I have played together 2? times I think (not discussing alts etc. etc.)
earthbound mafia she incorrectly townread scum!me basically constantly until we NK'd her, she also hard 1v1'd town!Mathdino d1 who was very very obviously town
then in kittymo's encore mafia I incorrectly townread scum!her because I ended up having not much time and nor reading her posts, I was badly overgamed and sheeped Pine on her
the time we've played together on alts doesn't yield very interesting meta and I'm not absolutely sure it was her and I don't believe in alt outing so I won't talk about that.
I'm surprised on how my logic is winning against my feelings by a good margin inside my head here
I might have just changed something very important about my playstyle accidentaly
I'm not sure it's a good thing though because although my feelings are mostly what seems the consensus right now, my logic doesn't point towards that at all
I'm a bit afraid of being a fool by going against consensus honestly but I'm tired of going with the flow as well
In post 190, Nibbui wrote:I think Mastina saying "TW is scum, 100% of the time here" is more alignment indicative than her whole attitude about explaining it or not tbh.
yeah when i saw that my first thought was kinda like:
just how confident are you on that? like if you're that confident try to get people to understand you and make it happen, why are you being all mysterious about a read you're being that confident on?
and what will you do if he flips town because like rn i think that's much more likely?
oh basically mastina pushes a narrative until she either realises it's wrong or decides it's right as both alignments. sorry. that would've been more useful to say earlier
kinda holistic gamestate vibe type deal but if she's town I'm not sure what she's doing
